ON
🔍Log in
← Back to feed
The conflict between Italy and Spain has just reached its climax.
Croatia🏛️ PoliticsCenter13 days ago

The conflict between Italy and Spain has just reached its climax.

The conflict between Italy and Spain has reached its peak after Spain introduced strict border controls on all air and sea routes from Italy. These measures, which came into effect at midnight and will last for a month, are a direct response to Italy's recent decision to impose similar restrictions following the influx of around 78,000 migrants from Morocco into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta. The crisis has intensified relations between Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and Italian leader Giorgia Meloni, who has long advocated for stricter EU migration rules. Although Italy does not share a land border with Spain, the Italian government suspended Schengen agreements under the pretext of preventing migrants from Ceuta from moving further into Italy. Madrid strongly rejected these arguments, calling them false and unsubstantiated, as these migrants legally cannot enter the Schengen area. Both countries officially claim the checks are random (between 5 and 10 percent), but reports indicate significant chaos at airports, with travelers from Spain being directed to special lanes. Meanwhile, concerns remain over potential new waves of migration, with investigations suggesting organized

Morocco has expressed willingness to assist in repatriating unaccompanied minors who arrived in Ceuta during the recent mass migration wave, according to state news agency MAP. The Moroccan government pledged to work with Spain and other European partners to identify and return these children to their countries of origin, following high-level royal directives issued to the ministries of internal affairs and foreign affairs. This comes a week after the large influx of migrants into Ceuta, which is gradually returning to its usual life, although hundreds of children and young people remain on the streets and in overcrowded reception centers. The local authorities in Ceuta estimate that among the tens of thousands of migrants who entered the city, there were approximately 1,100 unaccompanied minors. According to the central Spanish government, police have so far identified 528 boys and girls and handed them over to local authorities for care and accommodation. Other estimates suggest that between 3,000 and 5,000 people remain in Ceuta after the majority of migrants returned, including around 1,000 unaccompanied minors. Spanish authorities cannot automatically return these children to Morocco. Before each repatriation, they must determine the child's identity, locate their family, and assess whether the return is in the best interest of the child. Non-governmental organizations working on the ground claim that official figures do not reflect the true scale of the crisis. An organization based in the El Príncipe neighborhood stated that it collected data on 2,672 unaccompanied migrant minors in just one day, while hundreds more remain unaccounted for. Reception capacities in Ceuta have been significantly exceeded, leading some children to sleep in parks, on the streets, and in makeshift shelters. Spain has allocated €25 million for emergency assistance and housing for unaccompanied minors. Morocco has indicated it will cooperate in identifying children and facilitating their return to their families, but each process must be conducted individually and with respect for the rights of the minors. Following the crisis in Ceuta, European Union ministers of the interior agreed to strengthen efforts against migrant smuggling networks, improve monitoring of social media, and enhance border security. The meeting was convened after tens of thousands of migrants crossed into the northern African enclave from Morocco last week, causing tensions between Spain and several other EU member states. Ministers emphasized the need for continued relentless combat against smuggling networks, effective implementation of returns, strengthening EU borders, deepening partnerships with third countries, and improving situation forecasting. They also highlighted the importance of enhancing joint monitoring of situations, including better oversight of social media. The tone of the meeting contrasted sharply with earlier criticisms leveled by several EU countries against the Spanish government under Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez. In response to the events in Ceuta, 22 EU leaders who advocate for restrictive immigration policies criticized Madrid, arguing that Spain’s liberal approach could encourage further migrations. Some member states have increased controls on borders with other EU countries. Spain’s left-wing government accused other member states of exploiting the crisis for political gain. Migration commissioner Magnus Brunner noted that the number of arrivals in the EU has sharply declined in recent years and that none of the people who arrived in Ceuta last week had reached the mainland part of Spain or other Schengen countries. He mentioned that Spanish authorities and Europol are investigating what prompted the sudden surge of people and pointed to misinformation spreading through social media platforms such as TikTok. Many migrants claimed they learned about the supposed open border with Spain through videos and posts on social media. The hope that accommodation would be secured in Ceuta and that continuing the journey to the mainland part of Spain would be within reach spread quickly. To prevent similar situations in the future, EU ministers plan to monitor social media more closely. Although questions remain about why Morocco did not take stronger measures to prevent thousands of people from crossing into Ceuta, Brunner emphasized the important role played by the Moroccan authorities in allowing people to return to their country. He noted that negotiations for a new partnership agreement with Morocco are ongoing and that migration issues are part of these discussions. Ahead of the talks, the European Commission proposed improvements to early warning systems for border management and enhanced financial support for Morocco. Minister of Internal Affairs Davor Božinović stated that the EU response to the migrant crisis in Ceuta would be more coordinated, involving European agencies more strongly and further strengthening external border protection. He noted that Spain, with the support of 22 other member states, including Croatia, opened the issue of events in Ceuta at the European level, sending a clear message that security challenges at the borders of one member state represent a challenge for the entire European Union. He announced that detailed analysis of the circumstances leading to the migrant crisis would be prepared in the coming weeks, and its results would serve as the basis for another ministerial meeting of interior ministers in early November and later for discussion at the European Council. Speaking about Croatian priorities, Božinović expressed satisfaction that the European Commission opened a debate on the concept of safe third countries, which Croatia has long advocated for. He emphasized that people coming from countries far away from Croatia pass through a series of safe countries. If the international protection system is consistently applied, asylum should be requested in the first safe country. He added that current migration flows show that a large number of migrants entering the European Union come primarily for economic reasons, confirmed by statements made by migrants involved in the events in Ceuta. Božinović stressed that humanity and security are not opposing concepts and that the EU will continue to provide protection to those who need it, but simultaneously prevent illegal migration and resolutely fight against human trafficking networks. He noted that Croatian police arrested 698 human traffickers this year alone, showing the extent of organized criminal groups' activities and the effectiveness of police in border control. Italy wants to establish processing centers for migrants outside the EU territory, funded by the European Union, to prevent a recurrence of the previous week's influx of about 50,000 migrants into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta. Italian Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi told his colleagues that the EU can no longer simply react to crisis situations. "We as the European Union can no longer just react to urgent situations within our borders. We must act as a united and coherent block to stop departures at the source and return those who do not have the right to stay on EU territory," he said. This incident represents the first major test of the EU Pact on Migration, which came into effect in June after years of negotiations. The crisis tests whether new rules and solidarity mechanisms can handle an unexpected mass influx of migrants at the outer borders. Migration is one of the issues that cause the deepest divisions in the European Union since the 2015 and 2016 crises, when over a million refugees and migrants arrived in Europe, mostly from war-torn Syria. That wave strengthened support for anti-immigration and far-right parties and deepened existing disputes over border control, asylum rules, and responsibility distribution. Moroccan authorities stated that mass crossings into Ceuta and Melilla were triggered by misinformation on social media, smuggling networks, and misinterpretation of a Spanish court ruling. They noted that most people who crossed the border have already returned to Moroccan territory after failing to find the expected conditions. Despite this, Italy suspended the application of the Schengen agreement on travel without passports with Spain for a month, even though Schengen does not apply to Ceuta. Meanwhile, 22 out of 27 member states requested a coordinated action to strengthen the EU's external borders. Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis advocates for introducing an extraordinary migration mechanism for the EU, which would allow accelerated procedures and, in exceptional circumstances, temporary suspension of asylum applications registration during sudden mass arrivals. Mitsotakis believes that existing EU rules are tailored to usual migration pressures, not coordinated mass arrivals. European Commissioner for Internal Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner stated that the situation in Ceuta showed the readiness of some actors to use migration to test the European Union. "Europe has passed this test so far," he said on Monday via his spokesperson for Reuters. He announced that ministers would discuss lessons learned from this crisis and ways to strengthen the EU's response. "It encourages that we have placed the situation under control and carried out a rapid return. New European rules have helped make procedures more efficient and strengthened the reaction of member states," concluded Brunner. Minister Božinović commented on the migrant crisis at the border between Morocco and the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, stating that it is a situation about which Europe must draw certain messages. Announcing that he would talk today with ministers of member states of the European Union about the migrant crisis, Božinović said that he would get information from Spain and European representatives about the situation in Ceuta. "This is a big wave of people who have entered the territory of the EU, but they have not entered the continental part of Europe nor is there a possibility of entry into the Schengen area from Ceuta. The situation is resolved because most of the migrants have been returned to Morocco," said Božinović. He added that ministers must discuss how to prevent something similar from happening on any other external border of the EU, but also how to consistently implement European policy on migration. Božinović emphasized that it is known that besides criminal groups, there are also state-sponsored actors who want to destabilize the European space, but assessed that it would not succeed. Regarding the huge crowds at the border, the minister touched upon the large crowds at the border crossing of Karasovići, where waiting times to cross into Montenegro exceeded 15 hours over the weekend. "Today, this situation is almost normal when exiting Croatia. When talking about the border crossing of Karas

Go to the primary sources (4)

The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.

8 reports

tportal logotportalIndependentProgressiveFactual 95Objective 7022 days ago
Europe breaks down in Ceuta: After 60,000 migrants enter, an emergency meeting called, Spain furious

Španjolska je osudio reakcije europskih vlada na masovni ulazak 60.000 migranata iz Maroka u Ceutu, uz istaknuće da je granicu kontrolisala u roku od 48 sati i spriječila njihov dalji prolazak u Europu. Gotovo svi migranti su se vratili u Maroko, dok je broj poginulih porastao na najmanje 67. Španjolske vlasti su počele s pojačanim osiguranjem, uključujući vojsku, dronove i plovila, kao i postavljanjem plutajuće pomorske prepreke. Iako je situacija na terenu stabilizirana, diplomatski spor među EU državama intenzivira se. Italija je uvela kontrolne mjere za migrante koji dolaze iz Španjolske, dok su Finska, Danska i Češka zahtijevala oštrije reakcije, uključujući moguću privremenu suspenciju Schengenskog sporazuma sa Španjolskom.

Bias read (Progressive): Artikel fokusira na kritiku španjolske politike prema migraciji i ističe da su druge europske države, posebno desničarske, preuzeli agresivnije stajališta. Kritika je usmjerena prema 'desničarskoj demagogiji' i 'strančanstvu', što sugerira levičarski okvir. Upravo su desničarske države koje traže oš

Why factuality (95): This article provides detailed information about the migration crisis in Ceuta, including the number of migrants (50-60 thousand), the Spanish government's actions, and the international reactions. The facts align closely with the primary source document, though it omits some specific Croatian persp

Why objectivity (70): The article has a clear bias towards portraying Spain as being at odds with other European countries, particularly Italy and Denmark. It uses emotionally charged language such as 'sebične, polarizirajuće i protuzakonite' which may influence reader perception rather than presenting an entirely neutra

Index.hr logoIndex.hrIndependentConservativeFactual 90Objective 8513 days ago
Meloni and Frederiksen are looking for migrant return centers outside the EU

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen issued a joint statement warning against 'uncontrolled migration' into Europe and calling again for the establishment of migrant centers outside the European Union to return rejected asylum seekers to their countries of origin. Frederiksen emphasized that illegal immigration negatively affects societies by increasing crime rates, straining public services, and eroding public trust. She highlighted concerns about violent crimes, drug trafficking, and sexual violence committed by undocumented migrants. The two leaders, representing different ends of the political spectrum, Meloni leading the far-right Brothers of Italy and Frederiksen a social democrat, stated they disagree on many issues but share a common goal of protecting Europe. The proposal for deportation centers outside the EU has been debated for years and remains highly controversial within the bloc.

Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the issue through the lens of strict immigration control and calls for deportation centers outside the EU, which aligns with right-leaning policies. The emphasis on 'uncontrolled migration,' 'illegal immigration,' and the negative impacts on society reflect a conservative stance.

Why factuality (90): This article accurately reports on the border control measures between Spain and Italy, mentioning the specific numbers (5-10%), the duration (one month), and the context of the migrant influx into Ceuta. It includes relevant details about the political conflict between Sanchez and Meloni and refere

Why objectivity (85): The article maintains a relatively neutral tone, presenting facts without overtly biased language. It avoids taking sides and provides context about both countries' positions, though it could offer more perspective on the migrant experience or alternative viewpoints.

N1 Hrvatska logoN1 HrvatskaIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 8015 days ago
Spain responds to Italian border control measures, EU member states continue to dispute

Španjolska je uvela granične kontrole za zračni i pomorski promet iz Italije kao reakciju na italijanske mjere koje su bile usmjerene na sprečavanje migracija prema Italiji. Ove mjere, koje traju mjesec dana, nastale su nakon što je Italija uvela slična ograničenja nakon priljeva 78 tisuća migranata u Ceutu. Kriza je pogodila španjolskog socijalističkog premijera Petra Sancheza i talijanske konzervativne premijerke Giorgije Meloni, koje se sukobili oko politike prema migracijama. Italija, koja nema kopnenu granicu s Španjoms, objasnila je da je odluka o privremenom prekidu Schengenskog sporazuma donesena radi sprječavanja daljnjih migracija, dok Madrid smatra da su ti argumenti neotvoreni i činjenično netocni. Španjola traži od Italije da odustane od kontrola do nedjelje, dok Italija navodi da će ih održavati najkasnije do 15. kolovoza.

Bias read (Progressive): Članak naglašava poziciju španjolskog socijalističkog premijera Petra Sancheza, koji se suprostavlja italijanskoj konzervativnoj premijerki Giorgiji Meloni. Usporedba između socijalista i konzervativa sugerira levi ključ. Članak također ističe da su italijanske mjere 'neutemeljene' i 'bez činjenične

Why factuality (85): The article accurately describes the border control measures between Spain and Italy, referencing the 78,000 migrants in Ceuta and the Schengen suspension. It includes relevant details about the political conflict between Sanchez and Meloni and mentions the differing approaches to border checks.

Why objectivity (80): The article maintains a mostly neutral tone, presenting facts without overtly biased language. It avoids taking sides and provides context about both countries' positions, though it could offer more perspective on the migrant experience or alternative viewpoints.

Večernji list logoVečernji listIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 8022 days ago
What Ceuta means for Europe: The crisis at the EU's external border has reopened the debate on migration

The article discusses the recent migration crisis at Spain's North African enclave Ceuta, which has reignited debates over EU migration policies. Thousands of migrants arrived from Morocco, many returning after being denied entry. The situation echoes the 2015 refugee crisis, with tensions rising around border controls and the effectiveness of the new Common European Asylum System (GEAS). Spanish authorities reported around 60,000 migrants, while central government estimates were lower. Migrants attempted to cross into mainland Europe, facing police confrontations and maritime rescues. The incident highlights challenges in managing external borders and the limitations of Schengen rules within EU member states like Spain. Italy temporarily suspended the Schengen Agreement with Spain, signaling potential future restrictions on internal movement.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced overview of the migration crisis, citing both regional and national government figures, describing the situation without overtly criticizing any specific political stance. It reports on the broader implications for EU policy without taking a clear ideological position

Why factuality (85): The article accurately reports the migration crisis in Ceuta, citing specific numbers of migrants (around 50,000), mentions the conflict at the border, and references the European Commissioner Magnus Brunner's statement. However, it does not explicitly mention Dubravka Šuica being assigned by Von de

Why objectivity (80): The article maintains a relatively neutral tone, presenting facts without overt bias. It includes quotes from officials and describes events objectively, though it uses some emotionally charged terms like 'dramatic images' and 'mass influx,' which slightly reduce neutrality.

Večernji list logoVečernji listIndependentCenterFactual 80Objective 7521 days ago
When the migrants arrive in Lampedusa, Meloni asks for help, and when they arrive in Ceuta, he closes the borders

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has implemented border controls with Spain in response to a migrant influx into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, which received around 60,000 migrants from Morocco. This move contrasts with Italy’s usual approach of seeking European solidarity during migration crises, such as those involving Lampedusa. The decision appears to signal both a message to Italian voters and frustration with Spain’s leftist government, particularly since there was no evidence that the migrants intended to travel to Italy. The situation raises broader questions about the stability of the Schengen zone, as countries appear willing to erect barriers during significant migration pressures.

Bias read (Center): The article presents the situation objectively, highlighting Meloni’s actions and their implications without overtly favoring either Italy or Spain. It notes the contrast between Italy’s past requests for European support and its current unilateral measures but does not take a clear stance on the合理性

Why factuality (80): The article accurately reports on the migration crisis in Ceuta, the deployment of floating barriers, and the EU’s response. It mentions the death toll and the repatriation of most migrants, aligning with the primary source. However, it does not explicitly mention Dubravka Šuica or the 2015 referenc

Why objectivity (75): The article maintains a relatively neutral tone, presenting the facts without overt bias. It avoids strong emotional language but still highlights the severity of the situation, which could be seen as slightly favoring Spain’s perspective.

Jutarnji list logoJutarnji listIndependentCenterFactual 75Objective 6515 days ago
The conflict between Italy and Spain has just reached its climax.

The conflict between Italy and Spain has reached its peak after Spain introduced strict border controls on all air and sea routes from Italy. These measures, which came into effect at midnight and will last for a month, are a direct response to Italy's recent decision to impose similar restrictions following the influx of around 78,000 migrants from Morocco into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta. The crisis has intensified relations between Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and Italian leader Giorgia Meloni, who has long advocated for stricter EU migration rules. Although Italy does not share a land border with Spain, the Italian government suspended Schengen agreements under the pretext of preventing migrants from Ceuta from moving further into Italy. Madrid strongly rejected these arguments, calling them false and unsubstantiated, as these migrants legally cannot enter the Schengen area. Both countries officially claim the checks are random (between 5 and 10 percent), but reports indicate significant chaos at airports, with travelers from Spain being directed to special lanes. Meanwhile, concerns remain over potential new waves of migration, with investigations suggesting organized

Bias read (Center): The article presents both sides of the conflict between Italy and Spain regarding migration policies and Schengen suspensions. It includes quotes and actions from both governments, providing balanced coverage without overtly favoring one side through language or emphasis.

Why factuality (75): The article accurately reports the escalation between Italy and Spain over border controls following the migration crisis in Ceuta. However, it lacks specific details from the primary source document, such as the involvement of Dubravka Šuica and the reference to the 2015 crisis. The claim about 78,

Why objectivity (65): The article uses emotionally charged language like 'massive influx,' 'chaos at airports,' and 'completely bizarre.' It frames the situation as an Italian attempt to prevent migrants from moving to Italy, potentially favoring Spain’s position by emphasizing the 'illegal' nature of the migrants.

tportal logotportalIndependentCenterFactual 65Objective 4513 days ago
Meloni and Frederiksen call for a tougher approach: 'Illegal migration is having a negative impact on our countries'

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen issued a joint statement warning against uncontrolled migration into Europe, calling for the establishment of migrant centers outside the European Union to return rejected asylum seekers to their countries of origin. They emphasized that illegal immigration negatively affects societies by increasing crime rates, straining public services, and eroding public trust. The two leaders, representing different ends of the political spectrum, Meloni leading the far-right Brothers of Italy and Frederiksen a social democrat, stated they share a common goal of protecting Europe despite their differing views. The proposal for deportation centers outside the EU has been debated for years and remains highly controversial within the bloc.

Bias read (Center): The article presents both Meloni and Frederiksen’s positions without overtly favoring one over the other. It includes direct quotes from both leaders and acknowledges their differing political backgrounds while highlighting areas of agreement. There is no clear ideological slant in the framing or ph

Why factuality (65): Like items 0 and 1, this article focuses on Meloni and Frederiksen's joint statement about 'uncontrolled migration' and the need for migrant return centers. It provides minimal context about the actual events in Ceuta or the border control measures between Spain and Italy, missing crucial details fr

Why objectivity (45): The article uses emotionally charged language to describe 'illegal migration' and its negative effects on society. It frames the issue in a way that supports the leaders' positions without offering opposing viewpoints or balanced analysis.

Telegram.hr logoTelegram.hrIndependentCenterFactual 60Objective 5517 days ago
The split among European socialists after the crisis in Ceuta.

The article discusses growing divisions among European socialists following the migration crisis in Ceuta, a Spanish enclave in North Africa. Over 50,000 people reportedly entered the area illegally, prompting tensions between Spain and other EU member states like Italy. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen and Italian Premier Giorgia Meloni criticized Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez for his handling of the situation, leading to a letter signed by 22 EU leaders calling for stronger border controls. The article highlights differing approaches within the European Socialist Party (PES), noting that Croatia’s Social Democratic Party (SDP) aligns more closely with positions advocating stricter border management and efficient migration control. A representative from the SDP, Sanja Bježančević, emphasized effective governance of migration flows and rejected calls to suspend Schengen agreements.

Bias read (Center): While the article presents disagreements among European socialist leaders regarding migration policies, it does not overtly favor any specific ideological stance. It reports on multiple perspectives, criticism of Sánchez from Frederiksen and Meloni, support for stricter border controls from the SDP,–

Why factuality (60): The article discusses the political divide within the European socialist group due to the Ceuta crisis but fails to provide specific numbers or direct quotes from the primary source. It mentions the migration figures (approximately 50–60,000 people) but does not connect them to the broader EU respon

Why objectivity (55): The article has a biased tone, focusing on the internal divisions among European socialists rather than providing a balanced view of the crisis itself. It implies criticism toward Spain’s actions while supporting the positions of Italy and Denmark.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories

Call for renewed migrant rush: Ceuta border heavily secured

Call for renewed migrant rush: Ceuta border heavily secured

Lean Conservative4 sources20 hr. ago
Over 200 Brits have applied for asylum in Australia - but authorities tell them to stop

Over 200 Brits have applied for asylum in Australia - but authorities tell them to stop

Center3 sources19 hr. ago
Government fails to fully return migrants despite flattering Morocco: 6,500 still roam unchecked through Ceuta

Government fails to fully return migrants despite flattering Morocco: 6,500 still roam unchecked through Ceuta

Center6 sources21 hr. ago
Migration: Matteo Salvini stirs conflict with Germany over secondary migrants

Migration: Matteo Salvini stirs conflict with Germany over secondary migrants

Conservative3 sources22 hr. ago
Melons tomorrow afternoon in Amatrice for the 10th anniversary of the earthquake

Melons tomorrow afternoon in Amatrice for the 10th anniversary of the earthquake

Lean Conservative3 sources18 hr. ago
Vice President Cuerpo travels to Ceuta 25 days after the crisis to work on an economic support plan

Vice President Cuerpo travels to Ceuta 25 days after the crisis to work on an economic support plan

Center2 sources19 hr. ago