The trial of Argentine musician Cristian "Pity" Alvarez has finally begun after years of delays and legal challenges. The proceedings, which were initially scheduled for 2021, will take place before the 29th Criminal and Corrective Court in Buenos Aires. Alvarez faces charges related to the July 2018 murder of Cristian Maximiliano "Gringo" Diaz in the Samore neighborhood of Villa Lugano. The court rejected a new attempt by Alvarez's defense team to delay the trial, maintaining the previously set schedule. This decision followed medical evaluations indicating that Alvarez is now capable of participating in the judicial process. The trial comes after multiple suspensions due to concerns over Alvarez’s mental health. In 2021, the forensic medical board concluded that he was not fit to face an oral trial. A new date was set for 2023, but this too was postponed for the same reason. However, recent psychological and medical assessments have determined that Alvarez has regained the necessary capacity to understand the legal proceedings and defend himself effectively. These findings allowed the trial to proceed. Alvarez arrived at the courthouse on Monday wearing a black shirt with the phrase "If you wait, you'll understand," taken directly from his song "Nunca quise." His presence marked a turning point in a case that has spanned nearly eight years. The prosecution alleges that Alvarez shot Diaz during a heated argument in a hallway of the residential complex in Villa Lugano. According to the indictment, the two had known each other in the neighborhood and argued over accusations that Alvarez had stolen items from Diaz’s backpack. During the confrontation, Alvarez allegedly drew a .25-caliber gun, fired at Diaz’s face, and then shot him three more times while he lay on the ground. Alvarez fled with his partner in a Volkswagen Polo, discarded the weapon in a storm drain on the Riccheri highway, and remained at large for almost 24 hours before surrendering to police on July 13, 2018. At that time, Alvarez made statements to television cameras, claiming, "I killed him because it was either him or me. And I think any animal would do the same." He spent the following years in psychiatric hospitals, house arrest, and undergoing treatment. Now, he stands before the court to face formal charges. The trial is being conducted by Judge Gustavo Groerner, along with Juan Ramos Padilla and Hugo Navarro. Prosecuting the case is Fiscal Sandro Abraldes, representing the public ministry. The family of the victim is represented by attorney Fernando Burlando. If found guilty of aggravated homicide involving a firearm, Alvarez could receive a prison sentence ranging from 11 to 25 years. The exact penalty will depend on how the judges assess the evidence and legally classify the crime. Alvarez’s legal team had attempted to halt the trial earlier this week by requesting a postponement until certain appeals against the summons were resolved. However, the court ruled against this request, affirming the scheduled start date. The prosecutors emphasized that the trial represents the appropriate institutional framework to ensure the rights of the accused and resolve the controversies raised during the investigation. They also pointed out that Alvarez’s recent public activities, such as concerts and interviews, demonstrate that he is physically and mentally prepared to participate in the trial. In addition to the murder charge, Alvarez is also under investigation for alleged threats, unlawful detention, and aggression against his former manager and a friend, incidents that occurred in 2016. These cases add another layer of complexity to his legal situation. The trial is expected to last several weeks, with testimony from witnesses and presentation of evidence. The outcome will hinge on the credibility of the testimonies, the physical evidence presented, and the legal arguments made by both sides. As the proceedings begin, the focus shifts to the courtroom, where the fate of one of Argentina’s most controversial musicians will be decided.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
AR
