ON
← Back to feed
Catholic schools rort was a ‘running joke’. You won’t hear parents or taxpayers laughing
Australia🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives4 days ago

Catholic schools rort was a ‘running joke’. You won’t hear parents or taxpayers laughing

An investigation into Catholic schools in New South Wales (NSW) has uncovered allegations of financial abuse and misuse of charitable resources to support conservative political interests. The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) is examining claims that Catholic Schools NSW, which manages over 270,000 students, used its substantial public funding—nearly $4 billion annually—to employ Liberal Party operatives, including Dylan Whitelaw and Robert Assaf, to advance the agenda of right-wing political groups known as the Reformers. Whitelaw described the arrangement as a 'running joke,' suggesting that these individuals spent significant portions of their time on political activities rather than educational responsibilities. The scandal implicates high-ranking figures, including former CEO Dallas McInerney and Archbishop Anthony Fisher, raising concerns about the integrity of both religious institutions and political systems.

Taxpayers and parents of the 270,000 students enrolled in Catholic schools across New South Wales face a growing sense of outrage after revelations emerged during a major corruption inquiry on Tuesday. Evidence presented suggested widespread misuse of public funds and a pattern of political favoritism within Catholic Schools NSW, an organization responsible for distributing government grants to diocesan schools. The inquiry, conducted by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), has exposed allegations of financial misconduct involving high-ranking officials and ties to the NSW Liberal Party. These findings have sparked demands for accountability from both the public and private sectors. The investigation began earlier this month when the ICAC disclosed that Dallas McInerney, the former chief executive of Catholic Schools NSW, was under scrutiny as part of a broader probe into the relationship between the NSW Liberal Party and fugitive developer Jean Nassif. McInerney, described as a key figure in the Conservative movement and a favored associate of Archbishop Anthony Fisher, led the organization for nearly a decade. During his tenure, he reportedly leveraged the substantial budget of Catholic Schools NSW, estimated at over $4 billion annually from federal and state governments, to employ Liberal Party operatives. This practice raised serious concerns about the allocation of public resources. Among those implicated is Dylan Whitelaw, a former employee of Catholic Schools NSW who testified at the inquiry. He was hired directly by McInerney in 2019 without undergoing any formal application process. According to Whitelaw, McInerney recognized his potential and offered him a position, possibly influenced by their prior involvement in local Liberal Party activities. At the time, McInerney served as the president of the Mittagong branch of the Liberal Party, while Whitelaw held the role of secretary. During his time at Catholic Schools NSW, Whitelaw was assigned to tasks referred to internally as “Dallas projects.” These projects were linked to the ambitions of a group of right-wing Liberal members known as the Reformers. Another individual associated with the Reformers, Robert Assaf, was also employed by Catholic Schools NSW. From his desk, Whitelaw observed Assaf's work habits and noted that approximately 60 percent of his time was devoted to advancing the interests of the Reformers rather than fulfilling duties related to Catholic education. This situation reportedly gave rise to a casual remark among colleagues, referring to Assaf's minimal engagement with Catholic educational matters and his focus on Liberal Party activities. However, such remarks are now viewed as trivial compared to the gravity of the allegations against the organization. The financial implications of these actions are profound, considering that Catholic Schools NSW receives nearly $4 billion annually in public funding, which constitutes roughly 80 percent of the sector’s total revenue. Additionally, the organization generates over $550 million through school fees paid by families. The inquiry has also uncovered claims that McInerney directed $165,000 in funds to individuals affiliated with the Reformers over several years. These allegations suggest a deliberate effort to support political agendas using resources meant for educational purposes. Furthermore, Whitelaw indicated that James Tudehope, a manager at Catholic Schools NSW, was aware that Assaf was not consistently engaged in legitimate work for the organization. Tudehope, currently residing in New Zealand, has refused to cooperate with the ICAC investigation. His father, Damien Tudehope, a Liberal Member of Parliament, is scheduled to appear before the commission in the near future as part of Operation Rosny. As the inquiry continues, the spotlight remains firmly on the intersection of politics and education within the Catholic school system. The revelations have prompted calls for transparency and reform, emphasizing the need for rigorous oversight to prevent further misuse of public funds. With the stakes so high, the outcome of the ongoing investigation will determine whether justice can be served for those affected by these alleged misdeeds.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

2 reports

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 654 days ago
Catholic schools rort was a ‘running joke’. You won’t hear parents or taxpayers laughing

An investigation into Catholic schools in New South Wales (NSW) has uncovered allegations of financial abuse and misuse of charitable resources to support conservative political interests. The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) is examining claims that Catholic Schools NSW, which manages over 270,000 students, used its substantial public funding—nearly $4 billion annually—to employ Liberal Party operatives, including Dylan Whitelaw and Robert Assaf, to advance the agenda of right-wing political groups known as the Reformers. Whitelaw described the arrangement as a 'running joke,' suggesting that these individuals spent significant portions of their time on political activities rather than educational responsibilities. The scandal implicates high-ranking figures, including former CEO Dallas McInerney and Archbishop Anthony Fisher, raising concerns about the integrity of both religious institutions and political systems.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the misuse of Catholic school funds to support conservative political agendas as a serious ethical violation, emphasizing the exploitation of public money for partisan purposes. While the subject involves religious institutions and politics, the framing leans left by highlighting腐

Why factuality (85): The article reports on allegations of corruption involving Catholic Schools NSW CEO Dallas McInerney and his alleged ties to the NSW Liberal Party, based on evidence presented at an inquiry. These claims align with the cross-source consensus among the articles, though specific details like 'Dallas p

Why objectivity (65): The tone of the article is critical of the Catholic Church and the Liberal Party, suggesting a political bias. Phrases like 'breathtaking entitlement' and 'running joke' carry emotional weight, indicating a lack of neutrality. While the facts are presented, the framing leans toward condemnation rath

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 654 days ago
Catholic schools rort was a ‘running joke’. You won’t hear parents or taxpayers laughing

A major corruption inquiry in New South Wales has uncovered allegations of financial misconduct and misuse of resources within Catholic Schools NSW, a body responsible for overseeing 600 diocesan Catholic schools. Evidence presented at the inquiry suggests that Dallas McInerney, former CEO of Catholic Schools NSW and a prominent figure in the Liberal Party, allegedly used his position to employ Liberal operatives, including Dylan Whitelaw, who worked on initiatives related to the 'Reformers'—a group of right-wing Liberal members. These individuals reportedly spent significant time on Liberal Party activities rather than educational duties. The investigation highlights concerns over the mismanagement of public funds, as Catholic schools receive substantial government support, raising questions about accountability and transparency.

Bias read (Progressive): The article presents the actions of Catholic Schools NSW and its leadership in a critical light, emphasizing financial abuse, entitlement, and misuse of public funds. The tone is strongly disapproving of the behavior described, particularly highlighting the alleged prioritization of Liberal Party ag

Why factuality (85): This article mirrors the first in content, reporting similar allegations against Dallas McInerney and his connections to the Liberal Party. It references the same sources and quotes from Dylan Whitelaw, maintaining consistency with the cross-source consensus. However, it lacks some concluding detail

Why objectivity (65): Like the first article, this piece exhibits a similarly critical tone towards the Catholic Church and the Liberal Party. The language used suggests a partisan perspective, particularly in the way it frames the actions of McInerney and his associates. There is little attempt to present alternative vi

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories