ON
← Back to feed
Why are trees important? 'If we keep them, cities will become concrete ovens'
Croatia🏛️ PoliticsCenteryesterday

Why are trees important? 'If we keep them, cities will become concrete ovens'

Fran Poštenjak, Croatia's first doctor for trees, warns that without urban trees, Croatian cities risk becoming concrete ovens. He emphasizes that mature trees provide cooling, water retention, and other ecological benefits, which are crucial for climate resilience. The loss of trees is not just aesthetic but also financial, leading to higher cooling costs, increased pressure on healthcare systems, flood risks, and decades of waiting for new trees to replace lost functions. Scientific research confirms that proximity to urban greenery reduces stress, mitigates heat islands, cleans air, retains rainwater, and protects health from extreme heat. Poštenjak argues that investing in quality tree planting is an investment in safety, health, and city resilience. This season's droughts will have visible effects by autumn, with trees suffering irreversible damage due to high temperatures and lack of water.

Fran Poštenjak, the first Croatian doctor for trees, has issued a stark warning that without urban trees, Croatian cities will become "concrete ovens." His comments come amid rising concerns over extreme heatwaves, prolonged droughts, and the increasing vulnerability of urban greenery. According to Poštenjak, the loss of mature trees is not just an aesthetic issue, it represents a massive financial burden and a threat to public health, infrastructure resilience, and climate adaptation efforts. The warning comes as Croatia, like much of Europe, faces unprecedented levels of heat, with temperatures regularly exceeding 35°C during summer months. The period from June to September, which marks the peak of vegetation growth, has seen a sharp decline in rainfall, placing immense stress on urban tree populations. Urban trees, which provide essential cooling, air purification, and flood mitigation benefits, are among the first casualties of these environmental pressures. Poštenjak emphasizes that without proper watering and strategic planting, cities risk losing their primary defense against extreme heat, potentially transforming into "concrete ovens." Urban trees play a critical role in mitigating the effects of urban heat islands, areas where built environments absorb and retain more heat than surrounding rural areas. Studies have shown that proximity to urban greenery reduces stress, improves air quality, retains rainwater, and protects public health from the impacts of extreme weather. Mature trees, especially large ones such as oaks, beeches, and maples, are particularly effective in providing shade, reducing noise pollution, and increasing property values. They also contribute to improved mental and physical well-being among residents. However, the current state of urban forests in Croatia is under severe strain. During periods of intense heat, the water consumption of mature trees can increase dramatically, from around 150 to 200 liters per day at moderate temperatures to over 600 liters daily when temperatures exceed 35°C. This increased demand is exacerbated by the prevalence of asphalt and concrete surfaces, which trap and radiate heat, further intensifying the stress on trees. Without adequate irrigation and soil preparation, urban trees face a high risk of long-term damage or death. One of the most alarming consequences of prolonged drought is the phenomenon known as "summer branch drop," where heavy lower branches of mature trees break unexpectedly due to weakened structures. This poses a direct danger to pedestrians and property. In addition, extended dry spells lead to visible signs of distress in trees, including leaf drop, wilting, and even complete dieback of parts of the plant. These symptoms often go unnoticed until late autumn, when the true extent of the damage becomes apparent. Another major challenge facing urban trees is compacted soil, a result of years of foot traffic, vehicle movement, and construction activities. Compacted soil prevents water and air from reaching tree roots, making them highly susceptible to dehydration and disease. Poštenjak stresses that proper planning and maintenance are crucial to ensuring the survival of urban trees. He advocates for deep root watering, high-quality soil, and careful planting techniques to build resilience against future climatic shocks. In response to the growing crisis, experts emphasize the need for proactive measures rather than reactive solutions. Planning for tree resilience should begin before planting, not after damage occurs. This includes selecting appropriate species, preparing suitable soil conditions, and implementing sustainable irrigation strategies. With climate change continuing to drive more frequent and severe heatwaves, the importance of urban trees as a key component of city infrastructure, and as a vital tool in building climate resilience, has never been clearer.

3 reports

Novi list logoNovi listIndependentCenterFactual 97Objective 88yesterday
Cities will become concrete ovens, warns Croatia's first tree doctor

The article highlights concerns raised by Fran Poštenjak, Croatia's first urban forestry doctor, regarding the loss of urban trees and its impact on city resilience. He warns that without changes in urban greenery management, Croatian cities risk becoming 'concrete ovens' due to extreme heat. Poštenjak emphasizes that mature trees provide essential ecological benefits such as cooling, water retention, and protection against health risks. He notes that tree loss leads to increased costs for cooling, higher pressure on healthcare systems, and greater flood risks. The article also discusses the effects of current drought conditions, explaining how urban trees are among the most vulnerable components of city infrastructure. It stresses the importance of proper watering, soil quality, and planning to ensure urban forests remain resilient against climate challenges.

Bias read (Center): While the topic involves environmental policy and urban planning, key areas of public concern, the article presents factual information based on scientific research and expert opinion without overtly promoting a specific ideological stance. The framing remains balanced, focusing on the consequences of

Why factuality (97): This article closely mirrors the first one, accurately quoting Fran Poštenjak and presenting his arguments about the role of urban trees in climate resilience. All key points are supported by the speaker’s statements and general scientific consensus. The only minor issue is a slight formatting incon

Why objectivity (88): The tone remains mostly neutral and informative, with minimal editorializing. Some phrases such as 'betonirane pećnice' still carry a metaphorical weight, but overall the article maintains a balanced perspective without overt bias.

N1 Hrvatska logoN1 HrvatskaIndependentCenterFactual 96Objective 84yesterday
Expert: "If we are left without urban trees, Croatian cities will become concrete ovens"

Dr. Fran Poštenjak, prvi hrvatski doktor za drveće, upozorava na opasnosti gubitka urbanih stabala i njihovog utjecaja na klimatsku otpornost Hrvatske. Naglašava da gradovi bez stabala postaju 'betonirane pećnice' zbog ekstremnih vrućina, što dovodi do većih troškova hlađenja, pritiska na zdravstveni sustav, rizika poplava i dugoročnih gubitaka funkcionalnosti stabala. Ističe da urbani stabla smanjuju stres, smanjuju toplinske otoci, čiste zrak, zadržavaju vodu i poboljšavaju zdravlje stanovnika. Upozorava da su suše i ekstremne temperature posebno opasne za stabla, jer ih izlažu vodnom stresu, a posljedice se vide tek na jesen. Poziva na pametno planiranje sadnje i dobro natapanje kako bi se osigurala otpornost gradova.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a scientific and environmental concern regarding urban trees and their role in climate resilience, without taking a partisan stance. It emphasizes data, expert opinion, and ecological impact rather than promoting any specific political ideology. The framing remains objective, as

Why factuality (96): The article accurately conveys Fran Poštenjak’s concerns regarding the loss of urban trees and their impact on climate resilience. It includes direct quotes and aligns with the broader scientific consensus on the environmental and health benefits of urban green spaces. The only minor issue is the in

Why objectivity (84): The article is generally neutral in tone but uses emotionally charged metaphors like 'betonirane pećnice,' which can influence perception. While it avoids overtly biased language, the choice of phrasing slightly reduces its objectivity score compared to the others.

tportal logotportalIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 85yesterday
Why are trees important? 'If we keep them, cities will become concrete ovens'

Fran Poštenjak, Croatia's first doctor for trees, warns that without urban trees, Croatian cities risk becoming concrete ovens. He emphasizes that mature trees provide cooling, water retention, and other ecological benefits, which are crucial for climate resilience. The loss of trees is not just aesthetic but also financial, leading to higher cooling costs, increased pressure on healthcare systems, flood risks, and decades of waiting for new trees to replace lost functions. Scientific research confirms that proximity to urban greenery reduces stress, mitigates heat islands, cleans air, retains rainwater, and protects health from extreme heat. Poštenjak argues that investing in quality tree planting is an investment in safety, health, and city resilience. This season's droughts will have visible effects by autumn, with trees suffering irreversible damage due to high temperatures and lack of water.

Bias read (Center): The article presents scientific evidence and expert opinion on the importance of urban trees for climate resilience and public health. It does not take a clear ideological stance, focusing instead on environmental and practical concerns. The framing is neutral, emphasizing data and expert warnings.

Why factuality (95): The article accurately reports Fran Poštenjak’s warnings about the importance of urban trees in combating extreme heat and climate change. It includes direct quotes from him and cites scientific consensus on the benefits of urban greenery. The only minor deduction comes from the incomplete ending of

Why objectivity (85): The article presents the information in a largely neutral manner, focusing on Poštenjak’s statements and scientific evidence. However, some phrases like 'betonirane pećnice' (concrete ovens) carry a strong metaphorical tone that may imply an emotional stance rather than purely objective reporting.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories