My Sister Is Accusing Me of “Upstaging” Her at Her Own Wedding. There’s No Way What I Did Was So Wrong.

Dear Prudence

I thought it was a lovely surprise.

Advice by

Jenée Desmond-Harris

Enter your email to receive alerts for this author.

Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences.

Unsubscribe from email alerts

Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Jenée Desmond-Harris ?

June 15, 2026 6:00 AM

Photo illustration by Slate. Photo by ChrisGorgio/iStock/Getty Images Plus and Deagreez/Getty Images Plus.

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

Dear Prudence is Slate’s advice column.  Submit questions here .

Dear Prudence,

My sister “Nina” got married in early April, and she’s still angry over something my boyfriend did during the wedding reception. No, he didn’t get wasted, knock over the wedding cake, or make an unwanted pass at anyone. His crime? He proposed to me on the dance floor. After I accepted, people stopped dancing to briefly congratulate us, and then we all went back to having fun. Nina, however, says I completely “upstaged” her and accused me of trying to ruin her wedding by taking the attention away from her!

Now my sister is demanding that I apologize and says she won’t speak to me until I do.  She’s even dragged our mom into the act, and now my mom is on my case about it, too. I honestly had no idea my boyfriend was planning to propose to me at her wedding; it was just a pleasant surprise. My boyfriend says I have nothing to apologize for, and my mom and sister are completely out of line. I agree with him, but a part of me wonders if I should just give Nina a fake apology to restore peace in the family. Good idea, or should I stand my ground?

—Proposal Petulence

Dear Proposal,

There are two camps when it comes to proposals at weddings. Many people think they represent the most narcissistic, rude breach of etiquette imaginable. Others, like me, think, “Who cares??” The people getting married still had tons of attention for a long period of time leading up to the wedding, had their ceremony, took their photos, listened to speeches about them, received gifts, did their first dance, and had their guests’ undivided attention for all but five minutes of a very long day. What is the harm in a brief interlude during which the people present are, God forbid, happy for someone else? But even those who disagree with me would have to admit that it would be totally unfair to blame the person who was surprised when their partner got down on one knee.

Did Nina completely miss that your fiancé proposed to you, not the other way around? She’s being ridiculous, not to mention ruining her own newlywed days by being mad about something that’s over and can’t be undone.

Regular readers know I support offering an insincere apology to placate an unreasonable person. It costs you nothing, keeps their unhinged energy away from you, and leaves them stewing in their own misery when they realize they got what they wanted and are still unhappy. So if you want to say, “Nina, I’m sorry Kyle proposed to me at your wedding. I wish I’d told him not to do that,” go for it. That will take the temperature down a bit and maybe create some room to talk about what I suspect is the underlying issue: Nina feels you’ve always been prettier, more popular, or more loved in some way or another, and the proposal incident felt like confirmation of that dynamic. This feeling will rear its head again—when you have the nerve to graduate with your master’s degree during the same month her first child is born, or when you’re accused of trying to outdo her by taking the lead on planning a 50th anniversary party for your parents. Or when you make some misstep or another during your own wedding planning process. But actually, the way she and your mom are stressing you out about this actually makes me think you should show them what not stealing the spotlight really looks like and just elope.

Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don‘t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication.

Dear Prudence,

I am gay and old enough to remember when Ellen DeGeneres lost her sitcom for coming out. My mother was always on my side when it wasn’t trendy or well understood. She was the “theater mom” and considered the safe space for my kind of kids, even after I graduated. This is why this is so heartbreaking.

My brother’s kids are “Dee” and “Kay.” They are 10 and 6, respectively, and identify as nonbinary and trans. Their parents have been talking with multiple professionals for a while and decided it was in the kids’ best interest to move. Their state is bad enough for people like me. For kids, it is hell.

For my mom, it means her only grandchildren are not going to be within driving distance, and the high cost of living and m…