ON
← Back to feed
‘Organised harassment’: A Supreme Court judge on ‘obscenity’ charges against painter MF Husain
India🏛️ PoliticsLean Progressive

‘Organised harassment’: A Supreme Court judge on ‘obscenity’ charges against painter MF Husain

A former Supreme Court judge recounts presiding over the 2008 obscenity case against renowned Indian painter M.F. Husain, describing the legal proceedings as an instance of organized harassment designed to exhaust the artist through multiple criminal complaints across the country. The judge notes that while the artwork was widely labeled the 'Bharat Mata' painting due to a collector's interpretation, Husain did not adopt this title, and the court focused strictly on the specific work under review rather than judging the artist's entire body of work. Emphasizing the importance of artistic freedom in a democracy, the judge argues that the constitutional remedy for offensive art is tolerance rather than suppression, criticizing the use of the legal system to silence critics. The narrative highlights the reluctance of previous judges to handle the politically charged case, which had been adjourned sixteen times, and asserts that stepping back from difficult cases undermines judicial integrity.

The Supreme Court issued a contempt notice on Friday to office-bearers of the Indian National Congress’ Kerala unit, including the state chief. The court seeks their response on why proceedings should not be initiated against them regarding a social media post that criticised Chief Justice Surya Kant. The bench heard a plea filed by an advocate requesting suo moto action over the content, which has since been removed from the platform. During the hearing, counsel for the Congress Kerala unit stated that the post was authored by a party worker without the approval of organisational leadership. The lawyer noted that the content had been taken down and that the party had offered an apology. Justice Aravind Kumar, part of the bench, remarked that the court would examine whether the statement originated from the writer’s pen or their heart. The judges emphasised that the Constitution is supreme and that no individual or political organisation stands above it. The bench asserted that the independence of the judiciary is not a matter of political convenience. While acknowledging that the judiciary is open to criticism, the court ruled that freedom of expression cannot serve as a shield for intimidation or interference with the administration of justice. The justices stated that the authority of the court rests on the rule of law. Consequently, any attempt to undermine this authority needs to be dealt with an iron hand, according to reports quoting the bench. The impugned post concerning Chief Justice Kant was published during a march by the opposition INDIA bloc to the Supreme Court. Participants in the protest demanded the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The demonstrators raised concerns regarding the functioning of the Election Commission and alleged irregularities in the revision of the voter roll. The timing of the social media activity coincided with these physical protests outside the court premises. Separate legal commentary highlights the tension between free speech and judicial dignity. In a related discussion on artistic freedom, a former judge described a 2008 case involving painter M.F. Husain. That case involved criminal complaints filed across different parts of the country, which the judge characterised as organised harassment designed to drain resources and force a defensive posture. The judge concluded that the complaints constituted an abuse of process, noting that the paintings could not reasonably be said to outrage the religious feelings of any class of citizens. The judge argued that while free speech can be uncomfortable, hurtful, or outrageous, the alternative allows public figures to use courts to silence critics. The Constitution does not grant a right to suppress hurtful truths or, in most cases, hurtful lies about oneself. The primary remedy, according to this view, is a thicker skin. The judge noted that the Husain case had been adjourned sixteen times due to its controversial nature. However, stepping back from politically charged cases was deemed incorrect. The court decided the specific case before it without pronouncing on the painter’s entire body of work. In the current contempt matter, the focus remains on the specific social media post and the identity of its author within the party structure. The court’s directive requires the named officials to explain their position on the incident. The deletion of the post and the subsequent apology have not halted the procedural steps. The bench’s comments underscore a strict stance against perceived threats to judicial integrity. The outcome of the contempt proceedings will depend on the response submitted by the Congress Kerala unit leadership. The interplay between political protest, digital communication, and judicial authority continues to define the legal landscape in these disputes.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

Go to the primary sources (1)

The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.

3 reports

Scroll.in logoScroll.inIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 90
SC issues contempt notice to Congress’ Kerala unit for post criticising CJI

The Supreme Court of India issued a contempt notice to the office-bearers of the Indian National Congress' Kerala unit regarding a social media post that criticized Chief Justice Surya Kant. The court acted on a petition filed by an advocate requesting suo moto intervention after the post, which has since been deleted, drew attention. During the hearing, the defense argued that the content was posted by a worker without organizational approval and that the party had already apologized. The bench emphasized that judicial independence is not subject to political convenience and stated that attempts to undermine the rule of law must be addressed firmly. The incident occurred amidst a broader protest by the opposition INDIA bloc demanding the resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner.

Bias read (Center): The report relies exclusively on direct quotes from the Supreme Court and factual procedural details, presenting the judicial stance and the party's defense without adding editorial commentary or value judgments.

Why factuality (95): Accurately reports the core facts: the notice issuance, the specific quote from Justice Aravind Kumar ('pen or your heart'), and the defense arguments. It correctly attributes the reporting to Live Law. Minor typo ('intimation' instead of 'intimidation') but otherwise faithful to the source.

Why objectivity (90): Maintains a neutral, journalistic tone. Presents the court's strong language and the party's defense without injecting editorial bias or emotional adjectives beyond direct quotes.

The Wire logoThe WireIndependentCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 80
SC Issues Contempt Notice To Kerala Congress Leaders Over Post Asking CJI to Resign

The Supreme Court of India has issued contempt notices to several leaders of the Kerala unit of the Indian National Congress. This action follows a social media post by these individuals that called for the Chief Justice of India to resign. The court determined that the content of the post constituted an act of contempt. No further details regarding specific penalties or the exact wording of the notice were provided in the available text.

Bias read (Center): The headline uses neutral, factual language describing a legal procedure without employing loaded adjectives or taking a side on the underlying political dispute.

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (80): The headline is descriptive rather than sensationalist. It states the action taken by the court without using loaded language, though it omits the nuance of the 'show cause' nature of the notice.

Scroll.in logoScroll.inIndependentProgressiveFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 40
‘Organised harassment’: A Supreme Court judge on ‘obscenity’ charges against painter MF Husain

A former Supreme Court judge recounts presiding over the 2008 obscenity case against renowned Indian painter M.F. Husain, describing the legal proceedings as an instance of organized harassment designed to exhaust the artist through multiple criminal complaints across the country. The judge notes that while the artwork was widely labeled the 'Bharat Mata' painting due to a collector's interpretation, Husain did not adopt this title, and the court focused strictly on the specific work under review rather than judging the artist's entire body of work. Emphasizing the importance of artistic freedom in a democracy, the judge argues that the constitutional remedy for offensive art is tolerance rather than suppression, criticizing the use of the legal system to silence critics. The narrative highlights the reluctance of previous judges to handle the politically charged case, which had been adjourned sixteen times, and asserts that stepping back from difficult cases undermines judicial integrity.

Bias read (Progressive): The author explicitly frames the legal action as 'organized harassment' and advocates for 'thicker skin' over censorship, using normative language like 'throttle artistic expression' to criticize state intervention in cultural matters.

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (40): While the tone within the text is analytical, it is entirely irrelevant to the target event, making it impossible to assess balance relative to the specific incident.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories