Memory lapses, fake invoices and a reprimand: Key moments from ICAC
The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) continues its investigation into alleged illegal political donations and potential influence-peddling linked to fugitive property developer Jean Nassif. During recent hearings, lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood faced scrutiny for frequent responses of 'I don't know' and 'I don't recall,' including a moment where he claimed he couldn't remember details from a phone call. He also made a provocative remark during the session, prompting a reprimand from Commissioner Fabian Gleeson. The inquiry revealed a text exchange where Greenwood referred to 'filthy schools money' and 'f***ing whinging,' which counsel assisting Peggy Dwyer suggested might relate to Catholic Schools NSW funds being funneled into Liberal Party recruitment. Additionally, Dallas McInerney, a key figure in the case, testified about his communications with federal Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, including a message expressing intent to 'shake down Angus for 10k.'
The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) heard on Wednesday that lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood provided substantial financial kickbacks to Jean-Claude Perrottet from a contract secured with Catholic Schools NSW. Greenwood, appearing on his third day of evidence in Operation Rosny, testified that he agreed to pay Perrottet fifty percent of the ongoing retainer for his consultancy firm, JPG Advisory, specifically to boost his friend’s income. The commission is investigating allegations that prohibited political donations were funneled through third-party entities to support the right-wing Liberal faction known as the NSW Reformers and to advance the interests of fugitive property developer Jean Nassif. Greenwood stated that Perrottet, a key member of the Reformers, acted as his agent to convince Dallas McInerney, the then-chief executive of Catholic Schools NSW, to sign a contract with JPG Advisory in 2021. Although Perrottet was employed at Medallion Financial, Greenwood noted his salary was approximately $50,000. To compensate Perrottet for securing the client, Greenwood offered the half-share of the retainer. He also disclosed agreeing to a one-off payment of ten percent of the retainer to Robert Assaf, co-founder of the Reformers. When questioned by counsel assisting Dr Peggy Dwyer SC about how he accounted for these payments, Greenwood said he viewed the fifty percent fee as a fair commission structure. He indicated he would claim invoices from Perrottet as business expenses for tax purposes, describing the documentation as internal and stating that the specific description on the invoice, such as buying a flamingo, did not matter as long as the processing was correct. The inquiry examined the transition from Greenwood’s previous firm, Beckington, to JPG Advisory. The commission heard that McInerney terminated the contract with Beckington after board concerns arose regarding value for money. In a 2021 text message terminating the arrangement, McInerney wrote to Beckington founder Christian Ellis, "With Dylan [Whitelaw] moving on, time for us to wean ourselves off Beckington," noting the contract had lasted 1.5 years. Ellis corrected him, stating it had been two years, and thanked McInerney for the support. Earlier, in 2019, Beckington became the first client of Catholic Schools NSW. McInerney testified on Friday that he engaged the firm to supplement in-house government relations managed by employee James Tudehope. However, counsel assisting Juliet Curtin presented evidence that when McInerney requested an Australian Business Number, Ellis provided one registered to his sister, Dr Samantha Ellis. McInerney admitted that the due diligence conducted between April and August during negotiations was not particularly effective, acknowledging a missing step in verifying the entity. Evidence presented to the commission suggests that Beckington and later JPG Advisory were used to disguise political donations. A text exchange surfaced in which Greenwood told Perrottet he would "give you your filthy schools money and put up with you f***ing whining." Perrottet replied, "Don't put that in writing," to which Greenwood responded, "It deletes." On Wednesday, Greenwood dismissed the reference to "filthy schools money" as a "stupid joke" intended to rile his friend, denying that it referred to a dodgy arrangement for funding Liberal Party recruitment. Dr Dwyer argued the exchange demonstrated that key Reformers players knew sham arrangements were being used. Greenwood also admitted to urging Ellis to pay Perrottet from the Beckington business account after Perrottet complained, "I left my job under the pretense I would get paid." Greenwood cited money coming in from "Concord," his code name for Jean Nassif, as justification for the payment, though he later claimed not to recall the specific messages. The commission also addressed Perrottet’s travel to Fiji in 2023. Evidence indicates a position with a base salary of $165,000 was created for Perrottet at Catholic Schools NSW during the period he was in Fiji to avoid a summons for a parliamentary inquiry. Greenwood testified that he paid for the trip to help Perrottet avoid being served, with a plan for Nassif to ultimately cover the cost. A security guard organized by former Labor councillor Sharangan Maheswaran, likely paid by Nassif’s company, was stationed outside Perrottet’s home to prevent contact from process servers. Tensions rose during Greenwood’s testimony when Commissioner Fabian Gleeson SC rebuked him for snapping at someone in the room, telling him to maintain decorum. Greenwood frequently answered questions with "I don't know" or "I don't recall," including regarding a phone call he received that morning. The commission heard that Greenwood met Perrottet at the Oaks pub in Double Bay after giving private evidence in June 2025. Despite a commissioner’s order not to discuss his evidence, which carries criminal penalties for breach, Greenwood and Perrottet reportedly placed their phones at a separate table to avoid surveillance. Greenwood claimed he did not recall the meeting but said he would not be surprised if he had gone for a drink. Dallas McInerney, who stood aside from his role after being named in the investigation, denied that money was filtered through Beckington to the Reformers. He described the Reformers as "spectacularly unsuccessful" in pushing conservative values but supportive of their ideals. McInerney denied meeting Greenwood to discuss their evidence prior to the public hearings, a claim made by Robert Assaf. The inquiry continues, with McInerney expected to appear again before former Liberal minister David Elliott takes the stand. The commission is also examining whether donations linked to Nassif were exchanged for political favors, including efforts to damage Elliott’s career via a dossier referred to as a "David Elliott shit sheet," which Greenwood conceded he commissioned.
Go to the primary sources (1)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
During the ICAC Operation Rosny hearings, lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood testified that he provided 'kickbacks' to his close friend Jean-Claude Perrottet from a contract secured by Perrottet with Catholic Schools NSW. Greenwood explained that he paid Perrottet 50% of JPG Advisory's retainer as a reward for helping secure the contract, which Perrottet facilitated using his connections with Catholic Schools NSW leadership. Greenwood also mentioned paying another 10% to Reformers co-founder Robert Assaf. He justified these payments as legitimate business expenses, referring to them internally as a 'commission structure.' The testimony includes claims that Perrottet was underpaid at his job and that he was compensated through other channels, including funds linked to a disgraced property developer named Concord.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the actions of Jean-Claude Perrottet and Jeremy Greenwood in a manner that suggests unethical financial arrangements benefiting a right-wing group (Reformers). While the subject involves potential corruption, the framing emphasizes the personal and financial motivations behind the
Why factuality (90): This article provides detailed testimony from lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood regarding kickbacks to Jean-Claude Perrottet, including specifics about the contract, financial arrangements, and the perceived legality of the payments. These details are corroborated by multiple sources and align with the broa
Why objectivity (65): While the facts are presented clearly, the article frames the situation in a way that suggests questionable ethics, particularly through the portrayal of Greenwood's actions and the implications of the 'kickbacks.' This introduces a slight bias in the interpretation of events.
The article discusses the ongoing investigation by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) into alleged corruption involving Jeremy Greenwood, a lobbyist who recently returned to Australia after meeting with Christian Ellis in London. Greenwood, a key figure in Operation Rosny, is accused of involvement in schemes including diverting funds from Catholic Schools NSW to a conservative Liberal Party faction called the Reformers through sham contracts. Greenwood has been questioned by the ICAC and faced difficult questioning, showing signs of frustration and memory lapses. He is linked to multiple organizations and individuals under scrutiny, including the Catholic Archdiocese of Sydney and former politicians.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the findings and testimonies of the ICAC investigation without overtly favoring any particular political perspective. It reports on allegations against Greenwood and his connections to various entities, including political figures, but does not exhibit clear bias toward one side
Why factuality (90): The article accurately reports the $135,000 salary paid to Robert Assaf for factional Liberal Party work, citing text messages presented to the ICAC. It provides direct quotes from the commission proceedings and includes specific details such as the involvement of Jean-Claude Perrottet and Christian
Why objectivity (40): The article presents the information neutrally based on the ICAC proceedings but includes strong editorializing in the reader letters section, such as 'Heads must roll at Catholic Schools NSW after revelations' and 'We must hope the board of Catholic Schools NSW is at work.' These statements introdu
The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) continues its investigation into alleged illegal political donations and potential influence-peddling linked to fugitive property developer Jean Nassif. During recent hearings, lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood faced scrutiny for frequent responses of 'I don't know' and 'I don't recall,' including a moment where he claimed he couldn't remember details from a phone call. He also made a provocative remark during the session, prompting a reprimand from Commissioner Fabian Gleeson. The inquiry revealed a text exchange where Greenwood referred to 'filthy schools money' and 'f***ing whinging,' which counsel assisting Peggy Dwyer suggested might relate to Catholic Schools NSW funds being funneled into Liberal Party recruitment. Additionally, Dallas McInerney, a key figure in the case, testified about his communications with federal Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, including a message expressing intent to 'shake down Angus for 10k.'
Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced account of the ICAC proceedings, focusing on the testimonies and actions of individuals under investigation without overtly favoring any political side. It reports on the legal and ethical implications of the alleged misconduct without taking a clear ideological slant
Why factuality (85): The article provides a summary of recent developments in Operation Rosny, including specific quotes from Jeremy Greenwood and descriptions of interactions during the ICAC hearing. It references the allegations involving Jean Nassif and political donations, aligning with the cross-source consensus. T
Why objectivity (80): The tone remains neutral, presenting facts and quotes without overt bias. However, there is a slight editorial tilt in describing Mr. Greenwood's behavior as 'making the job of counsel assisting a struggle,' which implies judgment rather than purely reporting facts.
Catholic Schools NSW head Dallas McInerney faced scrutiny from the Independent Commission Against Corruption over a contract with a Liberal-aligned consultancy firm, Beckington, which provided him with an ABN belonging to someone else. McInerney claimed he performed 'due diligence' but admitted it was ineffective, as the ABN was actually registered to his sister, Dr Samantha Ellis. The commission is investigating whether funds were funneled through Beckington to the Reformers, a right-wing Catholic faction within the Liberal Party. McInerney denied providing money to the Reformers but acknowledged the contract lasted 1.5 years before being terminated. The firm's founder, Christian Ellis, was linked to former minister Damien Tudehope, who was dismissed for factional activities.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the controversy around a Liberal-aligned consultancy and potential misuse of public resources for a right-wing faction. While the subject involves political figures and institutions, the framing emphasizes accountability and ethical concerns, aligning more with left-leaning media.
Why factuality (85): The article accurately reports the details of Dallas McInerney's testimony before the ICAC regarding the ABN mix-up involving Sam Mooy Beckington and Christian Ellis. It cites specific statements made by counsel assisting Juliet Curtin and McInerney himself. The information aligns with what might be
Why objectivity (75): The article presents the facts neutrally but uses phrases like 'fledgling government relations firm set up by Liberal factional allies' and 'right-wing Liberal powerbroker' which could imply bias against the Liberal party. While it quotes both parties involved, the framing suggests a particular pers
The AgeIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 75
Catholic Schools NSW head Dallas McInerney faced scrutiny from the Independent Commission Against Corruption over a contract with a Liberal-aligned consultancy firm, Beckington, which provided him with an ABN belonging to someone else. McInerney claimed he performed 'due diligence' but admitted it was ineffective, as the ABN was actually registered to his sister, Dr Samantha Ellis. The commission is investigating whether funds were funneled through Beckington to the Reformers, a right-wing Catholic faction within the Liberal Party. McInerney denied providing money to the Reformers but acknowledged the contract lasted 1.5 years before being terminated. The firm's founder, Christian Ellis, reportedly thanked McInerney despite the termination.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the controversy around a Liberal-aligned consultancy and potential misuse of public resources for a right-wing faction. While the subject involves political figures and institutions, the framing emphasizes accountability and ethical concerns, aligning more with left-leaning media.
Why factuality (85): This article mirrors the content of item 0 almost verbatim, suggesting it is likely sourced from the same press release or report. It accurately conveys the details of McInerney's testimony and the nature of the ABN issue. As with item 0, the primary source document does not confirm these specific a
Why objectivity (75): Like item 0, this article uses similar phrasing that could be seen as biased towards certain political groups. The neutrality is somewhat compromised by the choice of words such as 'Liberal factional allies' and 'right-wing Liberal powerbroker', which may influence reader perception despite presenti
The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) is investigating allegations that prohibited political donations were funneled through third parties to support a right-wing Liberal-aligned faction known as the NSW Reformers. Lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood, who is connected to the faction, admitted sending a text message to Jean-Claude Perrottet, brother of former Premier Dominic Perrottet, referencing 'filthy schools money.' The message, which was shared during the ICAC inquiry, suggested payments from Catholic Schools NSW (CSNSW) were being used to fund Liberal Party recruitment efforts. Greenwood described the text as a 'stupid joke,' claiming it was meant to provoke Perrottet. Counsel assisting the commission argued that the message demonstrated knowledge of the fraudulent arrangements, while Greenwood denied any wrongdoing.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both sides of the issue: the ICAC's investigation into potential corruption and Greenwood's defense of the text as a joke. There is no clear ideological slant in the framing of the story, which focuses on the legal proceedings and the conflicting accounts rather than taking a立场.
Why factuality (75): The article reports on an ongoing ICAC investigation into alleged prohibited donations to a Liberal-aligned faction, citing a text exchange between Jeremy Greenwood and Jean-Claude Perrottet. It mentions the use of companies, sham invoices, and consulting agreements to disguise donations, aligning w
Why objectivity (80): The article presents facts neutrally, focusing on the allegations and the ICAC's role without overt bias. It includes quotes from multiple sources and avoids emotionally charged language, maintaining a balanced tone.
This article provides live coverage of the ICAC's Operation Rosny inquiry, focusing on allegations against lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood. Greenwood is accused of attempting to influence investigations by advising NSW Catholic Schools' head to avoid scrutiny and facilitating payments to Jean-Claude Perrottet to cover expenses related to a trip to Fiji. The inquiry includes claims that Greenwood provided financial support to Perrottet and engaged in secretive communications. The article highlights concerns about potential corruption and conflicts of interest within political and business circles.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual developments from the ICAC investigation without overtly endorsing or criticizing either side. While the content involves politically sensitive matters, the framing remains neutral, focusing on reported actions and legal proceedings rather than taking a clear ideological
Why factuality (75): The article reports on statements made by Jeremy Greenwood during the ICAC Operation Rosny inquiry, which aligns with the information available in the primary source document. It mentions specific actions and quotes from Greenwood, which are likely derived from the live stream or transcripts. The ar
Why objectivity (65): The article presents information in a journalistic style, focusing on the allegations against Greenwood. While it remains neutral in tone, there is a slight bias toward highlighting potential wrongdoing, particularly through phrases like 'wanted Nassif to pay for Jean-Claude Perrottet’s Fiji trip to
The article covers developments in the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) inquiry into the activities of lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood. Key points include Greenwood's admission to creating a damaging report on former police minister David Elliott, his alleged financial support for Jean-Claude Perrottet, and claims that he advised Perrottet to avoid the inquiry. Greenwood reportedly met with Perrottet at a pub after providing evidence to the ICAC, despite being warned not to discuss his testimony. The inquiry also involves Jean-Claude Perrottet's potential involvement in securing a high-profile position within NSW Catholic Schools, possibly through undisclosed negotiations.
Bias read (Progressive): The article focuses on allegations involving political figures and corruption investigations, which are inherently politically charged. The framing emphasizes the actions of individuals close to power, suggesting systemic issues within politics. The language used implies scrutiny of powerful actors,
Why factuality (75): This article mirrors the content of the previous one, reporting on the same statements and events related to Jeremy Greenwood's testimony. It references the same individuals and actions, suggesting consistency with the primary source. However, it lacks additional verification beyond what is publicly
Why objectivity (65): Similar to the first article, this piece maintains a neutral tone but leans into the narrative of potential misconduct by emphasizing certain aspects of Greenwood's testimony. Phrases such as 'wanted Nassif to pay for Jean-Claude Perrottet’s Fiji trip' imply a particular interpretation of the facts,
During the ICAC Operation Rosny hearings, lobbyist Jeremy Greenwood testified that he provided 'kickbacks' to his close friend Jean-Claude Perrottet in exchange for helping secure a contract with Catholic Schools NSW. Greenwood claimed that Perrottet, who worked for Medallion Financial, received 50% of JPG Advisory's retainer as compensation for facilitating the deal. Greenwood also mentioned giving a one-time payment to Reformers co-founder Robert Assaf. Greenwood defended these payments as legitimate commissions and suggested they were necessary to ensure Perrottet's cooperation. The testimony comes amid allegations of improper influence and financial arrangements involving Perrottet and other individuals.
Bias read (Progressive): The article presents allegations of corruption involving a prominent figure (Jean-Claude Perrottet), a right-wing organization (Reformers), and potential conflicts of interest. The framing emphasizes the nature of the alleged kickbacks and the involvement of a politically aligned group, suggesting a
Why factuality (75): Similar to Article 0, this piece covers the same allegations about Catholic Schools NSW and teacher concerns over transparency. It references the ICAC inquiry and quotes officials, but lacks the detailed testimonies found in Article 1. The alignment with other sources supports its factual basis, but
Why objectivity (60): The tone is similar to Article 0, suggesting concern over the impact of the allegations on schools and teachers. Phrases like 'actions of a few within the sector are undermining the work of its schools and teachers' carry a judgmental undertone, affecting objectivity.
A corruption inquiry into Catholic Schools NSW has raised concerns about potential misuse of public funds, including allegations that $165,000 was directed to Liberal Party operatives. The organization, which manages federal funding for nearly 600 Catholic schools, faces scrutiny over unreported political donations and possible violations of legal donation limits. Former leaders warn these issues could jeopardize future funding agreements and damage the reputation of Catholic education. The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) is investigating these claims, with Dallas McInerney, the former CEO of Catholic Schools NSW, set to testify. Teachers' unions have called for increased transparency in how public money is handled by organizations like Catholic Schools NSW, which distribute funds on behalf of Catholic diocesan schools. These developments follow other investigations into potential misconduct in the education sector.
Bias read (Center): The article presents allegations of corruption involving public funding and political donations but does not exhibit overt bias toward either side. It includes perspectives from multiple stakeholders, including the union, former officials, and the government, without favoring one narrative over the.
Why factuality (75): The article reports on allegations of political donations and potential corruption involving Catholic Schools NSW, citing the involvement of former leader Dallas McInerney and the Federal Education Minister's response. While these claims align with the cross-source consensus, some details like the e
Why objectivity (60): The article presents the allegations in a somewhat critical light, using phrases like 'under pressure from its own teachers' and 'actions of a few within the sector are undermining the work of its schools and teachers,' which may imply judgment rather than neutrality.
A corruption inquiry is examining allegations that Catholic Schools NSW, which manages federal funding for nearly 600 Catholic schools, funneled $165,000 to right-wing Liberal Party operatives. The organization's chief executive, Dallas McInerney, has stepped down and will appear before the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC). Federal Education Minister Jason Clare called the allegations 'very concerning.' Teachers' unions argue there is insufficient oversight of funding processes for non-government schools, raising concerns that public funds may be misused. The controversy follows other recent scandals involving education officials and private schools breaching laws against profiting from government funding.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the scandal as a systemic issue affecting public funding integrity, emphasizing concerns raised by teachers' unions and highlighting the potential misuse of taxpayer money. While the allegations involve right-wing operatives, the focus is on holding institutions accountable and re
Why factuality (75): This article mirrors the content of Article 0, covering the same allegations and quoting similar statements from officials. While it aligns with the cross-source consensus, it lacks additional details and does not reference the specific testimonies from the ICAC hearings that appear in Article 1.
Why objectivity (60): The language used is similar to Article 0, implying a negative assessment of the situation and the potential consequences for the sector. This affects the overall balance of the reporting.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.