Abramović openly about the conflict in the Constitutional Court: "It is not our goal to force the issue"Constitutional Court judge Andrej Abramovic appeared on N1 television to discuss a procedural dispute with Court President Frane Stanicic regarding audio recordings of sessions. Abramovic argued that decisions on recording protocols require a two-thirds majority vote by all judges, rather than being imposed unilaterally by the president. He criticized the current approach as procedurally flawed, comparing it to buying a car before obtaining a driver's license. The judge emphasized that his colleagues seek lawful procedures rather than personal conflict, stating that suspending collective decision-making leads to autocracy. Abramovic maintained that the issue concerns consistent application of the law and proper judicial authority.
Bias read (Progressive): The article exclusively features a dissenting judge criticizing the court president's unilateral actions, using strong normative language like 'autocracy' and 'authority' to frame the institutional conflict as a fight against overreach.
The Constitutional Court opened part of the sessions for the media and journalistsThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has decided to open some of its sessions to the media and journalists, marking a significant step toward greater transparency. This decision was made during a session attended by seven out of ten judges, where they unanimously supported the content of the Regulation on audio recording of sessions, expert meetings, and board meetings of the Constitutional Court, as well as the authority of the court president to publish these recordings. The regulation, which comes into effect tomorrow, is available on the court’s website. The court emphasized this move increases transparency while maintaining conditions necessary for independent judicial decision-making. However, three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have boycotted recent sessions, citing concerns over the unilateral introduction of audio recordings without formal approval or legal basis. The court president, Frane Staničić, rejected these claims, stating the practice was introduced due to previous disagreements over the reliability of minutes and that all judges were informed of it.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the court's decision to increase transparency and the dissenting views of three judges, providing balanced quotes from both sides without overtly favoring one perspective.
The Constitutional Court opened part of the sessions for the media: Three judges did not come to the sessionThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has decided to open some of its sessions to the media, marking a significant step toward greater transparency. This decision was made during a session attended by seven out of ten judges, where they unanimously supported regulations regarding audio recordings of sessions and the publication rights of the court president. However, three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, refused to attend the session, citing concerns over the unilateral introduction of audio recording practices without formal approval or legal basis. They have previously stated their opposition to such practices, arguing they violate procedural norms. The court president, Frane Staničić, defended the practice, stating it was introduced due to past disagreements over the reliability of minutes and emphasized that all judges must participate in decisions. Meanwhile, the National Assembly remains without an agreement on the selection of new constitutional judges.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the court's decision to increase transparency and the dissenting judges' objections, quoting both sides without overtly favoring one perspective.
The Constitutional Court opened part of the sessions to the mediaThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has decided to open some of its sessions to the media, marking a significant step toward greater transparency. This decision was made during a session attended by seven out of ten judges, where they unanimously supported regulations regarding audio recordings of sessions and the publication of such recordings. The court emphasized that this move increases transparency while maintaining conditions necessary for independent judicial decisions. However, three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have boycotted recent sessions, citing concerns over the unilateral introduction of audio recording practices without formal approval or legal basis. They have called for precise regulation of these recordings through amendments to the court’s procedural rules, along with safeguards against misuse and pressure. Meanwhile, the court president, Frane Staničić, defended the practice, stating it was introduced due to previous disagreements over the reliability of minutes and that all judges were aware of it.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the court's decision to increase transparency and the dissenting judges' objections without overtly favoring either side, using balanced language and quoting multiple perspectives.
The Constitutional Court made an important decision, but only moments later - another twist!The Constitutional Court of Croatia has decided to open some of its sessions to the media, marking a significant step toward transparency. This decision was made unanimously by seven judges present during the session, though three judges, Andrej Abramović, Lovorka Kušan, and Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, did not attend. The court approved a regulation regarding audio recordings of meetings and sessions, allowing the president of the court to publish it. However, the absence of three judges raised concerns over the legitimacy of the decision, as they argued that such regulations require a two-thirds majority of all judges, which was not met. The issue stems from ongoing disputes over the recording of meetings and sessions, with some judges opposing the lack of formal legal basis for these recordings.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the court’s decision and the dissenting views of three judges without overtly favoring either side, maintaining a balanced tone.
The Constitutional Court introduces recording sessions and opens them to the publicThe President of Croatia’s Constitutional Court, Frane Stanišić, announced that the court has adopted decisions to introduce audio recording of hearings and open sessions to the public. These measures were implemented to resolve a multi-week internal blockage of the court’s operations. The decisions were passed by seven out of ten judges, while three colleagues who oppose audio recording did not attend the session. Stanišić stated that the rules regarding recordings take effect immediately and that the court will now allow media access to its proceedings. He emphasized that majority decisions bind all members of the collegial body, despite the absence of dissenting judges.
Bias read (Center): The report relies exclusively on direct quotes from the court president describing procedural steps and majority voting, presenting the institutional conflict neutrally without external commentary or loaded adjectives.
Seven of the constitutional judges voted to record the sessions, three opposing it did not take placeThe President of Croatia’s Constitutional Court, Frane Staničić, announced that seven judges unanimously adopted a regulation permitting audio recording of court sessions and allowing media access to these proceedings. This decision was made despite the absence of three judges who oppose the recordings, arguing that such measures require amendments to the court’s procedural rules rather than a simple internal regulation. Staničić stated that the majority vote binds all members of the collegial body and emphasized that the new rules aim to resolve previous disputes over meeting minutes. The absent judges had previously sent a letter proposing conditions for their participation, including open debate on transparency, but they did not attend the session where the regulation was finalized.
Bias read (Center): The article neutrally reports the conflict by presenting both the president’s justification for the majority decision and the dissenting judges’ legal objections regarding procedural requirements.
The Constitutional Court will finally open at least part of its sessions to the publicThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has finally decided to open some of its sessions to the public after years of closed-door proceedings since 2003. This decision comes amid growing calls for transparency and accountability within the judiciary. Civil society and the public have long been concerned about the lack of openness in the court’s operations. The move marks a significant step toward greater public access to judicial processes, though details about which sessions will be open remain unclear.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the decision neutrally, citing public demand for transparency without overtly favoring any political side or using biased language.
President of the USUD: "At the meeting, we unanimously adopted two conclusions"...The President of the Croatian Constitutional Court, Frane Stanišić, announced that the court unanimously adopted two resolutions during a recent session aimed at resolving internal blockages. The first resolution approves regulations regarding audio recording of hearings, which Stanišić stated he prepared and was authorized to publish by the seven judges present, constituting a majority. The second resolution grants media access to future court sessions. Stanišić noted that recordings have been ongoing since October 1 and that the new rules would take effect immediately after publication. He addressed the absence of three dissenting judges who oppose audio recording, stating that collegial bodies operate by majority vote and that their decision binds all members, despite his invitation for them to discuss the matter.
Bias read (Center): The report relies exclusively on direct quotes from the court president describing procedural decisions, presenting the institutional perspective without independent verification or critical commentary on the legitimacy of bypassing absent judges.
The judges responded in conflict: 'If I see something is against the law, I can't do it'Three constitutional judges in Croatia, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have publicly stated they will not participate in meetings or sessions that are illegally recorded. This comes amid internal conflict within the Constitutional Court over the legality of recording sessions. Judge Abramović emphasized that the court’s work must follow legal procedures and expressed frustration that his proposed compromise, holding meetings in soundproof rooms, was rejected. The president of the Constitutional Court, Frane Staničić, announced new rules for opening sessions to the public and allowing media access, but noted that some matters remain confidential. He criticized the judges’ refusal to engage with media and reiterated the need to balance transparency with privacy.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the judges' concerns about illegal recordings and the court president's push for greater transparency, without overtly favoring either side.
The Constitutional Court today faces a crucial decision: Will the sessions be open to the public?The Constitutional Court of Croatia faces a critical decision regarding whether its sessions will be open to the public. Three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have refused to attend meetings where audio recordings are made without legal basis, citing concerns over privacy, potential misuse of recordings, and pressure from within the institution. They demand clearer rules for audio recording, guarantees against abuse, and direct access for journalists to sessions. President of the court, Frane Staničić, rejects these claims, stating the practice was introduced due to past disputes over minutes' accuracy and that all judges were informed. He supports greater transparency but insists all judges must participate in decisions. The court has been operating with only ten of thirteen judges since 2003, leading to unresolved cases and increased pressure.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the judges' concerns and the president's rebuttal without overtly favoring either side, using balanced language and quoting multiple perspectives.
The Constitutional Court decides on the audio recording of the debate while threatening the accumulated objectsThe Constitutional Court of Croatia is facing internal conflict over the practice of audio recording sessions, which three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have publicly refused to participate in, citing concerns about legality and potential misuse of recordings. They argue that the recordings were introduced unilaterally without legal basis or formal decision by the court. In contrast, President of the Constitutional Court Frane Staničić defends the practice, stating it was implemented due to past disagreements over the accuracy of minutes and that all judges were informed of it. He emphasizes the need for all judges to return to sessions to make any formal decisions. The three judges have conditioned their return on precise regulation of the recordings through amendments to the court’s procedural rules, stronger safeguards against abuse, and direct invitations for journalists to attend sessions. The issue of transparency has been a longstanding concern since the court closed its sessions to the media in 2003. The situation is further complicated by the court operating in a reduced composition, with only ten of the thirteen expected judges currently serving, leading to delays and increased pressure.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives of the dispute without overtly favoring one side, using balanced language and quoting both the dissenting judges and the court president.
The Constitutional Tribunal decides on the recording of sittings and their opening to the publicThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has begun a session to decide on the controversial audio recording of meetings and the potential opening of its proceedings to the public, aiming to resolve internal conflicts within the court. Three judges, Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, publicly stated they refuse to participate in sessions that are illegally recorded, citing the lack of legal basis for such recordings and concerns over data storage and misuse. They claim they faced pressure due to their disagreement. On the other hand, President of the Constitutional Court Frane Staničić rejects these claims, stating the practice was introduced due to previous disagreements over the accuracy of minutes and that all judges were informed. While Staničić supports greater transparency, he insists that any formal decisions require all judges to return to work. The three judges have conditioned their return on precise regulation of audio recordings through amendments to the procedural rules, stronger safeguards against abuse, and direct invitations for journalists to attend sessions. The issue of transparency has been under public scrutiny for years, as the court’s sessions have been closed to the media since 2003. The situation is further complicated by the court operating in a reduced composition, with only ten of the thirteen expected judges currently serving, leading to unresolved cases and additional pressure on the institution.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives of the dispute without overtly favoring one side, using balanced language and quoting multiple parties involved.
The Constitutional Tribunal decides on the recording of sittings and the opening of proceedings to the publicThe Constitutional Court of Croatia has convened to resolve an internal crisis regarding the audio recording of sessions and the potential opening of court proceedings to the public. Three judges, Andrej Abramovic, Sanja Bezbradica Jelavic, and Lovorka Kusan, recently refused to participate in meetings, arguing that the introduction of audio recordings was unilateral, lacked legal basis, and posed risks regarding data storage and misuse. They stated they faced pressure due to their dissent and demanded specific amendments to the rules of procedure, guarantees against abuse, and direct access for journalists before returning to work. President Frane Stanicic rejected these claims, stating that the practice was introduced to address previous disputes over the reliability of minutes and that all members were aware of it. He emphasized his support for transparency but insisted that formal decisions require the participation of all judges, citing a 2020 decision that explicitly barred media presence during sessions. The situation is further complicated by the fact that the court is currently operating with only ten of its thirteen designated judges, leading to a backlog of cases while the parliament fails to agree on new appointments.
Bias read (Center): The article presents conflicting viewpoints from both the dissenting judges and the court president using balanced attribution verbs like 'claims' and 'rejects', without favoring either side.
The court made two decisions: the sessions will be recorded, part of the work open to the media.The Constitutional Court of Croatia is holding a session to resolve a multi-week crisis regarding audio recording of its meetings and the opening of proceedings to the public. Three judges have refused to participate since October 27, arguing that audio recording lacks legal basis and requires a formal decision rather than implicit consent. President Frane Staničić maintains that recordings began on October 1 and asserts that all judges must attend for decisions to be valid, while criticizing the three dissenting judges for hindering the institution's work. The dissenting judges claim they face pressure during sessions and demand media presence before participating. Deputy President Maša Marochini Zrinski stated she cannot predict the outcome but believes the current session cannot be open to the public due to prior collective decisions. The court has operated with ten judges since April after a reduction from thirteen, with future appointments depending on a parliamentary agreement between the ruling coalition and opposition.
Bias read (Center): The article presents direct quotes and positions from both the court president and the dissenting judges, maintaining a balanced tone without editorializing or favoring one side over the other.