Croatia🏛️ PoliticsConservativeOverlooked by progressives
Plenković on the Constitutional Court: The entire legal profession is appalled by the behavior of these three judges
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic criticized three Constitutional Court judges who refuse to participate in recorded sessions, describing their behavior as irresponsible and hypocritical. He argued that these judges previously advocated for greater transparency but now fear recording, claiming that the entire legal profession is appalled by their conduct. Plenkovic accused opposition parties, specifically the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and Moze!, of obstructing the court's work and damaging institutional credibility from within, while rejecting their narrative that the ruling coalition occupies state institutions. The Prime Minister stated that the current situation represents serious obstruction after previous failed attempts to fill court vacancies through consensus. Additionally, he announced a decision to raise the minimum wage by 80 euros gross, increasing it from 1050 to 1130 euros for approximately 50,000 workers. To support employers during this transition, the government introduced compensatory measures where the Employment Service would cover the wage difference for the first three months of 2027.
Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic sharply criticized three judges of Croatia’s Constitutional Court on Thursday, accusing them of irresponsible conduct for refusing to participate in recorded sessions. Speaking at a public event in Varazdinske Toplice, the premier stated that the entire legal profession is appalled by their behavior, describing the situation as something so irresponsible that it had not been seen in a long time. The dispute centers on the refusal of three specific justices to attend court sessions that are being video-recorded. Plenkovic argued that this stance contradicts previous positions held by these same individuals. He noted that just a few years ago, these judges advocated for greater public inclusion in Constitutional Court proceedings. The prime minister labeled their current refusal to submit to recording as hypocrisy. He further directed criticism toward the political figures who proposed these candidates, claiming that comments made by those proponents regarding the judges' actions were entirely untrue. According to Plenkovic, the behavior represents serious and major negative aspects in the work of individuals who received the trust of a two-thirds majority in the Croatian Parliament. He emphasized that these judges took an oath and hold their positions because they are qualified legal experts. He found it incredible that they would receive such broad parliamentary support while engaging in conduct he deemed unacceptable. The premier urged listeners to examine the opinions of serious, independent legal specialists, asserting that the broader legal community is horrified by the actions of these three specific judges. The conflict has roots in recent efforts to fill vacancies on the Constitutional Court. Plenkovic recalled that several months ago, the process was close to completion. He described a shift in opposition tactics, noting that the opposition initially signaled readiness to elect three constitutional judges before reversing course. According to the prime minister, the opposition is now adopting an ultimatum approach, presenting two candidates of their choice and demanding that other parties agree with them. Plenkovic characterized this strategy as serious obstructionism. In his remarks, the prime minister accused the opposition parties, specifically naming the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and the Moze! party, of occupying institutions through internal sabotage. He rejected the narrative promoted by SDP and Moze!, which claims that the parliamentary majority, the government, the coalition, or the Croatian Democratic Union (HDZ) occupies state institutions. Plenkovic countered that the true policy of the opposition is to block institutions from the outside while simultaneously ruining and discrediting them from within. Beyond the judicial controversy, Plenkovic addressed the government's decision regarding the minimum wage for the coming year. He explained that the administration engaged in standard dialogue with employers and trade unions before determining an increase. The gross minimum wage will rise by 80 euros, moving from 1,050 euros to 1,130 euros. The government considers this amount realistic and a positive step for approximately 50,000 workers currently earning the minimum wage. To mitigate the impact on businesses, the government introduced compensatory measures. During the first three months of 2027, the Croatian Employment Service will pay employers, upon request, the difference between the current gross minimum wage and the new rate. This provision is intended to allow employers time to adjust to the higher costs. Plenkovic defended the measure as beneficial and consistent with the government's economic policies over its ten-year mandate. He cited assessments from economic experts that confirm the appropriateness of the chosen level, stating that the final objectives validate the decision. The prime minister’s comments highlight a deepening rift between the executive branch and parts of the judiciary, framed by Plenkovic as a battle over institutional integrity versus political obstruction. While the government points to expert consensus on economic matters and legal norms on judicial transparency, the opposition maintains that the ruling coalition is undermining democratic checks and balances. The immediate focus remains on the operational status of the Constitutional Court and the implementation of the new wage regulations starting in early 2027.
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic publicly criticized three Constitutional Court judges after they refused to participate in court sessions that were being recorded. The Prime Minister stated that the entire legal profession was appalled by their behavior. This incident highlights a significant conflict between the executive branch and the judiciary regarding transparency and procedural compliance within Croatia's highest constitutional body.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the judicial refusal as a serious breach of professional ethics, using strong language such as 'appalled' ('zgraža se') and highlighting the Prime Minister's condemnation. By focusing exclusively on the executive's criticism and omitting any counterarguments from the judges or the
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic criticized three Constitutional Court judges who refuse to participate in recorded sessions, describing their behavior as irresponsible and hypocritical since they previously advocated for greater transparency. He accused the opposition parties, specifically the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and We Can!, of obstructing judicial institutions by proposing candidates who undermine credibility from within, while dismissing claims that the ruling coalition occupies state institutions. The Prime Minister stated that the entire legal profession is appalled by the conduct of these judges, who were elected with a two-thirds majority in parliament. Additionally, Plenkovic announced a decision to increase the minimum wage by 80 euros gross, raising it from 1050 to 1130 euros for approximately 50,000 workers. To support employers during this transition, the government introduced compensatory measures where the Employment Service will cover the wage difference for the first three months of 2027.
Bias read (Conservative): The article relies exclusively on statements from the Prime Minister, the leader of the center-right HDZ party, without including counterarguments from the opposing judges or the opposition parties he criticizes. The framing adopts his perspective entirely, using strong negative descriptors such as
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic criticized three Constitutional Court judges who refuse to participate in recorded sessions, describing their behavior as irresponsible and hypocritical since they previously advocated for greater transparency. He accused the opposition parties, specifically the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and Moze!, of obstructing judicial appointments and undermining institutional credibility through internal sabotage rather than external blockades. Plenkovic stated that the legal community is appalled by the conduct of these judges, who were elected with a two-thirds parliamentary majority. Additionally, the Prime Minister announced a decision to increase the minimum wage by 80 euros gross, raising it from 1050 to 1130 euros for approximately 50,000 workers. The government plans to implement compensatory measures where the Employment Service will cover the cost difference for employers during the first three months of 2027 to facilitate adjustment.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents a direct quote from the ruling center-right Prime Minister attacking the judiciary and the left-wing opposition. It frames the refusal of judges to attend recorded sessions as 'hypocrisy' and 'obstructionism' orchestrated by the opposition, while portraying the government's wage
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic criticized three Constitutional Court judges who refuse to participate in recorded sessions, describing their behavior as irresponsible and hypocritical. He argued that these judges previously advocated for greater transparency but now fear recording, claiming that the entire legal profession is appalled by their conduct. Plenkovic accused opposition parties, specifically the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and Moze!, of obstructing the court's work and damaging institutional credibility from within, while rejecting their narrative that the ruling coalition occupies state institutions. The Prime Minister stated that the current situation represents serious obstruction after previous failed attempts to fill court vacancies through consensus. Additionally, he announced a decision to raise the minimum wage by 80 euros gross, increasing it from 1050 to 1130 euros for approximately 50,000 workers. To support employers during this transition, the government introduced compensatory measures where the Employment Service would cover the wage difference for the first three months of 2027.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents a highly partisan perspective dominated by the Prime Minister's rhetoric. It frames the constitutional crisis as a result of 'obstruction' and 'hypocrisy' by specific opposition parties (SDP, Moze!) and judges, using strong negative descriptors like 'fake narrative' and 'ruin'.
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenković criticized three judges of the Constitutional Court who refuse to participate in recorded sessions, describing their behavior as irresponsible and hypocritical since they previously advocated for greater transparency. He accused the opposition parties, specifically the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and Možemo!, of obstructing the institution by proposing candidates who undermine its credibility from within, while rejecting their narrative that the ruling coalition occupies state institutions. The Prime Minister stated that the entire legal profession is appalled by the conduct of these specific judges, whom he claims were elected with a two-thirds majority in parliament. In a separate segment, Plenković announced a decision to increase the minimum wage by 80 euros gross, raising it from 1050 to 1130 euros for approximately 50,000 workers. The government plans to implement compensatory measures where the Employment Service will cover the cost difference for employers during the first three months of 2027 to facilitate adjustment.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents the Prime Minister's perspective exclusively, using his strong, accusatory language ('hypocrisy', 'obstruction', 'ruin') without providing counterarguments from the opposing judges or the mentioned opposition parties. By framing the judicial dispute primarily through the lens of
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.
Croatia
%3Aformat(jpg)%3Aquality(99)%2Ff.elconfidencial.com%2Foriginal%2F2f0%2F14e%2F82a%2F2f014e82a48512f8bd2fcfa6568fb526.jpg&w=3840&q=75&output=webp&we)
