Premiér Andrej Babiš (ANO) opakuje, že svůj střet zájmů vyřešil vložením Agrofertu do svěřenského fondu. Státní zemědělský intervenční fond (SZIF) se s ním ztotožnil a odblokoval Agrofertu stamilionové dotace, které žádá uhradit z evropského rozpočtu .
EU to ale vidí jinak. Na konci května dorazil do Prahy dopis psaný jménem pěti generálních ředitelství Evropské komise, který zdůrazňoval, že požadavky Bruselu Česko nevyřešilo . Listina obsahovala požadavek – vláda měla do jednoho měsíce expertům Komise poslat jasnou a podloženou právní analýzu, která zdůvodňuje, zda svěřenský fond, do něhož Babiš vložil Agrofert, české i evropské paragrafy proti střetu zájmů splňuje.
Nyní je ale jasné, že se Evropská komise nedočká. Ministerstvo pro místní rozvoj Zuzany Mrázové (ANO), které je za komunikaci s Komisí zodpovědné, ostře formulované žádosti nevyhovělo. Evropské unii napsalo, že oficiálně nemá k dispozici ani klíčový statut svěřenského fondu RSVP Trust, z nějž podle mnohých expertů plyne, že Babiš je s evropskými paragrafy stále v konfliktu .
„K dispozici máme pouze verzi, která se objevila v médiích, přičemž u takového dokumentu nemůžeme potvrdit jeho správnost ani úplnost,“ napsal za českou vládu v odpovědi Evropské komisi vrchní ředitel ministerské sekce fondů EU a mezinárodních vztahů Stanislav Schneidr.
Naráží tak na text statutu, který zveřejnily Seznam Zprávy poté, co se ho premiér pokoušel utajit. Schneidr přitom nijak neobjasňuje, proč si ministerstvo nemohlo ověřenou kopii statutu vyžádat od rejstříkového soudu, kde je uložen.
„Na posouzení nemáme kompetence“
Odpověď ministerstva pokračuje obsáhlým zdůvodněním toho, proč Česko nemůže do Bruselu poslal vyzdrojovaný verdikt, zda premiér skutečně střet zájmů vyřešil.
„Podle Ústavy České republiky lze státní moc uplatňovat jen v případech, v mezích a způsoby, které stanoví zákon. Zákon o střetu zájmů, kompetenční zákon ani jiný právní předpis nebo předpis EU nesvěřují žádnému ústřednímu správnímu úřadu obecné zmocnění k vydání autoritativního nebo závazného stanoviska,“ tvrdí ministerstvo, které vede Mrázová.
„My to analyzovat nemůžeme.“ Z odpovědi Evropské komisi z pera ministerstva pro místní rozvoj.
Zároveň ale dodává, že na základě statutu, který má ministerstvo z médií, se zdá, že nové uspořádání svěřenského fondu RSVP Trust eliminuje výhrady EU proti předchozím svěřenským fondům z let 2017–2021, kterými se Babiš neúspěšně pokoušel svůj střet zájmů vyřešit, když seděl ve vládě naposledy.
Dopis se ale zcela vyhýbá komentování toho, zda nový svěřenský fond splňuje evropské předpisy, na které podle mnohých expertů pravděpodobně jeho parametry narazí.
Co říká utajený statut Babišova fondu?
Experti argumentují, že klíč obsahuje neveřejný statut fondu, který premiér Andrej Babiš tajil. Zveřejnily ho až Seznam Zprávy .
Babiš totiž sice tvrdil, že se navždy vzdal Agrofertu a jeho děti ho dostanou až po jeho smrti, reálně ale už s Babišovým koncem v politice bude fond řídit rada složená z jeho dětí. Těm navíc nic nebrání učinit Babiše správcem fondu, čím by znovu dostal pod kontrolu i Agrofert.
Chceme jasný závěr, psala Komise
Právě o to, aby takovou analýzu Česko poskytlo, přitom Evropské komisi šlo.
„Žádám vás o předání úplného právního posouzení, vypracovaného řídicím orgánem týkajícího se této společnosti v rámci skupiny Agrofert. Toto posouzení by mělo zahrnovat veškeré pracovní dokumenty, hodnoticí tabulky a podpůrné důkazy týkající se souladu se článkem 61 finančního nařízení a českým zákonem o střetu zájmů,“ vypočítal požadavky dopis z Bruselu.
„Dokumentace musí obsahovat jasný a konečný závěr, zda se má za to, že stávající majetkové uspořádání je v souladu s příslušnými právními předpisy Unie a vnitrostátními právními předpisy,“ dodává listina, pod níž je podepsán zástupce generální ředitelky pro regionální politiku Evropské komise Hugo Sobral.
Ministerstvo: možná do konce roku
Ministerstvo pro místní rozvoj požadavek odrazilo i tvrzením, že taková analýza vznikne až ve chvíli, kdy si Agrofert požádá o nějakou dotaci a vypracuje ji poskytovatel peněz.
„Posouzení splnění podmínek žádostí o podporu tedy náleží příslušným poskytovatelům, a to incidenčně pro každé řízení a s ohledem na konkrétní okolnosti případu,“ dodal v reakci vrchní ředitel Schneidr.
Evropská komise ovšem už v původním květnovém dopise jednu takovou žádost o dotaci identifikovala. Podaly ji Kostelecké uzeniny do programu, za který ručí ministerstvo průmyslu Karla Havlíčka (ANO). I v tomto případě vysoce postavený úředník Sobral do měsíce požadoval analýzu, zda konkrétně tuto dotaci s ohledem na případný střet zájmů Andreje Babiše může firma z holdingu Agrofert dostat.
Ani v tomto případě se ale Evropská komise jen tak nedočká. „Vzhledem k tomu, že dosud není ukončeno dodání podkladů od žadatele, nelze dopředu posuzovat kroky následující. Jakmile to bude relevantní, řídicí orgán otázku střetu zájmů posoudí a výsledné posouzení Evropské komisi poskytne. Předpokládaný časový rámec těc…
Read the full article at Seznam Zprávy →📄Source document: European Commission→13 reports
Seznam ZprávyIndependentCenter2 days agoThe Czech government has refused to provide evidence to the European Commission regarding whether Prime Minister Andrej Babiš has resolved potential conflicts of interest by transferring his Agrofert company into a trust fund. The EU requested a clear legal analysis from the Czech government within a month, but the government stated it does not have access to the official statute of the trust fund, citing only media-published versions as unavailable for verification.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the Czech government's position and the EU's request without overtly favoring either side. It includes direct quotes from officials and references the EU's formal communication, maintaining neutrality in framing the dispute.
Aktuálně.czIndependentCenter2 days agoThe article discusses Prime Minister Andrej Babiš's response to criticisms regarding a proposed amendment to the conflict of interest law, which would allow his business group Agrofert to receive state subsidies without restrictions. Critics argue this could benefit both Babiš and Agrofert, raising concerns about potential conflicts of interest. The article notes that Babiš has been focusing on anti-drug policies and other issues recently, possibly diverting attention from the Agrofert matter.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both Babiš's perspective and criticism from opponents, including legal experts, without overtly favoring either side. It frames the issue neutrally, highlighting concerns about potential conflicts of interest while also noting Babiš's recent focus on other policy areas.
Official sources cited
- government Babiš's comments at the press conference
- other Advokát Aleš Rozehnal's statement
Seznam ZprávyIndependentCenter3 days ago The European Anti-Fraud Office has launched an investigation into the possible conflict of interest of the grandfatherThe European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) has begun investigating potential conflicts of interest involving Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babiš. The investigation focuses on a trust fund into which Babiš placed his Agrofert holding, claiming this resolved any conflict of interest. This follows previous investigations by OLAF into Babiš's 'Čapí hnízdo' case, where he was suspected of misusing EU funds. OLAF confirmed it is currently examining the matter but declined to provide further comments. OLAF's current head, Petr Klement, previously worked as a prosecutor specializing in economic crime.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information without overtly biased language or selective sourcing. It reports on an ongoing investigation by OLAF, quotes official responses, and provides background on past cases involving Babiš. There is no clear ideological framing or emphasis on one side over another
Deník NIndependentLeft5 days agoA private clinic owned by Prime Minister Andrej Babiš, Iscare, has access to free consultations with doctors at the Faculty Hospital in Prague's Vinohrady. Following an alert from the newspaper Deník N, the clinic began sending 330,000 Czech crowns annually to the hospital for student meals. The agreement, reached in March, allows Iscare to use expert consultations from the public healthcare facility without paying hourly rates. Other private clinics typically pay based on hours worked. The hospital is now revising the terms of cooperation, including potential additional agreements.
Bias read (Left): The article highlights a potential conflict of interest involving the prime minister's private clinic receiving benefits from a public institution. It emphasizes the unusual nature of the arrangement compared to other private clinics, which typically pay for such services. This framing suggests a批判性
Official sources cited
- government Fakultní nemocnice Královské Vinohrady
- press release Deník N
Novinky.czIndependentCenter7 days agoThe article discusses a proposed amendment to the Czech conflict of interest law, introduced by a group of MPs led by ANO deputy leader Radim Vondraček. The amendment would allow members of the government to participate in decisions affecting their companies' profits, among other changes. Current Prime Minister Andrej Babiš no longer holds the Agrofert holding, which he transferred to a trust fund, according to Justice Minister Martina Šcherbáková. However, the European Commission has not yet clarified whether this transfer resolves his potential conflict of interest. The opposition criticizes
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the government's position, as stated by Justice Minister Šcherbáková, and the opposition's criticism, including comments from former PM Petr Fiala. It does not exhibit clear bias toward either side, providing balanced perspectives without overtly favoring one over the other
Official sources cited
- government Justice Minister Martina Šcherbáková
- government Radim Vondraček
- government Petr Fiala
Novinky.czIndependentCenter7 days ago BRIEFLY: Babis says he has given up Agrofert and resolved the conflict of interests. Why does the EU doubt it?Andrej Babiš claimed he has resolved his conflict of interest regarding Agrofert by transferring shares into a trust fund. However, media investigations raise doubts about whether he and his family have completely disassociated from the company. The European Commission also questions this resolution and it remains uncertain if the Union will continue funding companies under the Agrofert holding.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both Babiš's claims and the skepticism from media and the European Commission without overtly favoring either side. It does not use emotionally charged language or selectively present information to support one perspective over another.
Deník NIndependentLeft11 days ago The conflict of interest news is a wake-up call for optimistsThe article discusses proposed changes to conflict-of-interest rules that would benefit Andrej Babiš, the leader of the Czech government. It criticizes these changes as legitimizing an oligarchic style of governance. The text highlights Babiš's longstanding ties to Agrofert, one of the largest corporate conglomerates in the country, and argues that even with the current arrangement involving a trust fund, Babiš remains closely connected to the company through his children. The article suggests this situation represents a significant anomaly in democratic principles.
Bias read (Left): The article uses critical language toward the proposed changes to conflict-of-interest rules, frames them as legitimizing an 'oligarchic' form of governance, and emphasizes concerns over democratic principles. It also critiques Babiš’s continued influence over Agrofert despite the trust fund setup,
Deník NIndependentRight11 days ago Grandma has it checked out from multiple sides, Agrofert could take back, says an expert on the proposal to limit the conflict of interestThe article discusses a proposed amendment to the Czech conflict of interest law, which has been criticized for benefiting Prime Minister Andrej Babiš. Legal expert Petr Bezouška argues that the draft law clears Babiš of any conflicts of interest, allowing him to retain control over assets like Agrofert through the RSVP Trust fund. The amendment reduces the time frame for reclaiming improperly paid subsidies from ten years to four, retroactively applying this change. This could mean the Czech Republic would no longer be able to reclaim misallocated European Union funds from before 2022.
Bias read (Right): The article frames the proposed law as favoring Premier Babiš, suggesting it benefits his position and allows him to retain control over assets like Agrofert. It highlights concerns raised by an expert who criticizes the law’s wording and implications, implying a negative view of the government’s ul
Official sources cited
- statement Petr Bezouška interview
Seznam ZprávyIndependentLeft12 days ago Deza from Agrofertu lost a billion dollars to cheap competition from Asia.The chemical company Deza, part of the Agrofert holding owned by Prime Minister Andrej Babiš, reported a record loss of over one billion Czech crowns last year due to high energy prices and cheap Asian competition. The firm specializes in processing coal tar and crude benzene, producing materials used in industries such as aluminum production, construction, and tire manufacturing. A spokesperson noted that Europe is increasingly recognizing the importance of its chemical industry amid challenges from Asia.
Bias read (Left): The article explicitly links the company's financial struggles to the impact of the war in Ukraine and mentions Prime Minister Andrej Babiš directly, implying criticism of his economic policies through the lens of corporate performance. It also frames European industrial policy as being challenged,
Official sources cited
- organisation Statement from Agrofert Spokesperson Pavel Heřmanský
Deník NIndependentRight12 days ago The government's lawmakers want to change the conflict of interest law.Members of three governing parties have quietly proposed changes to the conflict of interest law, which could allow Agrofert to access direct subsidies. The amendment would also shorten the period for reclaiming subsidies and narrow restrictions related to conflicts of interest to only apply to specific ministries. The proposal, published today on the website of the Chamber of Deputies, includes several key changes. According to the proposal, conflicts of interest would no longer apply to so-called 'eligibility' or direct subsidies, which are based on objective criteria such as the size of far
Bias read (Right): The article frames the proposed changes to the conflict of interest law in a manner that suggests they benefit specific entities like Agrofert, implying potential favoritism without providing balanced counterarguments or alternative perspectives.
Aktuálně.czIndependentCenter12 days ago Agrofert received a grant of 204 million crowns in May.Agrofert received agricultural subsidies totaling 204 million Czech crowns in May. However, it remains unclear whether the European Union will reimburse these funds. The EU is currently investigating potential conflicts of interest involving former Agrofert owner and current Prime Minister Andrej Babiš (ANO). Babiš transferred shares of Agrofert into a trust fund called RSVP Trust in February, claiming this resolves any conflict of interest. The Czech Agricultural Insurance Company (Češpiva) reported that a regular report was submitted to the European Commission for 21.3 million euros (about 5
Bias read (Center): The article presents facts without overtly biased language or selective sourcing. It reports on an ongoing investigation by the EU regarding potential conflicts of interest involving a prominent political figure but does not take a clear stance or emphasize one side over another.
Official sources cited
- organisation Češpiva
- organisation European Commission
Aktuálně.czIndependentCenter12 days ago Agrofertu subsidiaries refuse to reimburse the support received in Babiš' first termThe Czech state fund has initiated a prejudicial phase of enforcement proceedings against subsidiaries of Agrofert, demanding the return of subsidies received during Andrej Babiš's first period in office. The fund has not specified exact amounts or deadlines for repayment. Agrofert denies any wrongdoing, stating it followed legal procedures and is prepared to defend itself in court if necessary. European Commission and domestic courts have previously concluded that Babiš did not resolve conflicts of interest during his first tenure, maintaining influence over Agrofert through two trust funds.武
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives without overt bias. It includes statements from both the fund and Agrofert, providing a balanced view of the situation. There is no clear favoring of one side over the other.
Official sources cited
- organisation Barbora Šenfeldová, spokesperson for the fund
- organisation Pavel Heřmanský, spokesperson for Agrofert
Novinky.czIndependentCenter12 days ago Volunteer your money back, the fund calls on 28 Agrofertu companies.The Czech state fund has called on 28 companies linked to Agrofert to voluntarily return subsidies, citing potential conflicts of interest. The fund has initiated a prejudicial phase of the enforcement process. Agrofert denies any wrongdoing, stating it followed legal procedures and is prepared to defend itself in court if necessary. The European Commission and domestic courts have previously concluded that former Prime Minister Andrej Babis did not resolve his conflict of interest during his first term, maintaining influence over Agrofert through two trust funds. Babis recently transferred Ag
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives without overtly favoring one side. It includes statements from both the fund and Agrofert, providing a balanced view of the situation regarding the subsidy dispute and conflict of interest allegations.
CZ