ON
← Back to feed
GermanyTechnology2 days ago

Trump's deal with Iran: Close to a nightmare scenario

The article discusses Donald Trump's agreement with Iran, highlighting concerns from Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu. It notes that Trump, adhering to his 'America First' policy, prioritizes domestic interests ahead of the congressional election over Israel's security concerns. From Israel's perspective, the deal is nearly a nightmare scenario, allowing the Iranian regime to remain in power with strengthened Revolutionary Guard, receiving billions in funding, retaining ballistic missiles, and halting operations in Lebanon. The fate of Iran's nuclear program remains unclear. The article also对比

"Ships of the World, start your engines," US President Donald Trump said while announcing a deal with Iran to end the conflict he launched along with Israel more than three months ago.

The online post on Sunday also saw Trump "fully authorize" the toll-free reopening of the Strait of Hormuz.

"Let the oil flow!" he added.

The US and Iran are due to sign a memorandum of understanding (MoU) in Geneva later this week. With the details still under wraps , Trump later said Hormuz would "fully reopen" only after the deal is signed.

US, Iran announce initial 'peace deal'

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

But unconfirmed reports on the MoU published in pro-regime Iranian media claim that Tehran's future role in Hormuz is still up for negotiation. Fars news agency reported that "Iranian-Omani sovereignty over the Strait of Hormuz" had been added to negotiations at the last minute, while claiming that the US had "accepted" that fees would be paid to Iran.

When asked for clarification on Monday, US Vice President JD Vance told CNBC news outlet that Washington's "expectation is that the strait is going to be opened in a toll-free way for the long term," adding, "that's the sort of thing that we're going to figure out in these technical negotiations."

Exposing the limits of US power

Opacity aside, it is clear that the US is not able to dictate the terms regarding the Strait of Hormuz to Iran, despite Washington's overwhelming military strength.

Moreover, Iran's ability to use drones, mines and small boats to shut down free movement of shipping has shed uncomfortable light on the role of US power in protecting freedom of navigation and ensuring free trade.

"The Iran war showed America's exceptional military prowess — and its inability to convert those capabilities into anything resembling strategic victory," said Rebecca Lissner, senior fellow for US foreign policy and director of the Future of American Strategy Initiative at the US Council on Foreign Relations (CFR).

"This is a blow to America's image as a global superpower and undercuts its status as a guarantor of freedom of navigation. This war has left the United States in a weaker position than when the war began," she told DW.

Iran's new leverage

Trump laid out an array of objectives when launching the war, including the "annihilation" of Iran's conventional navy. This one objective, at least, seems to have been met — the Center for International and Strategic Studies (CSIS) has assessed that "Iran lost the majority of its naval capability in less than 10 days."

But Iran didn't need a conventional navy to hold shipping in Hormuz hostage. And its drone-based asymmetric strikes on Gulf energy facilities proved an effective deterrence against US escalation. Tehran's proxies in Yemen and Lebanon also remain a threat.

The US-Israeli airstrikes have also taken out much of the Islamic Republic's leadership and degraded its military. At the same time, the conflict has made life much harder for ordinary Iranians, who faced a brutal crackdown for protesting against the regime just weeks before the war. Trump has not mentioned their fate, nor the idea of "regime change" since the first weeks of the conflict.

And regionally, ties between Tehran and neighboring Gulf states have also been degraded, portending protracted regional instability. Gulf states have also been left questioning the reliability of the US security umbrella after their civilian infrastructure and energy facilities were left vulnerable.

Why Saudi Arabia is redrawing its global alliances

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video

Who holds the keys to Hormuz?

Still, the key strategic issue moving forward is the Strait of Hormuz, with the world waiting to see if the US will grant Iran even partial control over shipping through the waterway.

"Even if the deal succeeds in reopening the strait, Iran now has leverage it did not have before," said Lissner, who served as deputy national security adviser to former US Vice President Kamala Harris.

"The United States has shown itself to be unable or unwilling to coerce Iran into reopening the strait, which means the world will live with the risk that Iran can close the strait again at will," she added.

And with the Iranian regime having blocked the world's energy supplies for months , it remains unclear why they would hand over that leverage without getting something in return.

One widely reported part of the MoU is Iran receiving some $12 billion (€10.34 billion) of its frozen funds before the nuclear talks even begin, in what would amount to payment for reopening the strait. The US denies this.

And as  global markets breathe a sigh of relief , there are still doubts that shipping through Hormuz will ever return to normal .

"This deal seems likely to effectively codify Iranian control over the strait by…

Read the full article at Deutsche Welle (English)

2 reports

Frankfurter Allgemeine (FAZ)Independent🔒Center2 days ago
Trump's deal with Iran: Close to a nightmare scenario

The article discusses Donald Trump's agreement with Iran, highlighting concerns from Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu. It notes that Trump, adhering to his 'America First' policy, prioritizes domestic interests ahead of the congressional election over Israel's security concerns. From Israel's perspective, the deal is nearly a nightmare scenario, allowing the Iranian regime to remain in power with strengthened Revolutionary Guard, receiving billions in funding, retaining ballistic missiles, and halting operations in Lebanon. The fate of Iran's nuclear program remains unclear. The article also对比

Bias read (Center): The article provides a factual summary of events without overtly favoring any side. It presents information objectively, focusing on the implications of Trump's policies and their impact on international relations.

Deutsche Welle (English)State / PublicCenter5 days ago
Does the Iran war diminish US superpower status?

The article discusses recent developments regarding a potential agreement between the United States and Iran aimed at ending hostilities in the region, particularly focusing on the Strait of Hormuz. U.S. President Donald Trump announced plans to fully open the strait to oil traffic, emphasizing 'let the oil flow.' A memorandum of understanding (MoU) is set to be signed in Geneva, though details remain undisclosed. Unconfirmed reports suggest that Iran's role in the strait, including potential tolls, is still under negotiation. U.S. Vice President JD Vance stated that the expectation is for the

Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information without overtly biased language or framing. It reports on statements from both U.S. officials and Iranian media without taking a clear stance or using loaded terminology.