Slovenia🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives
Concerns raised over emerging US-Slovenia nuclear energy deal
Slovenia’s Ministry of Infrastructure and Energy faces accusations of conducting undisclosed negotiations with the United States regarding a bilateral nuclear energy agreement that would favor Westinghouse as the supplier for a new unit at the Krsko nuclear power plant. The proposed project, estimated to cost between 15 and 22 billion euros, follows the withdrawal of South Korea’s KHNP from consideration, leaving Westinghouse and France’s EDF as primary candidates. Although a consultative referendum on the project was initially planned for late 2024, the initiative was abandoned after leaked recordings suggested collusion between major political parties to ensure the project’s passage regardless of voter sentiment. Environmental non-governmental organizations have criticized the lack of transparency, arguing that the draft agreement violates European Union competition laws by restricting market access and urging the immediate suspension of confidential talks. In response to requests for the updated draft, the ministry refused disclosure, citing the informal status of the negotiations and concerns that releasing the text could prejudice final outcomes or damage international relations.
Slovenian environmental groups have demanded the immediate suspension of confidential negotiations regarding a bilateral nuclear energy agreement with the United States. The organizations argue that the emerging pact unlawfully favors the American firm Westinghouse as the preferred supplier for a new unit at the country’s sole nuclear power plant. This demand followed the Ministry of Infrastructure and Energy’s refusal to release a newly drafted intergovernmental accord to the public. The ministry confirmed it received a fresh proposal from Washington but blocked media access, citing ongoing informal consultations. Critics warn the move violates European Union competition rules and could lock Slovenia into a financially dependent relationship with the US. The controversy centers on the planned construction of a second reactor unit at the Krsko Nuclear Power Plant, located on the border with Croatia. The existing facility, built by Westinghouse, began operations in the early 1980s. Following the withdrawal of South Korea’s KHNP from the bidding process, attention shifted to Westinghouse and France’s EDF as leading candidates. Project costs are estimated between 15 and 22 billion euros, varying by technology and scale. Although supported by successive governments, the initiative faced a crisis in late 2024. A planned consultative referendum was cancelled after leaked wiretaps suggested collusion between major political parties to secure the project regardless of voter sentiment. The current administration has since abandoned plans for a vote. Details of the diplomatic friction emerged through transparency requests. Last December, journalists obtained a draft agreement via a freedom of information law. That document outlined joint financing mechanisms and indicated a clear preference for an American reactor technology. The outgoing government published the text online and pledged not to sign any documents restricting competition before its term ended. Under the new leadership, however, the ministry removed the old draft from state websites. It acknowledged receiving a new US proposal in June, a fact previously reported by local media. When asked for the new text, the ministry invoked legal protections for documents in the drafting phase. Officials stated that formal procedures for concluding the treaty have not started. They argued that releasing the document, even partially, could misrepresent Slovenia’s negotiating stance, prejudice the final outcome, or damage international relations. The ministry noted that the government has not approved public release. Public broadcaster RTV Slovenija has appealed this decision to the Information Commissioner. A coalition of non-governmental organizations held a press conference in Ljubljana on November 5 to protest the secrecy. They accused the ministry of engaging in back-channel talks that eliminate market competition. The group urged authorities to halt confidential discussions, publish the current draft, and ensure open tendering to protect public funds. They insisted no binding agreements be signed until a referendum occurs, preceded by broad public debate on geopolitical implications and alternative energy scenarios, including non-nuclear options. Jonas Sonnenschein of the environmental group Umanotera emphasized that an intergovernmental treaty carries legal weight unlike standard memoranda. He warned that a financing clause involving the US Export-Import Bank would bypass international tendering processes and create long-term fiscal reliance on Washington. The NGOs cautioned that such an agreement could face legal challenges at the Constitutional Court and the European Court of Justice. The ministry rejected these accusations. It maintained that the agreement concerns general technology standards rather than selecting a specific vendor. Furthermore, officials claimed the pact would carry no direct financial consequences for Slovenia. Despite this, Infrastructure Minister Jernej Vrtovec recently stated the government intends to advance the Krsko 2 project. The legal basis for withholding the document relies on the Law on Access to Information of Public Interest. Article 6 allows refusal if disclosure causes misunderstanding during the preparation phase. Additionally, the Law on International Treaties restricts access to coordination documents unless the cabinet determines that release will not harm national interests or international relations. Since the government has not made such a determination, access remains excluded. The situation highlights a growing tension between executive discretion in foreign policy and civic demands for transparency in high-stakes infrastructure decisions.
The Ministry of Infrastructure and Energy has confirmed receiving a new draft intergovernmental agreement with the United States regarding nuclear energy cooperation, specifically concerning the second unit of the Krsko Nuclear Power Plant. The ministry removed the previous draft from its website and denied a request for public access to the new document under the Freedom of Information Act, citing that it is still in the drafting phase and disclosure could cause misunderstanding. Earlier this year, the previous draft was revealed to favor US technology suppliers, prompting the then-government to state they would not sign any agreement limiting competition before their term ended. The current minister, Jernej Vrtovec, stated that only informal talks are ongoing and formal procedures have not yet begun. The article notes that the removal of the old document and the refusal to share the new one raise questions about transparency in the procurement process for the new nuclear power plant.
Bias read (Progressive): The article emphasizes the government's refusal to disclose documents under freedom of information laws and highlights prior concerns about limiting competition, framing the issue through a lens of democratic accountability and transparency typical of critical oversight journalism.
Why factuality (75): Accurately reflects the core facts: receipt of a new US draft, removal of the old one, and denial of public access. It correctly cites the prior FOIA disclosure and the previous government's stance. Minor deduction because the text appears truncated mid-sentence ('...sodel'), preventing full verific
Why objectivity (85): Maintains a largely neutral journalistic tone. While it uses slightly critical phrasing like 'naklonjenost' (favoritism) regarding the US supplier, this is directly supported by the content of the previously disclosed document rather than being pure editorializing.
The Slovenia TimesIndependentProgressiveFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 70
Slovenia’s Ministry of Infrastructure and Energy faces accusations of conducting undisclosed negotiations with the United States regarding a bilateral nuclear energy agreement that would favor Westinghouse as the supplier for a new unit at the Krsko nuclear power plant. The proposed project, estimated to cost between 15 and 22 billion euros, follows the withdrawal of South Korea’s KHNP from consideration, leaving Westinghouse and France’s EDF as primary candidates. Although a consultative referendum on the project was initially planned for late 2024, the initiative was abandoned after leaked recordings suggested collusion between major political parties to ensure the project’s passage regardless of voter sentiment. Environmental non-governmental organizations have criticized the lack of transparency, arguing that the draft agreement violates European Union competition laws by restricting market access and urging the immediate suspension of confidential talks. In response to requests for the updated draft, the ministry refused disclosure, citing the informal status of the negotiations and concerns that releasing the text could prejudice final outcomes or damage international relations.
Bias read (Progressive): The article emphasizes NGO criticisms of anti-competitive practices and highlights the removal of documents from public websites, framing the government's secrecy as a violation of democratic norms and EU law rather than a legitimate security measure.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (70): Uses somewhat charged language such as 'accused of being in secret talks' and highlights the 'leaked wiretap' scandal, which frames the narrative more critically toward the government. This reduces neutrality compared to a purely descriptive account.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.