The National Freedom Party (NFP) finds itself embroiled in a deepening crisis as internal conflicts escalate, threatening its stability and future. At the heart of the controversy is an accusation that several expelled and suspended leaders, including former national chairperson Sibusiso Mkhabela and former provincial secretary Zodwa Mtshali, are orchestrating a clandestine effort to form a new political party. This allegation was made by NFP Secretary-General Sunset Xaba, who claimed that these individuals are undermining the organization's structure and integrity while continuing their political ambitions outside the party framework.
The situation began with the suspension of Mtshali and the dismissal of Mkhabela, both of whom have publicly supported Mbali Shinga, a former party member who was expelled and subsequently removed from her legislative post. Shinga, who served as the sole representative of the NFP in the KwaZulu-Natal Legislature and as the Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Social Development, found herself at odds with the party leadership after defying directives during a vote of no confidence in Premier Thami Ntuli in December of the previous year. This defiance led to disciplinary proceedings, culminating in her expulsion from the party. However, Shinga successfully contested her removal in court, and the KwaZulu-Natal Legislature reinstated her position, restoring the status quo ante.
Xaba defended the suspension of Mtshali by stating that the party had intelligence indicating that she, along with Mkhabela and other former members, had already begun forming an alternative political entity. He criticized Mtshali for violating the party's constitution and code of conduct by issuing a public statement supporting Shinga without prior approval from the provincial executive committee (PEC). According to Xaba, Mtshali had long promoted Shinga's candidacy for party president and worked alongside her faction to challenge the authority of the National Executive Committee (NEC).
Mtshali, who also holds the position of deputy mayor of the Mhlabuyalingana Local Municipality, categorically denied the allegations, calling them "baseless and politically motivated." She argued that she could not have initiated the formation of a new party given her recent suspension and noted that new political entities cannot register to contest elections once the dates have been set. She further dismissed the claim that she was involved in efforts to oust NFP president Ivan Barnes, emphasizing that the accusations lacked merit.
Mkhabela, who has been a staunch supporter of Shinga, has faced mounting pressure from the party leadership. He was one of the primary figures who led a group of party members to storm a Durban hotel where Shinga's disciplinary hearing was taking place, demanding that the proceedings be stopped. His actions have drawn criticism, and the NFP is now considering removing him from his position as mayor of the eDumbe Local Municipality. Additionally, Mkhabela and his bodyguards were involved in a motor vehicle accident on the R34 near the Gluckstad off-ramp, though no injuries were reported, and the cause of the crash remains unknown.
Other notable figures expelled from the NFP include National Executive Committee member Thuba Thwala and national coordinator and NEC member Bawinile Mhlongo. These developments underscore the deepening rifts within the party, particularly as it seeks to consolidate its strength and influence in the region. Political analysts have warned that the ongoing infighting could lead to the fragmentation of the NFP, potentially jeopardizing its viability as a political force. The situation highlights the challenges facing the party as it navigates internal discord while striving to maintain its relevance in the political landscape.
4 reports
IOL (Independent Online)Party-alignedCenterFactual 90Objective 7019 days ago NFP alleges expelled and suspended leaders are behind new political partyThe National Freedom Party (NFP) accuses suspended and expelled members, including former party member Mbali Shinga, of forming a new political party while undermining the NFP. This follows the suspension of provincial secretary Zodwa Mtshali and the dismissal of national chairperson Sibusiso Mkhabela, both of whom supported Shinga. Shinga was expelled from the NFP and removed from her legislative role after defying the party's directives during a vote of no confidence in Premier Thami Ntuli.
Bias read (Center): The article reports on internal disputes within a political party without taking a stance or using biased language. It presents facts and quotes from officials without evident slant.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 70): The article provides detailed background on the NFP's accusations against Shinga and her supporters. It presents the situation fairly but uses some emotionally charged language like 'destabilise' and 'creating instability,' which may affect objectivity.
News24IndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 7514 days ago Mbali Shinga successfully blocks NFP expulsion, legislature removalMbali Shinga has successfully blocked efforts to expel her from the National Freedom Party (NFP) and prevent her removal from the legislature.
Bias read (Center): The article provides minimal detail beyond stating the outcome of the situation involving Mbali Shinga. It does not include quotes, perspectives, or contextual information that would indicate a clear ideological slant. The lack of elaboration prevents determination of a specific lean.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 75): The article accurately reports that Mbali Shinga blocked her expulsion and removal from the legislature, though it lacks specific details on how this was achieved. It aligns with other sources regarding her legal battle and conflict with the NFP leadership.
News24IndependentCenter11 days ago UPDATE | NFP chairperson suspends party president Ivan BarnesThe National Freedom Party (NFP) chairperson has suspended the party's president, Ivan Barnes, following internal disputes within the organization. The suspension comes amid reports of disagreements over the party's direction and leadership. Barnes had been leading the party since its formation but faced increasing criticism from within the ranks. The move is expected to have significant implications for the party's future strategy and cohesion.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the event factually, without apparent bias toward either the chairperson or the suspended president. It does not include loaded language or one-sided sourcing, focusing instead on the reported actions and their potential impact.
IOL (Independent Online)Party-alignedCenter12 days ago Infighting threatens the NFP's future amid attempt to suspend BarnesThe National Freedom Party (NFP) in South Africa is facing internal conflict as top leaders suspend each other from party activities, raising concerns about the party's stability. Sibusiso Mkhabela, the party's national chairperson, suspended President Ivan Barnes over alleged misconduct, including undermining the party's independence and encouraging members to support rival organizations. In response, Barnes' faction suspended Mbali Shinga, the KwaZulu-Natal provincial chairperson and an MEC for Social Development, but she successfully challenged her expulsion in court, leading to her reinstatement in the legislature. The NFP spokesperson denied the validity of Mkhabela's suspension letter, stating that Mkhabela no longer held the chairmanship since June 8.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both sides of the dispute without overtly favoring one faction over the other. It includes quotes from multiple parties involved and outlines the legal and procedural aspects of the situation without using biased language or omitting key perspectives.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter