ON
← Back to feed
Released Youssef, the extremist pro-PAL: "He is not a violent person"
Italy🏛️ PoliticsLean Conservative

Released Youssef, the extremist pro-PAL: "He is not a violent person"

A Milan court has released Youssef Siher, a 30-year-old activist associated with the 'October 17 Movement,' after rejecting charges of aggravated incitement to crime linked to terrorism. The investigating judge, Tiziana Landoni, ruled that Siher’s online messages did not advocate for violent actions but rather promoted collective awareness and legitimate constitutional protest against current government policies. This decision directly contradicts the prosecution’s earlier request for detention, which argued that his communications aimed to intimidate the population and support logistical coordination for riots. The judge further determined that Siher bore no direct responsibility for violent posts made by other users within the movement’s Telegram chats or Instagram pages. Defense attorneys indicated that Siher may resume posting online soon, while the prosecution had previously characterized his activities as part of a strategy to create chaos and undermine the democratic order.

Simonetta Matone, a deputy for Forza Italia, engaged in a heated verbal altercation with Edmondo Bruti Liberati during a broadcast of L’aria che tira on La7. The dispute centered on the release of Youssef Siher, a thirty-year-old man detained on charges related to terrorism and instigation to commit crimes. The exchange escalated into shouting matches, mutual accusations, and laughter, culminating in Matone threatening to leave the studio unless the host muted her guest. She demanded that Bruti Liberati remain silent, stating she would depart if his audio was not cut. The conflict arose over the judicial decision by Judge Tiziana Landoni, the investigating magistrate at the Milan court, who ordered Siher’s release. Bruti Liberati, speaking via video link, criticized Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s comments regarding the judge, describing them as an unacceptable insult to the judiciary. He argued that the reference to terrorism in the Milan prosecutor’s office case file was so unfounded that the judge dismissed it in very few pages. Matone interrupted him repeatedly, prompting Bruti Liberati to correct her address, telling her to watch her words. This remark triggered the initial flare-up, with Matone insisting she should be addressed as Honorable or Doctor, noting that he would not call a male colleague Sir. She accused him of using informal terms reserved for family members. Bruti Liberati attempted to return to the legal merits, explaining that Judge Landoni did not validate the detention because there was no instigation to commit crimes. He stated that the judge strictly applied principles from the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court. Specifically, he noted that the portion of an Egyptian manual shared online did not contain calls for violence, thus negating the charge. Matone shifted focus, accusing Bruti Liberati of failing to distance himself from the events of December 17. Maurizio Acerbo, secretary of the Communist Refoundation party, interjected to suggest that distancing oneself from such events is difficult. Bruti Liberati reacted sharply, asking what he needed to dissociate from and reminding Matone that he served as chief prosecutor in Milan for a lifetime. Matone retorted that he had done a poor job. Bruti Liberati countered that he had sent ISIS terrorists to trial and secured their convictions. The debate continued as Matone criticized Bruti Liberati for calling the indictment vulgar, reminding him that the judicial office is not a local greengrocer. When Bruti Liberati tried to respond, again using the term madam, Matone exploded, ordering him to shut up and declaring her intention to leave. She claimed his behavior demonstrated the arrogance of certain magistrates. Bruti Liberati burst into laughter while Matone returned to the topic of the October 17 events. He joked that he could even dissociate from the assassination of King Umberto I if she wished. Finally, Matone turned to host David Parenzo, issuing an ultimatum to either mute Bruti Liberati or allow her to exit the program. Background details from the legal proceedings reveal that Judge Landoni completely rejected the prosecution’s framework. She determined that Siher’s messages did not plan violent actions but instead promoted a collective mobilization against government policies. The judge viewed these acts as a legitimate exercise of constitutional freedoms rather than criminal conduct. Prosecutors Francesca Crupi and Marcello Viola had previously argued that Siher aimed to inflict serious damage on the state and intimidate the population. They described the Telegram chats and associated Instagram page used by Siher as logistical support for creating chaos among protesters. However, the judge found no evidence of direct responsibility for posts made by other users in those groups, including violent ones. The judge also analyzed a document titled Revolution, Instructions for Use, which prosecutors considered a guide for clashes. She concluded it did not contemplate gathering people for violent acts. Furthermore, Siher’s call to act like in France was interpreted as a reference to the persistence and activism of French protest movements rather than violence. Although released, Siher remains under investigation for the alleged offenses. His lawyers, Benedetto Ciccarone and Yasmina Abu Sharar, indicated he might resume posting online soon. The prosecution has not excluded appealing the decision to the Review Tribunal. Meanwhile, judges within the Council of the Judiciary have requested the opening of a protective procedure for Judge Landoni following the Prime Minister’s statements about her ruling.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 3 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

3 reports

Il Fatto Quotidiano logoIl Fatto QuotidianoIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 70
Lady says to her sister. Furious fight between thugs and freed animals on La7, screaming, laughing and threatening to leave the studio

A heated verbal altercation erupted during the broadcast of the Italian television program 'L'aria che tira' on La7, involving Forza Italia deputy Simonetta Matone and former Milan Chief Prosecutor Edmondo Bruti Liberati. The dispute centered on the release of Youssef Siher by Milan magistrate Tiziana Landoni and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's subsequent criticism of the judicial decision. Bruti Liberati defended the magistrate's ruling against Meloni's remarks, while Matone challenged his professional conduct and his stance on past security incidents. The exchange escalated into personal insults regarding forms of address and professional competence, prompting Matone to threaten to leave the studio if her co-host did not intervene. The incident highlighted ongoing tensions between political figures and legal professionals regarding recent terrorism-related cases in Italy.

Bias read (Center): The article reports on a televised political dispute using descriptive but largely neutral language ('heated', 'verbal altercation'). It presents arguments from both sides without explicitly endorsing one over the other, focusing on the procedural breakdown of the debate rather than taking a stance.

Why factuality (85): The article provides specific details regarding the TV show 'L'aria che tira', naming participants (Matone, Bruti Liberati, Parenzo) and quoting specific exchanges. It aligns with the broader context of the Siher case mentioned in other sources. However, as no primary transcript was available, the e

Why objectivity (70): The tone is somewhat sensationalist, using phrases like 'Scontro al fulmicotone' (flashpoint clash) and describing the scene as having 'involuntary comic interludes.' While it reports the conflict, the framing emphasizes the chaotic and humorous nature of the dispute rather than treating it as a ser

Il Giornale logoIl GiornaleParty-alignedConservativeFactual 80Objective 60
Released Youssef, the extremist pro-PAL: "He is not a violent person"

A Milan court has released Youssef Siher, a 30-year-old activist associated with the 'October 17 Movement,' after rejecting charges of aggravated incitement to crime linked to terrorism. The investigating judge, Tiziana Landoni, ruled that Siher’s online messages did not advocate for violent actions but rather promoted collective awareness and legitimate constitutional protest against current government policies. This decision directly contradicts the prosecution’s earlier request for detention, which argued that his communications aimed to intimidate the population and support logistical coordination for riots. The judge further determined that Siher bore no direct responsibility for violent posts made by other users within the movement’s Telegram chats or Instagram pages. Defense attorneys indicated that Siher may resume posting online soon, while the prosecution had previously characterized his activities as part of a strategy to create chaos and undermine the democratic order.

Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the judicial release of a pro-Palestinian activist as a significant failure of the prosecution's case, using strong language such as 'shatters completely' regarding the accusations. It emphasizes the judge's view that the activism was a 'legitimate exercise of constitutional fre

Why factuality (80): The article accurately reflects the legal outcome described in the consensus (Siher released, judge rejected terrorism charges). It cites specific names (Judge Landoni, Prosecutors Crupi/Viola, Lawyers) and quotes the reasoning used by the court. However, it includes interpretive summaries of the me

Why objectivity (60): The headline uses the label 'pro-Pal extremist,' which is a charged term that frames the subject negatively before the reader engages with the legal details. The body text contrasts the prosecutor's view with the judge's view but leans into the narrative that the prosecution's case was weak ('strazz

la Repubblica logola RepubblicaIndependent🔒CenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 95
Siher case, the outcasts of the Csm: We ask for the opening of a case to protect the Milan GP

The professional judges' section of Italy’s High Council of Magistracy (CSM) has requested the opening of a protective procedure for Tiziana Landoni, the investigating magistrate at the Milan Court. This action follows comments made by the Prime Minister regarding Landoni’s decision not to validate the arrest of Youssef Siher. The request aims to safeguard the magistrate’s independence in light of high-level political intervention in a specific judicial matter.

Bias read (Center): The article reports a formal institutional reaction to a political figure's interference in a judicial process. It uses neutral, factual language ('requested,' 'regarding declarations') without editorializing on the merits of the arrest or criticizing either the Prime Minister or the magistrate. The

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (95): The text is extremely dry and factual, typical of a wire service summary. It presents the action taken by the CSM without adding adjectives, opinions, or emotional coloring, maintaining high neutrality.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories