On July 3, 2026, the Portuguese Parliament approved a new legal framework for stateless individuals, known as the "statute of the apátrida." This legislation was introduced by the Social Democratic Party (PSD) and passed in its final vote with the opposition of the Chega party. The law received support from all left-wing parties, including the Socialist Party (PS), Left Bloc (Bloco de Esquerda), and the Free Party (Livre), as well as the PSD and the Initiative for Liberty (Iniciativa Liberal). The only votes against were cast by Chega, while the Center Democrat and Social Party (CDS) abstained.
The new statute defines a stateless person as someone who is not recognized as a national by any country under their respective laws or due to the application of the law. The status ceases upon acquiring Portuguese nationality or another nationality, or when another state grants a similar status. For minors seeking recognition as stateless, the law ensures they have the right to be accompanied by their parents throughout the process and receive legal assistance. The statute also provides temporary residence permits valid for six months, renewable until a final decision is made, along with access to free interpretation services, legal aid, healthcare, education, employment programs, and vocational training.
The approval of this law followed a contentious debate over another legislative proposal that had been rejected earlier in the day. That measure aimed to introduce a penalty of losing one's nationality for committing serious crimes such as homicide, trafficking, and terrorism-related offenses. However, the bill was vetoed by former President Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa and deemed unconstitutional by the Constitutional Court. Despite strong arguments from the government and the Chega party, which supported the measure, the bill failed to gain enough support in the final vote, receiving only 56 votes in favor compared to 152 against.
The minister of the Presidency, António Leitão Amaro, argued that the loss of nationality should be a consequence of grave crimes that undermine the social fabric and civic ties to the nation. He emphasized that the initiative was necessary to prevent individuals from committing serious offenses without facing consequences. However, the PSD faced criticism from Chega leader André Ventura, who accused them of weakening the proposed measures to appease the left and avoid political pressure. Ventura insisted that countries in Europe already apply such penalties and that Portugal should follow suit, particularly given the rise in human trafficking cases, which he claimed had increased by more than 300% in recent years.
The debate over the loss of nationality was part of broader negotiations between the PSD and Chega regarding the revision of the Nationality Law. These discussions had previously led to tensions, especially after the PSD’s defeat on labor reform and the approval of the Universal Social Allowance with the help of the PS. The PSD defended its position by stating that the Constitution allows for the loss of nationality in exceptional circumstances but that the new text respects the limits imposed by the Constitutional Court.
Meanwhile, the Chega party announced its intention to oppose amendments to the so-called "burqa law," which prohibits the concealment of faces in public spaces for religious reasons. The PSD had proposed changes to the law, focusing on security concerns rather than religious motivations, but Chega refused to accept these modifications. This stance could potentially block the final approval of both the nationality loss bill and the burqa law, as the Chega party has threatened to vote against any compromises.
The political landscape remains tense, with the Chega party accusing the PSD of failing to uphold agreements reached during previous negotiations. Meanwhile, the Socialist Party criticized the current government for being influenced by Chega and suggested that Prime Minister Luís Montenegro might eventually return to the Chega party, citing his apparent alignment with their policies despite the government's challenges. The situation highlights the ongoing power struggles within Portuguese politics and the complexities surrounding immigration, nationality, and civil liberties.
5 informaciones
Diário de NotíciasIndependienteDerechaVeracidad 95Objetividad 70hace 15 hEl Parlamento portugués rechazó un decreto propuesto que habría impuesto la pena accesoria de perder la nacionalidad para las personas que cometen delitos graves, como el terrorismo, la trata de personas y el homicidio. El proyecto de ley había sido vetado previamente por el ex presidente Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa y se enfrentó a dos desafíos constitucionales por parte del Tribunal Constitucional. Mientras que el gobierno y los partidos de derecha argumentaron que la medida era necesaria para la seguridad nacional, la mayoría de los parlamentarios votaron en contra, con el apoyo solo de los partidos Chega y CDS. La propuesta tenía como objetivo despojar de la ciudadanía a aquellos que cometieron delitos graves, pero incluía disposiciones que permitían la reacquisición de la nacionalidad después de 1025 años dependiendo del delito. André Ventura de Chega defendió la idea como un principio derivado de las negociaciones con el PSD durante la revisión de la Ley de Nacionalidad.
Lectura del sesgo (Derecha): El artículo hace hincapié en los argumentos presentados por el gobierno y los partidos de derecha que abogan por medidas más estrictas contra los delincuentes, incluida la pérdida de la nacionalidad, mientras que describe la oposición de los partidos de izquierda como una desestimación de la iniciativa.
Por qué estas puntuaciones (Veracidad 95 · Objetividad 70): The article presents the rejection of the decree on loss of nationality with precise details on the voting outcome and the arguments from both sides. The minister's speech is reported fairly, though the overall tone shows a slight inclination toward supporting the government's position on national s
Diário de NotíciasIndependienteDerechaVeracidad 90Objetividad 70ayer Ventura anuncia voto en contra de las enmiendas del PSD sobre pérdida de nacionalidad y ley de burkasThe article discusses political tensions between the Chega party and the PSD regarding two legislative proposals: one concerning the loss of nationality for individuals committing certain crimes, and another related to the 'burqa law' regulating face concealment in public spaces. President of Chega, André Ventura, announced he would vote against amendments proposed by the PSD to both bills, arguing they dilute the original intent of the legislation. The PSD has introduced a third version of the nationality law, narrowing the scope of crimes leading to loss of nationality compared to previous drafts. In response to changes to the 'burqa law', Ventura criticized the PSD for shifting focus from religious reasons to security concerns. He accused the PSD of undermining the original project and suggested that if Chega votes against the proposals, they could fail due to lack of consensus. Ventura emphasized that the PSD should reconsider whether it prefers to achieve nothing or maintain the existing consensus.
Lectura del sesgo (Derecha): The article frames the debate through the lens of Chega’s opposition to what it perceives as the PSD’s attempt to weaken the original legislation. Language used suggests a strong ideological stance, particularly in criticizing the PSD for allegedly failing to uphold societal values and legal norms.
Por qué estas puntuaciones (Veracidad 90 · Objetividad 70): This article provides clear facts about the rejection of the bill regarding loss of nationality and the stance of Chega against the PSD proposals. It quotes Andre Ventura directly but uses some emotionally charged language such as 'shows that, in truth, it does not want to change anything in our soc
Diário de NotíciasIndependienteIzquierdaVeracidad 85Objetividad 75hace 14 h Nuevo estatuto del apátrida aprobado en votación final sólo con la oposición de ChegaLa Asamblea de la República Portuguesa aprobó, el 3 de julio de 2026, el nuevo estatuto para las personas apátridas a través de una votación final. La legislación se originó a partir de una propuesta socialdemócrata y recibió el apoyo de todos los partidos de izquierda, el PSD y la Iniciativa Liberal, con solo la CDS absteniéndose y el Chega oponiéndose. La ley define a una persona apátrida como alguien que no es reconocido como nacional por ningún estado bajo el derecho internacional. Delinea las condiciones bajo las cuales cesa la apatridia, incluida la adquisición de la nacionalidad portuguesa o la ciudadanía de otra nación. La ley también garantiza la participación de los padres en procedimientos que involucran a menores.
Lectura del sesgo (Izquierda): El artículo enmarca la aprobación del estatuto como un logro progresista, enfatizando el amplio apoyo bipartidista de partidos izquierdistas y grupos centristas como el PSD e Iniciativa Liberal.
Por qué estas puntuaciones (Veracidad 85 · Objetividad 75): The article accurately reports the approval of the new status for stateless individuals by the Assembly of the Republic, noting the opposition from Chega and the inclusion of suggestions from various parties. However, it leans slightly towards the political positions of the left and PSD, using terms
PúblicoIndependienteDerechaVeracidad 85Objetividad 65hace 23 hThe article discusses the potential motivations behind the PSD's insistence on maintaining ties with Chega, suggesting it may stem from a desire to counteract setbacks such as the failure of labor law reforms and the approval of the Unified Social Benefit with the support of the PS. The editorial by Marta Moitinho Oliveira frames this behavior as politically strategic, highlighting the complex interplay between parties in Portuguese politics.
Lectura del sesgo (Derecha): The article implies that the PSD's actions are driven by strategic considerations rather than ideological alignment, which suggests a focus on pragmatic outcomes over broader political principles. This framing leans toward a right-wing perspective by emphasizing tactical maneuvering over collective,
Por qué estas puntuaciones (Veracidad 85 · Objetividad 65): The article discusses the persistence of the PSD on the issue of losing nationality and speculates on their interest in maintaining ties with Chega. While it offers analysis, it also includes editorial commentary suggesting a specific viewpoint rather than presenting a neutral assessment.
RTP NotíciasEstatal / públicoIzquierdaVeracidad 80Objetividad 55hace 5 dCarlos César, presidente del Partido Socialista de Portugal (PS), declaró durante una reunión de la Comisión Nacional del PS que el primer ministro Luís Montenegro, líder del partido de centroderecha PSD, exhibe síntomas del síndrome de Estocolmo con respecto al partido de extrema derecha Chega. César afirmó que a pesar de que el gobierno del PSD está "rehenado" por Chega y repetidamente engañado por él, Montenegro parece haber desarrollado un cariño por Chega y puede volver a ellos. Argumentó que la alternativa al extremismo en la sociedad portuguesa no son los partidos menos extremos sino los no extremistas, posicionando al PS como la opción viable contra el gobierno actual. César enfatizó el compromiso del PS con el buen gobierno y su papel en la configuración de las relaciones con el gobierno de la República.
Lectura del sesgo (Izquierda): El artículo enmarca al gobierno actual como bajo la influencia del partido de extrema derecha Chega y sugiere que el primer ministro Luís Montenegro tiene una visión favorable de Chega, lo que implica una evaluación negativa del liderazgo del gobierno.
Por qué estas puntuaciones (Veracidad 80 · Objetividad 55): The article makes a strong claim about Luis Montenegro having Stockholm Syndrome and returning to Chega, which lacks sufficient evidence and appears more like opinion than fact. The language used is highly biased and subjective.
★
Mantengamos las noticias honestas.
ObjectiveNews se financia con los lectores y no tiene anuncios: te mostramos el sesgo en lugar de ocultarlo. Apoya el periodismo independiente por 5 €/mes.
Hazte suscriptor
PT
