Croatia🏛️ PoliticsConservativeOverlooked by progressives
Three judges have refused to work under video recording, and the president, Frane Staničić, has stated: "The court will function very poorly."
The President of the Constitutional Court of Croatia, Frane Staničić, stated in an interview that the court’s operations are severely hindered because three judges refuse to participate in working groups unless audio recording of sessions is discontinued. Staničić defended the introduction of audio recordings as necessary to ensure the reliability of transcripts, particularly after issues arose during the determination of the court panel in May. He rejected claims by Judge Andrej Abramović that access to recordings was denied, noting that all judges can listen to them and requests for copies are being considered. While acknowledging he lacks mechanisms to force compliance, Staničić criticized the dissenting judges for choosing to deepen conflict rather than protect citizens’ rights. He announced plans to schedule a session by mid-November and proposed greater transparency, including open sessions, threatening to publicly name any judges who oppose sharing recordings with the public.
The President of Croatia’s Constitutional Court, Frane Staničić, warned on Wednesday that the institution will function with significant difficulty after three judges refused to participate in court sessions due to the introduction of audio recording. Speaking during an interview with the television program RTL Danas, Staničić stated that he was deeply sorry that some colleagues had decided to cease providing protection to citizens. He attributed the operational strain directly to the refusal of specific judges to engage in constitutional bodies while audio recordings of meetings are active. The dispute centers on the implementation of audio recording for court sessions. Three judges, identified as Andrej Abramović, Sanja Bezbradić Jelavić, and Lovorka Kušan, have objected to the method used to introduce the practice. They argue that no formal decision was adopted by the court as a collegiate body and that the rules of procedure were not amended. Consequently, they consider the recording unlawful and have declined to attend sessions where it occurs. Staničić acknowledged that no formal vote was taken and that the internal regulations remained unchanged. However, he maintained that the change was introduced based on prior informal agreements and repeated warnings given to the bench. Staničić detailed the timeline of the implementation, noting that he informed the judges multiple times about the purchase, installation, and testing of the recording system. He pointed to a session held on October 6, which was itself recorded, where he announced to all present that recording would begin immediately in accordance with their agreement. He claimed that no judge reacted to this announcement at the time. As the president of the court, Staničić asserted he possesses the authority to determine how minutes are established, rendering a separate formal vote unnecessary for his view. The primary motivation for introducing audio recording, according to Staničić, was to resolve persistent disputes regarding the credibility of written minutes. He cited specific incidents, particularly one occurring in May of this year during deliberations on the composition of the court’s panel. In that instance, he noted, the very judges who now oppose recording had challenged a minute signed by two clerks and confirmed by five judges. Staničić argued that audio recording is the only mechanism capable of ensuring a credible record that cannot be disputed. Tensions escalated following public comments made by Judge Abramović, who appeared on the same television channel the day before Staničić. Abramović stated that he was aware of plans to introduce recording but did not consider it his duty to warn the president. Staničić responded sharply, questioning whether it aligns with a judge’s role to remain silent about objections until a conflict arises. He asked the public to evaluate whether a judge should collegially notify the president of concerns or stay quiet and later create problems based on unexpressed disagreement. Staničić also rejected claims that the recordings are private or that judges lack access to them. He clarified that the files were created using official equipment in official rooms and stored on the court’s servers. Any judge can listen to the recordings, and requests for copies are being considered separately. He proposed forming a working group to draft a specific act regulating the recording process. The group was to include himself, the chief secretary, and one judge opposing the measure. However, the proposal was rejected because participation was conditioned on halting the recording immediately. Staničić stated this condition was unacceptable, as stopping the recording would undermine the security of the minutes. Regarding the current status of the dissenting judges, Staničić noted that one female judge continues to attend sessions despite her opposition to the recording. He criticized the other two for choosing to deepen an unnecessary conflict rather than continue protecting citizen rights. He dismissed allegations that recent court sessions were illegal, insisting they are lawful. He emphasized that while procedural disagreements are acceptable, they must not impede the court's core mission of safeguarding citizens. Looking ahead, Staničić announced that a new session will be scheduled once judges currently on official business return, expected around November 13. He admitted that as president, he lacks mechanisms to force judges to comply with decisions. Additionally, he revealed that media outlets, civil society groups, and citizens have requested access to the recordings under the Law on the Right to Access Information. Given the sensitive nature of the data, Staničić believes he cannot release them unilaterally. He intends to seek consensus among all judges. If consensus is reached, the recordings will be released to the public. If any judge objects, Staničić stated he will publicly identify which judges voted against disclosure.
Go to the primary sources (1)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
The President of the Constitutional Court of Croatia, Frane Staničić, stated in an interview that the court’s operations are severely hindered because three judges refuse to participate in working groups unless audio recording of sessions is discontinued. Staničić defended the introduction of audio recordings as necessary to ensure the reliability of transcripts, particularly after issues arose during the determination of the court panel in May. He rejected claims by Judge Andrej Abramović that access to recordings was denied, noting that all judges can listen to them and requests for copies are being considered. While acknowledging he lacks mechanisms to force compliance, Staničić criticized the dissenting judges for choosing to deepen conflict rather than protect citizens’ rights. He announced plans to schedule a session by mid-November and proposed greater transparency, including open sessions, threatening to publicly name any judges who oppose sharing recordings with the public.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the dissenting judges negatively as obstructing justice and deepening unnecessary conflict, while presenting the president's unilateral actions as justified and transparent.
Constitutional Court President Frane Staničić addressed the ongoing institutional crisis triggered by three judges refusing to participate in sessions due to the introduction of audio recording. He asserted that the recording was implemented based on prior informal agreements and his authority over minute-taking procedures, citing previous disputes regarding the reliability of written records. Staničić rejected claims that the recordings were private, emphasizing they were created with official equipment and stored on court servers accessible to all judges. He criticized the dissenting judges for prioritizing conflict over protecting citizens' rights and dismissed allegations that the court’s sessions are unlawful. While proposing a working group to regulate the process, he stated the proposal failed because participation was conditioned on stopping the recordings immediately.
Bias read (Conservative): The article relies exclusively on the President's defense of unilateral administrative actions and frames dissenting judges as obstructive actors who abandon their duty to protect citizens, omitting critical perspectives from the opposition within the court.
The President of Croatia’s Constitutional Court, Frane Staničić, stated that the court will face significant operational difficulties because three judges have refused to participate in sessions involving audio recording. These judges argue that the introduction of recordings was implemented without a formal collective decision by the court, rendering the process unlawful. Staničić acknowledged the absence of a formal vote but claimed there was an informal agreement among all justices regarding the installation of the equipment. He defended his actions by citing previous disputes over meeting minutes and asserted that he had the authority to determine record-keeping methods as the court president. Additionally, Staničić criticized one of the dissenting judges for failing to raise objections earlier and for publicly criticizing the situation after the fact.
Bias read (Conservative): The article relies exclusively on the President's defense of unilateral administrative changes and frames dissenting judges' legal concerns as obstructive silence rather than valid procedural challenges.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.