President of the Epidemiologists: "Migrants don't bring diseases, they get them here because of the bad conditions they are in"
The situation in Ceuta, where thousands of migrants are living in poor conditions on the streets, has reignited discussions linking migration to disease. The leader of Spain’s Popular Party, Alberto Núñez Feijóo, warned of a 'public health crisis' and attributed cases of tuberculosis, scabies, and other infectious diseases to these individuals. However, medical professionals warn of a potential collapse in healthcare services, which the Ministry of Health downplays as significant stress. María João Forjaz, president of the Spanish Society of Epidemiology, argues that the issue should be viewed through a human rights lens rather than as a health crisis. She emphasizes that migrants do not bring diseases but contract them due to poor living conditions, such as overcrowding, lack of hygiene, and inadequate shelter. These conditions weaken both physical and mental health and increase vulnerability to contagious illnesses like skin infections, gastrointestinal issues, and respiratory diseases. While Feijóo mentioned cases of tuberculosis and scabies, Forjaz clarifies that these diseases spread through close contact and poor ventilation, not necessarily from the migrants themselves.
The Spanish government has assigned Minister Ángel Víctor Torres, responsible for territorial policy, to coordinate the management of ministries involved in the ongoing crisis in Ceuta following the mass influx of migrants on July 30 and 31. This decision comes amid growing concerns over the humanitarian situation and the strain on public services. The government’s move signals a shift toward centralized oversight of the response, aiming to streamline efforts among different departments and ensure a unified approach to addressing the complex challenges posed by the migrant surge. The crisis began with thousands of migrants attempting to cross into Ceuta, a Spanish territory located in North Africa, from Morocco. The overwhelming number of arrivals overwhelmed local infrastructure and led to severe overcrowding in public spaces. Many migrants were left stranded in the streets and beaches, exposed to extreme weather conditions and lacking basic necessities such as shelter, food, and medical care. The situation sparked both immediate concern and long-term debate over Spain’s migration policies and its obligations under international law. Minister Torres was tasked with coordinating the actions of multiple ministries, including Health, Interior, and Foreign Affairs, to manage the crisis effectively. His role will involve ensuring that all relevant agencies work together to provide adequate support to the affected population while maintaining compliance with legal frameworks. The government has already announced plans to establish four new facilities capable of accommodating up to 1,500 individuals, though the exact criteria for prioritizing who receives shelter remain unclear. These measures aim to alleviate the immediate pressures on the city's resources and restore some level of order. The health implications of the crisis have become a focal point of discussion. Medical professionals and epidemiologists have raised alarms over the deteriorating living conditions faced by the migrants, which they argue have created an environment conducive to the spread of infectious diseases. While some political figures, including the leader of the People’s Party (PP), have suggested links between the migrants and outbreaks of illnesses such as tuberculosis and scabies, experts counter that these conditions are more likely to emerge due to poor hygiene and lack of access to clean water and sanitation. The president of the Spanish Society of Epidemiology, María João Forjaz, emphasized that the situation should be viewed through a human rights lens rather than solely as a public health issue. She stressed that the well-being of all individuals, regardless of their origin, must be protected. The crisis has also intensified political tensions within Spain. The mayor of Ceuta, Juan Jesús Vivas, has publicly criticized the national government for its perceived inaction and has threatened to take legal action against the administration. Meanwhile, the Prime Minister, Pedro Sánchez, has held several emergency meetings with senior officials to assess the situation and coordinate responses. The involvement of high-level ministers underscores the gravity of the situation and the need for a cohesive strategy to address both the immediate humanitarian needs and the broader policy implications. International observers have noted that the crisis has placed Spain under increased scrutiny, particularly regarding its adherence to European Union standards for managing migration flows. Some EU leaders have expressed solidarity with Spain, acknowledging the complexity of the situation and the need for a balanced approach that respects both national sovereignty and international commitments. However, the handling of the crisis has also highlighted divisions within Spain itself, with political parties taking contrasting stances on how best to respond to the influx of migrants. In addition to the immediate logistical challenges, the crisis has reignited debates over Spain’s historical relationship with North African countries and its role in the broader context of European migration policy. Critics argue that the current approach fails to adequately address the root causes of migration, such as poverty and conflict in regions of origin. Others contend that Spain’s ability to manage migration flows more effectively than many other EU nations demonstrates the viability of a socially democratic model. Nevertheless, the situation continues to test the limits of Spain’s capacity to balance security, compassion, and legality in its treatment of migrants.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
Spain
