America’s 250th anniversary compared with its 200th: Measuring the mood in 1976 and now

Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.

We need your help.

More Info

America’s 250th anniversary compared with its 200th: Measuring the mood in 1976 and now

History

250th U.S. anniversary

A parade of tall ships leaving Newport, Rhode Island, for New York on July 1, 1976. (AP)

A country in a sour mood. Inflation and gasoline prices soaring. A culture war raging. A president with sagging approval ratings.

America at 250? Actually, America at 200 and 250.

As the United States celebrates the 250th anniversary of its founding, a look back five decades to 1976 — the year of the nation’s bicentennial — reveals notable similarities with today.

Substitute Richard Nixon for Donald Trump, Vietnam for Iran and Watergate for using the Justice Department to reward friends and punish enemies and you can see a pretty fair resemblance between 1976 and 2026.

"The parallels are eerie: international conflict, domestic strife, political turmoil, partisan division and economic instability," said Marc Stein, a San Francisco State University historian.

As the 250th approached, we asked a handful of historians to describe their sense of the national mood during both celebrations, and how the commemorations were similar and different.

In both 1976 and 2026, the U.S. was celebrating an anniversary amid "major crises of confidence about national values, vices, and virtues, and about the past, present, and future of national greatness," Stein said.

The zeitgeist during the two periods diverged in some ways, notably in the degree of partisan polarization, which is generally considered much higher today.

How did the nation celebrate the bicentennial?

In recent weeks, several musical acts pulled out of a series of 250th anniversary concerts scheduled on the National Mall. The performers’ complaint that the event had become politicized was underscored when Trump countered by saying he might hold a political rally instead.

Other 250th anniversary events, many organized by the Freedom 250 group with close ties to Trump, include a UFC event on the White House lawn and a religious event on the National Mall.

A top-down presidential approach is not entirely new for such celebrations; it’s also how the bicentennial developed.

Planning began a decade ahead of time in 1966, with President Lyndon B. Johnson creating a bipartisan commission to organize the commemoration. Johnson wanted a World’s Fair, an echo of the 1876 centennial in Philadelphia. But within two years, Johnson was out of office.

When Nixon became president, he appointed "political cronies and longtime supporters" to the commission, wrote M.J. Rymsza-Pawlowska, an American University historian and author , in an essay on the bicentennial.

Before long, she wrote, critics said Nixon was framing the bicentennial in ways that centered himself and his 1972 campaign. Some said the committee was "corrupt and unwieldy." Others, including the Black Panther Party and the American Indian Movement, said the effort was paying scant attention to the history of racial and ethnic minorities. Alternative bicentennial organizing committees emerged.

Eventually, the Nixon administration responded to the criticism by shifting gears, initiating a more hands-off process of handing out money to local groups without strict federal mandates. The idea was to empower local communities to undertake historical projects meaningful to their own communities.

While some activities were national in scope — including a parade of tall ships, a reverse wagon train from west to east and a July 4 fireworks show — the majority were hyperlocal. They ranged from the restoration of a railroad station in Ogden, Utah, to preservation of a historic one-room schoolhouse at Bowling Green State University in Ohio and a Seafood Heritage Trail in Biloxi, Mississippi.

A team of oxen hauls cannon into Cambridge, Massachusetts, in a re-enactment of a march 200 years earlier from Fort Ticonderoga, New York, on Jan. 28, 1976. (AP)

A study by the General Accounting Office , the former name of Congress’ investigative arm, found "1,766 historical re-enactments, beauty pageants, tree plantings and an "oldtime fiddlers’ contest," David Skinner, a former editor at the National Endowment for the Humanities, wrote recently for The Wall Street Journal. In contrast to today, bicentennial imagery was everywhere, including the most unexpected places; several archival collections attest to the wide variety of consumer items stamped with bicentennial themes, from popcorn buckets to dry cleaner hangers and diaper bags.

The mood of historical discovery was evident in a range of activities and offerings, from research into family ancestry to television blockbusters like the slavery saga "Roots."

Rymsza-Pawlowska told PolitiFact that the way the bicentennial celebration developed — more pluribus than unum — fit the nation’s mood. Beginning in the 1960…