The trial against Cristian "Pity" Álvarez, accused of murdering his neighbor Cristian Díaz in July 2018, officially begins tomorrow, August 10. After eight years and one month since the crime, Álvarez will finally stand before the court as the defendant. The case has been marked by repeated delays, legal challenges, and medical evaluations, all centered around whether the musician was fit to face trial. The murder took place on July 12, 2018, in the neighborhood of Cardenal Samoré, in Villa Lugano, Buenos Aires. According to official records, Álvarez shot Díaz four times during a confrontation. The two men were not close friends but had known each other through occasional encounters. Following the killing, Álvarez reportedly disposed of the weapon in a sewer and remained at large for 24 hours before surrendering to police authorities. During his arrest, he confessed to the crime, stating, “It was him or me. And I think any animal would do the same.” Álvarez was initially detained and placed under the Programa Interministerial de Salud Mental Argentino (Prisma), which operates within Ezeiza Prison. He was granted house arrest with ankle monitoring. However, the judicial process stalled repeatedly. In 2021, the trial was suspended after a forensic medical team determined that Álvarez had a significantly impaired capacity for thought and comprehension, making him unfit to participate in a public hearing. His defense argued that the proceedings could not proceed until he was deemed mentally capable. In March 2023, the court again postponed the trial, rejecting the defense’s request for dismissal while ordering the termination of Álvarez’s house arrest. The prosecution, led by Fiscal General Sandro Abraldes, opposed the suspension, arguing that the trial must continue as planned. A medical evaluation conducted by a team of doctors and psychologists later concluded that Álvarez possessed sufficient cognitive ability to engage in the legal process. This finding prompted the Fiscalía to demand that the trial resume. Now, the trial is set to begin with 11 scheduled sessions, each lasting three hours. The case will be heard by Judges Gustavo Goerner, Juan María Ramos Padilla, and Hugo Navarro. The public prosecutor will be represented by Fiscal Abraldes, while the complainant's lawyer is Fernando Burlando. Álvarez will be defended by the official defender, Javier Aldo Marino. During the first session, Judge Goerner informed Álvarez that he was acquitted in a separate case involving alleged violence and illegal detention of two women in 2016. When asked if he would testify, Álvarez responded that he would do so "later" in the process. The judge also inquired about his drug use, to which Álvarez admitted using narcotics in the past but stated he was currently in treatment and no longer used them. Testimony from key witnesses is expected to play a central role in the trial. One of the first witnesses, Verónica Román, the last partner of the deceased, testified that she believed Álvarez did not regret the killing and that she hoped justice would be done for her child. She described the relationship between Álvarez and Díaz as one of casual acquaintance rather than frequent interaction. She also denied ever seeing Álvarez use drugs during their time together. Additional testimony is anticipated from others who were present during the incident, including Álvarez’s girlfriend at the time, his father, and a bystander who witnessed the altercation. These accounts aim to reconstruct the sequence of events leading up to the shooting and clarify the nature of the dispute between the two men. As the trial proceeds, the outcome will hinge on the evidence presented, the credibility of the witnesses, and the legal arguments surrounding Álvarez’s mental fitness to stand trial. The case continues to draw attention not only for its legal complexity but also for the broader implications regarding the rights of individuals with mental health conditions to participate fully in the justice system.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
AR
