A famous historian sees the fall of Vucic and Bolsonaro as a key turning point: The rise of the far right is not inevitable
Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Anne Applebaum commented on recent electoral defeats of President Aleksandar Vučić in Serbia and Jair Bolsonaro’s son Flavio Bolsonaro in Brazil, describing them as significant turning points against the global rise of the far-right. She noted that despite her reservations regarding Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s foreign policy and limited knowledge of the specifics of the Serbian student movement, these results demonstrate that high voter turnout can reverse seemingly unstoppable political trends. In Serbia, the student-led list 'Students Win' secured 51.71 percent of the vote compared to 39.85 percent for Vučić’s coalition, a victory driven by nearly two years of protests initiated after a fatal collapse at the Novi Sad railway station in November 2024. Applebaum emphasized that while she does not support all aspects of the winning candidates' policies, the elections prove that democratic participation remains a powerful force capable of altering historical shifts toward authoritarianism.
Serbia’s long-time leader Aleksandar Vučić conceded defeat on Sunday night to a student-led protest movement in historic snap parliamentary elections, ending more than a decade of his political dominance. The outcome, driven by record voter turnout, signals a profound shift in the Balkan nation’s political landscape. Based on preliminary exit polls, the Student List secured between 135 and 140 seats in the 250-member parliament, while Vučić’s Serbian Progressive Party (SNS) obtained approximately 105 mandates. Vučić acknowledged the loss in a televised address, stating that the Student List had won and that no other parties crossed the threshold for parliamentary representation. He estimated the Student List received roughly 2.2 million votes, compared to 1.72 million for his coalition. The elections were held on October 25, following nearly two years of mass demonstrations and blockades. These protests originated in November 2024 after the collapse of a canopy at the railway station in Novi Sad, a tragedy that claimed 16 lives. The disaster sparked widespread outrage over alleged corruption, institutional accountability, and the nexus between political power and major construction projects. What began as campus-based activism evolved into a broad political force capable of challenging the established order. Turnout reached nearly 70 percent, the highest recorded since the breakup of Yugoslavia in 1992, with lines stretching from polling stations in cities and towns across the country. International observers and figures reacted swiftly to the result. Anne Applebaum, the Pulitzer Prize-winning historian and author of Autocracy, Inc., noted on social media that the simultaneous defeats of Vučić in Serbia and Flávio Bolsonaro in Brazil demonstrated that the rise of the international far-right is not inevitable. She highlighted that both politicians had close ties to US President Donald Trump and his circle, yet were defeated due to high voter participation. Applebaum added that while much remains unknown about the structure of the Serbian student movement, the results prove that voters can alter trajectories that appeared historically fixed. In Belgrade, celebrations erupted immediately after Vučić’s concession. Tens of thousands of people gathered on the main boulevards, honking car horns, dancing, and chanting slogans such as “Victory” and “He’s done.” Radomir Sajcic, a professor at Belgrade University who spoke on behalf of the students, declared that the voice of the people was finally being heard. He described the moment as a time to celebrate victory today and build the future tomorrow. Other candidates, including farmers, athletes, and artists, emphasized that the movement represents a victory of courage over fear. One woman named Tanja, celebrating in the streets, expressed overwhelming joy at finally getting rid of what she termed a mafia-like system. European leaders extended congratulations to the new victors. Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, stated that the EU stands ready to cooperate with Serbia to advance its future within the union. She emphasized readiness to support reforms regarding the rule of law, media freedom, and anti-corruption efforts. Marta Kos, the European Commissioner for Enlargement, affirmed that the voices of Serbians had been heard after two years of protests. Sandro Gozi, Secretary General of the European Democratic Party, labeled the result an exceptional victory for democracy and freedom, noting that the young generation had convinced citizens of all ages that change was possible. Hungarian Prime Minister Peter Magyar also offered support to the students. The Guardian analyzed the election as a pivotal moment that could mark the end of a specific political era. The publication noted that Vučić’s defeat followed a campaign characterized by intense mobilization of voters beyond the initial student base. The paper warned, however, that the incoming leadership faces the daunting task of governing a country whose institutions have been heavily influenced by the previous regime for years. According to the Guardian, the boundary between the state and the ruling party has been largely erased, with the SNS maintaining control or strong influence over nearly all television channels. Raša Nedeljkov, Program Director of the Center for Research, Transparency and Accountability (CRTA), told the newspaper that this entanglement poses significant challenges for the new administration. Reuters reported that the victory reflects deep dissatisfaction with the political system and highlights the strength of the student movement, which emerged as the primary challenge to Vučić’s authority since he became prime minister in 2014 and president three years later. The agency noted that prior to the election, there were warnings about an atmosphere of intimidation, physical attacks on activists, cyberattacks, and threats against opposition figures. The student movement, lacking a single unified leader, makes decisions through large assemblies and includes candidates with varying views on key political issues, united primarily by a demand for different governance methods. Vučić blamed the defeat on interference from independent media and unnamed European countries, as well as the American "deep state." His party had previously denied allegations of repression, corruption, and surveillance of opponents. The Guardian cautioned that tensions or violence could occur if the final results are disputed or if the margin is narrow, citing past incidents involving violent groups disrupting opposition gatherings. Conversely, students announced they were prepared to take to the streets to protect the electoral outcome should they perceive any threat to the validity of their victory. The final official results were pending at the time of initial international reporting, though exit polls by CESID-IPSPS indicated the Student List would secure 138 deputies and the SNS 104, with remaining seats allocated to ethnic minority parties.
Go to the primary sources (8)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
A student-led movement achieved a historic victory in Serbia's early parliamentary elections held on October 25, ending the long-standing rule of Prime Minister Aleksandar Vučić. Vučić conceded defeat on Sunday evening, acknowledging based on exit polls that the Student List won between 135 and 140 seats out of 250, while his coalition secured approximately 105 mandates. The election result follows nearly two years of mass protests by students demanding accountability regarding a tragedy in Novi Sad. International media outlets have described the outcome as a major political shockwave on the Balkans and a pivotal turning point in Serbian politics. While the student movement successfully mobilized a broad base of voters beyond just university students, analysts note that the new leadership faces significant challenges in managing state institutions that were heavily influenced by the previous administration.
Bias read (Center): The article functions as a meta-review of international media coverage rather than presenting a single editorial stance. It neutrally summarizes the factual outcomes of the election and attributes specific framings to distinct foreign sources (e.g., noting The Guardian's focus on the end of an era,而
Why factuality (95): Very faithful to the primary source. Cites specific numbers (135-140 seats, 2.2m votes) and quotes Vučić accurately. Mentions the New Sad tragedy as context, which aligns with the 'student protests' origin mentioned in the source.
Why objectivity (85): Balanced. Reports on international media reactions neutrally. Acknowledges the difficulty of governing mentioned in the source.
The British newspaper The Guardian published an extensive analysis on election day describing Serbia as a state where democratic institutions have been systematically weakened over the past decade. The report asserts that President Aleksandar Vučić has gradually undermined democratic foundations while his party gained significant control over media and state institutions, noting that nearly all television channels are under government influence. The article highlights the uncertain future of two independent TV channels recently acquired by a Portuguese investor linked to Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s political circles. It references the collapse of a canopy at the Novi Sad railway station in November 2024, which killed 16 people and sparked mass student protests that evolved into a political movement now running for parliament. The Guardian warns of potential post-election unrest, citing historical allegations against the ruling Serbian Progressive Party regarding the use of violent groups to disrupt opposition gatherings.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the situation through a critical lens focused on democratic erosion, authoritarian consolidation, and media capture, which aligns with liberal-left analytical frameworks. It emphasizes the strength of the grassroots student movement and expresses concern about state violence, omit
Why factuality (92): Faithfully summarizes the Guardian analysis referenced in the text, accurately linking the Student List's rise to the 2024 Novi Sad tragedy and detailing the media landscape under Vučić. Claims align with the primary source's description of the political shift.
Why objectivity (85): Maintains a journalistic tone by attributing views to the Guardian and CRTA director rather than adopting them as absolute facts. Presents the narrative of democratic erosion as reported analysis rather than direct opinion.
Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Anne Applebaum commented on recent electoral defeats of President Aleksandar Vučić in Serbia and Jair Bolsonaro’s son Flavio Bolsonaro in Brazil, describing them as significant turning points against the global rise of the far-right. She noted that despite her reservations regarding Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s foreign policy and limited knowledge of the specifics of the Serbian student movement, these results demonstrate that high voter turnout can reverse seemingly unstoppable political trends. In Serbia, the student-led list 'Students Win' secured 51.71 percent of the vote compared to 39.85 percent for Vučić’s coalition, a victory driven by nearly two years of protests initiated after a fatal collapse at the Novi Sad railway station in November 2024. Applebaum emphasized that while she does not support all aspects of the winning candidates' policies, the elections prove that democratic participation remains a powerful force capable of altering historical shifts toward authoritarianism.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the electoral victories of anti-Vučić and anti-Bolsonaro forces as positive democratic milestones that counter the 'inevitability' of the far-right rise. By highlighting the success of student movements and emphasizing the power of voter turnout to check authoritarian tendencies,
Why factuality (90): Quotes Anne Applebaum correctly. However, it includes specific vote percentage breakdowns (51.71% vs 39.85%) that differ slightly from the primary source's estimate (52% vs 32.3%). This discrepancy might stem from different polling stages or data sources, reducing strict faithfulness to the provided
Why objectivity (75): Adopts Applebaum's interpretive framework ('far-right', 'inevitable'), which introduces a specific ideological lens. While attributed to her, the article structure emphasizes this interpretation strongly.
Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Anne Applebaum commented on recent electoral defeats of Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic and Brazilian former President Jair Bolsonaro, noting that both leaders had close ties to US President Donald Trump and his circle. Applebaum stated via social media that these simultaneous losses demonstrate that the rise of the international far-right and authoritarianism is not inevitable, citing high voter turnout as a decisive factor. In Serbia, the 'Students Win' coalition secured over half the votes in early parliamentary elections, ending the 14-year dominance of Vucic's Serbian Progressive Party. The student movement originated from protests following a fatal roof collapse at the Novi Sad railway station in late 2024. Applebaum emphasized that while uncertainties remain regarding the student movement, their victory serves as proof that citizens can alter political processes previously considered unstoppable through active participation.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the election results as a positive democratic development by highlighting the defeat of 'authoritarian' and 'far-right' figures linked to Donald Trump. It relies heavily on the commentary of Anne Applebaum, a prominent critic of autocracy, who explicitly labels the defeated side's
Why factuality (85): Accurate reporting of Applebaum's tweets and the comparison to Bolsonaro. Correctly states the outcome of the Serbian election.
Why objectivity (60): Adopts the perspective of the quoted historian, framing the election as a global anti-authoritarian victory. While attributed, the overall tone is celebratory and aligned with a specific political narrative.
N1 HrvatskaIndependentProgressiveFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 60
American-Polish historian and journalist Anne Applebaum commented on recent political shifts in Serbia and Brazil via social media. She noted that both Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro and Serbian President Aleksandar Vučić, who she described as having close ties to Donald Trump and his family, unexpectedly lost their respective elections due to high voter turnout. Applebaum emphasized that these results demonstrate that voters can reverse processes that appeared unstoppable, challenging the notion that the rise of the international far-right is inevitable. In a follow-up post, she clarified that she does not support Lula’s foreign policy and acknowledged significant uncertainties regarding the Serbian student movement. The article provides background on Applebaum, highlighting her Pulitzer Prize win for 'Gulag: A History' and her expertise in analyzing authoritarian regimes and Eastern European politics.
Bias read (Progressive): The article centers on a quote from a prominent liberal commentator who frames the election losses of Bolsonaro and Vučić as victories against the 'international far-right.' By explicitly labeling the defeated leaders as part of a global far-right trend and celebrating the outcome as proof that this
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (60): Similar to item 6, frames the story through the lens of a Western liberal intellectual's approval. Tone is positive towards the outcome, reflecting the subject matter selected.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.