ON
← Back to feed
Sydney private school put dog collar and lead on student, inquiry hears
Australia🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives9 days ago

Sydney private school put dog collar and lead on student, inquiry hears

A parliamentary inquiry in Australia is examining allegations of abuse and financial misconduct against Redeemer Baptist School and its affiliated church. Helen Johnstone, a former member, testified that her sister was subjected to harsh treatment, including wearing a dog collar and being pulled by a lead, as well as being submerged in a duck pond. She also described systemic abuse of her foster brother, an Indigenous boy believed to be part of the stolen generations, including physical punishment. Witness Graeme Glossop, a former accountant, alleged the institution operated a scheme to avoid taxation, calling it a 'criminal gang' using religion as cover. Accounting expert Clinton Free supported these claims, noting potential fringe benefits tax obligations. The inquiry continues to explore the extent of abuse and financial irregularities within the organization.

A former member of Redeemer Baptist School and Church has testified before a parliamentary inquiry that her sister was placed in a dog collar and dragged by a lead, describing the institution as a place of severe abuse and control. The testimony, delivered on the second day of hearings, comes amid growing scrutiny over the North Parramatta private school and its affiliated religious organization, which has been labeled a “cult” by some witnesses. Helen Johnstone, speaking at the inquiry, recounted how her family joined the community in 1976 when she was a child, marking the beginning of a deeply troubling period for her and her siblings. Johnstone described a dramatic shift in her life shortly after joining the group. She and her sisters began experiencing feelings of discomfort and fear, noting a sharp deterioration in their quality of life. Her older sister was regarded as a “rebel” and endured regular abuse. According to Johnstone, she witnessed her sister being placed in a dog collar and pulled around by a lead. Additionally, she claimed her sister was held underwater and thrown into a “filthy duck pond.” The sister was also subjected to constant shunning, shaming, and humiliation. Johnstone also spoke about the abuse of her foster brother, an Indigenous boy she believes may have been part of the stolen generations. She described how her father physically assaulted him while he lay curled in a fetal position. In her account, the boy's education was defined by punishment rather than learning. He was beaten regularly for minor infractions such as not eating, providing incorrect homework answers, or soiling his clothes. Despite these abuses, the boy was eventually adopted into the family. Johnstone expressed a desire for further investigation into the circumstances surrounding his arrival in the community. Corporal punishment was reportedly a routine practice within the church, according to multiple witnesses. This form of discipline continued as recently as 2005. The inquiry also received allegations of widespread financial misconduct involving the school and church. Graeme Glossop, an accountant who previously worked with the institution in 2004, accused the organization of running a “scheme of arrangement designed to avoid taxation.” He characterized the school and church as a “criminal gang who uses religion as camouflage” and claimed they were “stealing government money.” Glossop asserted that the school and church were not paying fringe benefits tax, a claim backed by University of Sydney accounting professor Clinton Free. Free noted that given the workers received an “extremely modest stipend” along with additional benefits such as housing and a vehicle, there appeared to be a tax obligation. Glossop likened the situation to a “disease” affecting the entire community, comparing it to a “cancer” that continues to impact individuals. Barney Jones, a former member, testified that the institution exploited legal loopholes to accumulate substantial wealth. He cited the ownership of at least 40 properties valued at a minimum of $140 million. Jones explained that by offering low stipends to volunteers, the institution avoided several taxes, including payroll tax, GST, capital gains tax, fringe benefits tax, stamp duty, and HECS repayments. He also mentioned the phenomenon of “double-dipping,” where members accessed Centrelink benefits to sustain their lifestyle despite having artificially low incomes. Jones presented a 102-page dossier detailing alleged violations of legislation and employment practices. He stated that he had raised concerns with the Board of Studies, now known as the NSW Education Standards Authority, in 2005, but his efforts were met with indifference. On Monday, NESA confirmed it was investigating the school under Section 83C of the Education Act, which mandates that non-government schools must operate on a not-for-profit basis to maintain eligibility.

2 reports

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 709 days ago
Sydney private school put dog collar and lead on student, inquiry hears

A parliamentary inquiry in Australia is examining allegations of abuse and financial misconduct against Redeemer Baptist School and its affiliated church. Helen Johnstone, a former member, testified that her sister was subjected to harsh treatment, including wearing a dog collar and being pulled by a lead, as well as being submerged in a duck pond. She also described systemic abuse of her foster brother, an Indigenous boy believed to be part of the stolen generations, including physical punishment. Witness Graeme Glossop, a former accountant, alleged the institution operated a scheme to avoid taxation, calling it a 'criminal gang' using religion as cover. Accounting expert Clinton Free supported these claims, noting potential fringe benefits tax obligations. The inquiry continues to explore the extent of abuse and financial irregularities within the organization.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the allegations against the school and church in strongly negative terms, emphasizing abuse and criminal behavior. While the subject is a specific institution, the language used ('criminal gang', 'stealing government money') reflects a left-leaning critique of religious groups and

Why factuality (85): This article mirrors the content of the previous one, reporting similar testimonies from Helen Johnstone regarding the alleged use of a dog collar and lead on students. It references the parliamentary inquiry and the description of the school as a 'cult,' indicating alignment with the broader narrat

Why objectivity (70): Similar to the first article, this piece uses emotive language such as 'criminal gang' and 'cult,' which may reflect the bias of the witnesses rather than an impartial analysis. The tone remains consistent with the first article, presenting the allegations without clear distinction between personal

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 709 days ago
Sydney private school put dog collar and lead on student, inquiry hears

A parliamentary inquiry in Australia is examining allegations against Redeemer Baptist School and its affiliated church, which has been described as a 'cult.' Helen Johnstone, a former member, testified that her sister was subjected to severe mistreatment, including wearing a dog collar and being dragged by a leash, as well as being submerged in a contaminated duck pond. She also recounted witnessing physical abuse of her foster brother, an Indigenous individual believed to be part of the stolen generations. Additional testimony from accountant Graeme Glossop and University of Sydney professor Clinton Free alleged financial misconduct, claiming the institution operated a scheme to evade taxation by not paying fringe benefits tax despite providing substantial non-cash benefits to staff.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the allegations against the school and church in a highly critical light, using strong language such as 'criminal gang,' 'cult,' and 'disease' to describe the institution. It emphasizes testimonies from individuals who claim to have suffered abuse and exploitation, suggesting a sl

Why factuality (85): The article reports on testimony from Helen Johnstone, a former member of Redeemer Baptist School and Church, describing alleged abuses including the use of a dog collar and lead on students. These accounts are presented as part of a parliamentary inquiry, suggesting they are based on credible sourc

Why objectivity (70): The article presents the allegations in a somewhat dramatic manner, using phrases like 'criminal gang' and 'cult,' which may reflect the perspective of the witnesses rather than an objective assessment. While it reports the testimony accurately, the language used could be seen as emotionally charged

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories