PolandThe case of the murder on Nowy Świat has been sent back to the first instance court after the Supreme Court annulled the appeal court's verdict. The decision was based on the claim that the first-instance court had an 'unfit composition,' specifically due to the involvement of a 'neo-judge'—a term referring to a judge who may lack independence or impartiality. The two defendants, Łukasz G. and Sebastian W., were originally sentenced to seven years in prison for their role in a fight that resulted in death. Their defense argued that the trial was compromised by the presence of this judge, which the Supreme Court agreed with, citing concerns over institutional impartiality and potential ties to executive power. The case will now be retried at the Warsaw District Court, while the conviction of a third defendant, Radosław W., remains in force.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): The article presents the legal reasoning behind the Supreme Court's decision without overtly favoring either side. It reports on the judicial process, the grounds for overturning the verdict, and the implications for the case, using neutral language and focusing on the legal arguments rather than a
