Les Italiens ont-ils vraiment inventé le cola ?

A German magazine has raised questions about whether Italian monks might have invented the precursor to Coca-Cola nearly a century before the American beverage giant launched its iconic product. The inquiry centers around documents discovered within a monastery in Florence, Italy, which describe a tonic containing ingredients similar to those used in the famous soft drink. According to the findings, the formula includes colanuts and coca leaves, key components of the original Coca-Cola recipe, though the connection to the modern drink remains unclear. The discovery was made by Brother Russo, the head of the monastery, who reportedly stumbled upon old advertising materials while reviewing historical records. He began examining documents stored within the cloister more closely after this initial finding. According to Russo, there is no direct evidence linking the formula described in these documents to the mixture developed by John Stith Pemberton in the United States during the late 19th century. The document, which appears to date back several decades, describes a “strengthening wine elixir” known as Elixir vinoso ricostituente. This tonic, according to the text, was intended to alleviate physical and mental exhaustion, headaches, and weaknesses caused by aging or extraordinary exertion. The composition listed on the yellowed paper includes 30 grams of colanuts and 10 grams of Bolivian coca leaves steeped in one liter of alcohol. These ingredients were allegedly brought to Tuscany by missionaries from South America. The exact formula for Coca-Cola has long been shrouded in secrecy. Periodically, claims surface suggesting that someone has uncovered the recipe, but none have proven true so far. According to the company, only a small number of individuals inside the corporation know the precise formulation. These employees are bound by strict confidentiality agreements, and their identities remain undisclosed. Coca-Cola has previously addressed speculation regarding the secrecy of its formula. A spokesperson stated that the few people who possess knowledge of the complete recipe are legally obligated to maintain silence. Furthermore, the company has humorously noted that some stories suggest the formula is known to just two people, who are supposedly kept apart to prevent them from conspiring together. However, such tales are considered part of folklore rather than factual accounts. The discovery in Florence adds another layer to the ongoing debate surrounding the origins of Coca-Cola. While the connection between the Italian elixir and the modern soft drink is uncertain, the presence of similar ingredients raises intriguing questions. Historians and researchers will likely scrutinize the documents further to determine whether they represent an independent development or a possible influence on the eventual creation of Coca-Cola. The monastery’s archives contain a wealth of historical information, much of which remains unexplored. Researchers interested in the history of beverages and medicinal tonics may find additional insights within these collections. The Italian government and cultural institutions have expressed interest in preserving and studying such historical artifacts, recognizing their potential value to both scientific research and public understanding of historical practices. Brother Russo has indicated that the monastery plans to collaborate with historians and experts in pharmacology to analyze the documents thoroughly. Any new findings could contribute significantly to the broader narrative of how traditional remedies evolved into commercial products. Meanwhile, Coca-Cola continues to guard the secrecy of its formula, maintaining that the company's legacy is built on innovation and quality control rather than historical claims.