Testing: Pistachio ice cream from the supermarket

A test of pistachio ice cream from supermarkets has revealed mixed results among consumers. Five brands were sampled, each offering its interpretation of the classic flavor. The evaluation focused on texture, taste, sweetness, color, and overall appeal. The verdicts varied significantly, with some products scoring highly while others received low marks. The tested products included Eskimo Cremissimo Pistazie Vanille, Despar Gelateria Pistacchio, Magnum Crackables Pistachio, Bon Gelati Ice Cream Pistachio, and Mucci Sensation Pistazie. Each brand presented a unique approach to the pistachio flavor, resulting in different consumer experiences. One product, however, could not be tasted due to its appearance, which raised initial doubts among testers. Eskimo Cremissimo Pistazie Vanille stood out with its creamy consistency and recognizable pistachio flavor. The product scored well in all categories, earning high marks for both texture and taste. Its green hue was considered appealing, and the inclusion of nut pieces added to its charm. Priced at €5.99 for 825ml, this option is available at Spar stores. In contrast, Despar Gelateria Pistacchio received lower scores. While the texture was praised, the pistachio flavor was weak, and the sweetness level was deemed too high. The greenish-brown color did not impress all tasters, leading to an overall score of 5 out of 10. This product, priced at €3.99 for 900ml, can be found at Spar locations. Magnum Crackables Pistachio offered a different experience with its chocolate-covered design. The texture was enjoyable, and the bright green color was appreciated by some. However, the chocolate layer overshadowed the pistachio flavor, resulting in a lower score. At €7.29 for 440ml, this item is sold at Billa stores. Bon Gelati Ice Cream Pistachio faced criticism for its artificial green color and overpowering sweetness. The pistachio flavor was almost absent, with some testers noting a marzipan-like taste instead. This product, priced at €2.79 for 900ml, is available at Lidl. Mucci Sensation Pistazie, available at Hofer, took a more unconventional route with its stick form and thick chocolate coating. While the texture and sweetness were appreciated, the pistachio flavor was subdued. The artificial green color was noted, though the overall quality was still considered acceptable. Priced at €2.39 for four 70g portions, this option offers a different take on the classic flavor. One brand, Grom Gelato al Pistacchio, was unable to be tasted during the evaluation. The brownish color initially caused skepticism among testers, raising questions about its authenticity. Despite its reputation, the product failed to meet expectations based on visual inspection alone.