It's truly difficult to find a milder term than "farce" to describe today's move by the HDZ's Minister of Justice
Croatian Justice Minister Damir Habijan defended the decision by Constitutional Court President Frane Stancic to record court sessions despite objections from four judges who argued that no formal rules had been established regarding the usage of such recordings. In a radio interview, Habijan criticized the dissenting judges for obstructing the court's work and stated they were unfit for their positions, while simultaneously denying any political influence over the judiciary. He justified the move by comparing it to the planned introduction of recording in all ordinary courts starting July 1, 2025, which has undergone a sixteen-year legislative process involving multiple law amendments and specific regulations. The article highlights the contradiction in Habijan's arguments and notes that the Constitutional Court lacks similar procedural safeguards, describing the situation as a political farce driven by partisan interests rather than legal necessity.
Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic accused three judges of Croatia’s Constitutional Court of acting irresponsibly after they refused to participate in court sessions that are being audio recorded. Speaking on Thursday, the government chief stated that the entire legal profession is appalled by the conduct of the dissenting justices. He described their behavior as unprecedented in its lack of responsibility, claiming such actions had not been witnessed for a long time. The conflict centers on the implementation of audio recording during Constitutional Court hearings. Four judges have opposed the practice because no official decision has been adopted regarding the procedure, nor have rules been agreed upon governing how and when the recordings can be used. Despite this opposition, Constitutional Court President Frane Stanicic has maintained his decision to proceed with recording the sessions. Stanicic has warned that he will not abandon this course even if it results in a blockage of the court’s work, a scenario for which he blames the judges who disagree with him. Justice Minister Damir Habijan defended the president’s stance during an appearance on the Croatian Radio program “U mrezi prvog.” Habijan criticized the judges who refuse to work under unauthorized recording conditions, stating that the question of their responsibility arises. He argued that these individuals are making it difficult for citizens to access the Constitutional Court and claimed that three of them have failed to live up to their functions. Minutes later in the same broadcast, Habijan asserted that there is absolutely no political influence over the Constitutional Court. This statement followed his earlier comments questioning the integrity of specific judges, creating a contradiction that observers noted was left unexplained by the minister. Habijan further justified the move by comparing it to the introduction of recording in ordinary courts across Croatia. He noted that starting July 1 of next year, all courtrooms in the country will feature audio recording. However, critics point out that the process in regular courts took 16 years to implement. That lengthy period required three amendments to the Civil Procedure Act. Additionally, the Justice Minister was required to issue a special regulation detailing technical conditions, storage methods, and access rights for audio recordings before the system could go live. In contrast, the Constitutional Court began recording five months ago following a dispute over the minutes of a hearing in May. There is currently no formal decision authorizing the recording of Constitutional Court sessions, nor does a regulation exist for the use of the tapes. Plenkovic amplified the criticism against the dissenting judges, labeling their actions as hypocrisy. He pointed out that the same judges who are now fearful of recording had previously requested that the public be included in Constitutional Court sessions just a few years ago. The Prime Minister suggested that the comments made by those who proposed these judges were entirely untrue. He emphasized that the judges were elected with the trust of a two-thirds majority in the Croatian Parliament and are legal experts who swore an oath. Consequently, he found it incredible that they received support to behave in such a manner. The Prime Minister also addressed recent developments regarding the composition of the court. He recalled that several months ago, the process of filling vacancies at the Constitutional Court was underway. According to Plenkovic, the opposition initially signaled readiness to elect three constitutional judges but subsequently reversed position. He alleged that the opposition is now adopting an ultimatum approach, presenting two candidates and demanding others agree with them. Plenkovic characterized this as serious obstructionism. He rejected the narrative promoted by the Social Democratic Party and the We Can party, which claim that the parliamentary majority or the HDZ coalition occupies institutions. Instead, he argued that the opposition seeks to block institutions from the outside while ruining and discrediting them from within. In a separate segment of his address, Plenkovic discussed the government’s decision on the minimum wage for the coming year. He stated that standard dialogue with employers and unions led to a decision to increase the gross minimum wage by 80 euros. The new amount will rise from 1,050 euros to 1,130 euros. The government considers this a realistic step forward for approximately 50,000 workers earning the minimum wage. To assist businesses, the government introduced compensatory measures. For the first three months of 2027, the Croatian Employment Service will pay employers who request it the difference between the current gross minimum wage and the future rate. This measure provides employers with time to adjust to the higher costs. The dispute highlights deep divisions within the judicial body. While the administration views the refusal to attend recorded sessions as an obstruction of justice and a failure of duty, the opposing judges maintain that procedural rules must be established before such surveillance begins. The absence of a regulatory framework for the Constitutional Court contrasts sharply with the legislative history of ordinary courts, where extensive legal groundwork preceded the rollout of recording technology. The situation leaves the operational status of the Constitutional Court uncertain, with the president insisting on continuing proceedings despite the boycott by four members of the bench.
3 reports
Net.hrIndependentConservativeFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 90
The provided text consists of a series of headlines and short teasers from various sections of a Croatian news portal, rather than a single cohesive article. The snippets cover diverse topics including sports updates such as Cibona hiring a new coach and Harry Kane retaining the Golden Ball award, along with entertainment news regarding Prince Charles dancing in the Bahamas and celebrity relationships. Other headlines address current affairs like judges protesting against the recording of Constitutional Court sessions, health warnings about silent killers, and local issues such as train accident survivors struggling to cope. Additionally, there are brief mentions of environmental concerns regarding endangered species, economic anxieties about AI replacing jobs, and social issues involving children consuming excessive amounts of certain products.
Bias read (Conservative): Although the input is a collection of unrelated headlines rather than a single narrative, the most prominent and detailed headline within the 'Politics' category (which takes precedence over sports or entertainment per the tie-break rules) concerns the conflict between the Minister of Justice and a
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (90): The tone is standard tabloid/portal style, using catchy but relatively neutral phrasing like 'In the shadow of painful topics.' It presents the quote directly without excessive editorializing or emotional manipulation, maintaining a balance between reporting the event and providing context.
Dnevnik.hrIndependentConservativeFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 50
Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenkovic publicly criticized three Constitutional Court judges after they refused to participate in court sessions that were being recorded. The Prime Minister stated that the entire legal profession was appalled by their behavior. This incident highlights a significant conflict between the executive branch and the judiciary regarding transparency and procedural compliance within Croatia's highest constitutional body.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the judicial refusal as a serious breach of professional ethics, using strong language such as 'appalled' ('zgraža se') and highlighting the Prime Minister's condemnation. By focusing exclusively on the executive's criticism and omitting any counterarguments from the judges or the
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (50): The headline 'Plenković napao' (Plenković attacked) uses aggressive, judgmental language that frames the political statement as an attack rather than a comment. This introduces a negative bias in the framing, although the lack of body text limits further analysis.
Croatian Justice Minister Damir Habijan defended the decision by Constitutional Court President Frane Stancic to record court sessions despite objections from four judges who argued that no formal rules had been established regarding the usage of such recordings. In a radio interview, Habijan criticized the dissenting judges for obstructing the court's work and stated they were unfit for their positions, while simultaneously denying any political influence over the judiciary. He justified the move by comparing it to the planned introduction of recording in all ordinary courts starting July 1, 2025, which has undergone a sixteen-year legislative process involving multiple law amendments and specific regulations. The article highlights the contradiction in Habijan's arguments and notes that the Constitutional Court lacks similar procedural safeguards, describing the situation as a political farce driven by partisan interests rather than legal necessity.
Bias read (Progressive): The headline uses pejorative terms like 'farce,' and the body heavily criticizes the ruling party minister for logical inconsistencies and political interference, framing the judicial dispute as a partisan abuse of power.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.