ON
← Back to feed
Berlin: Debate after 'Spiegel' interview with left-wing winner
Austria🏛️ PoliticsLean Conservative

Berlin: Debate after 'Spiegel' interview with left-wing winner

A debate erupted in German politics after the magazine 'Der Spiegel' published internal notes from Berlin Left Party candidate Elif Eralp regarding an interview about forming a coalition government. The controversy stems from Eralp’s decision to remove a section addressing a pro-Hamas activist who attended a party event, citing personal safety concerns and advice from the state criminal police to avoid naming specific individuals due to organized crime risks. Former SPD Mayor Michael Müller criticized this approach, arguing that if a future mayor cannot clearly identify threats, she becomes susceptible to blackmail. In contrast, the Green Party expressed solidarity with Eralp, stating that politicians should not be intimidated, while CDU Mayor Kai Wegner emphasized the need for a firm stance against extremism despite security fears. Eralp declined to comment on the private nature of the leaked notes but affirmed her commitment to ensuring public safety and fighting violence. Additionally, reports indicate that the Left Party is considering filing a complaint with the German Press Council over the publication of these internal communications.

Berlin’s incoming mayor, Elif Eralp, faces a political crisis after internal communications expressing fear for her family’s safety were inadvertently published alongside an authorized interview with the German news magazine Der Spiegel. The controversy erupted on Thursday following the release of notes from Eralp’s team that remained attached to the interview transcript despite her request to strike specific questions and answers. The incident has intensified scrutiny of the Left Party’s relationship with pro-Palestinian activists and complicated ongoing coalition negotiations with the Social Democratic Party and the Greens. Eralp, the Turkish-German politician who led the Left Party to victory in the Berlin municipal election held on September 20, was interviewed by Der Spiegel on Monday in her office at the Berlin House of Representatives. The interview addressed allegations of antisemitism within her party, stemming from incidents where individuals with questionable backgrounds attended the Left Party’s election night celebration in the Neukölln district. Specifically, the magazine asked Eralp about Ibrahim Ibrahim, a pro-Palestinian activist who appeared at the event. Ibrahim, who has described Yahya Sinwar, the former head of Hamas in Gaza, as a "martyr" and "hero," is associated with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a group designated as a terrorist organization by the European Union. According to Der Spiegel, Eralp initially confirmed the connection to Ibrahim in the interview. However, during the standard authorization process, where interviewees review and approve text before publication, her team requested the removal of both the question and her answer. While the main text was edited, internal marginalia and messages between Eralp, her spokesperson, and Kerstin Wolter, the state chairwoman of the Berlin Left Party, were left in the document. These notes were subsequently sent back to the magazine and published. In the leaked annotations, Eralp wrote that she could not put herself and her family in danger for the sake of the interview. She questioned whether the entire interview should be cancelled and stated, "I should never have agreed to this interview." The notes referenced advice previously given by the Berlin State Criminal Police Office, which recommended against naming specific individuals linked to organized crime. Eralp noted that while that previous advice concerned organized crime, the current situation involved "people with connections to Hamas." She further remarked that an unnamed individual, likely her husband, did not want to name specific persons because he feared them, adding, "He is afraid of these people, and so am I." The publication triggered immediate backlash from across the political spectrum. Former Berlin Mayor Michael Müller, a member of the Social Democratic Party, argued on the Phoenix television channel that if Eralp refuses to clearly identify whom she opposes, it implies the future governing mayor is extortable. Conversely, the Berlin branch of the Green Party expressed solidarity with Eralp. Philmon Ghirmai, the Green state chairman, stated that it is unacceptable for a leading politician to fear for their safety, though he emphasized that politicians would not allow themselves to be intimidated. Kai Wegner, the current Governing Mayor from the Christian Democratic Union, demanded a clear stance against extremists, asserting that politicians must not have to fear for themselves or their families. Eralp declined to provide detailed commentary on the reporting, citing the publication of private, internal content. Speaking at the inaugural session of the new parliament, she maintained that worrying about one's family is normal and a result of a "poisoned debate" in recent months. She pledged to ensure social and individual security for all Berliners and vowed to act consistently against organized crime, violence-glorifying organizations, and terror using all available means. She assured residents that they could feel safe in the city, on the streets, and at home. Legal and professional repercussions are now being considered. According to reports from Politico, Eralp’s camp plans to file a complaint with the German Press Council and potentially take legal action against Der Spiegel. The Left Party argues that the magazine violated privacy norms and exposed Eralp to public ridicule and potential danger from the very individuals discussed. Der Spiegel maintains that it fulfilled its journalistic duty, noting that while the questions belonged to the medium and the answers to the interviewee, the remaining annotations created a story of significant public interest. Ibrahim Ibrahim has denied the accusations leveled against him. In a statement released through his lawyers earlier this month, he clarified that he is not a member of the Left Party. He categorically rejected claims of supporting terrorism or Hamas and denied any involvement in antisemitic activities. The incident has cast doubt on the stability of the emerging coalition government. The Left Party’s pro-Palestinian stance was instrumental in mobilizing voters during the campaign, yet Jewish organizations have accused the party of harboring antisemitic elements, charges the party denies. Critics argue that the leaked notes demonstrate an inability to govern effectively if the leader feels threatened by figures within her own political orbit. Supporters counter that the episode highlights the real dangers faced by politicians engaging with radicalized groups and view the reaction as an attempt to discredit the new administration. As coalition talks proceed, the focus remains on how Eralp will navigate the tension between maintaining security protocols and demonstrating firm leadership against extremism.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

ORF News logoORF NewsState / PublicCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 85
Berlin: Debate after 'Spiegel' interview with left-wing winner

A debate erupted in German politics after the magazine 'Der Spiegel' published internal notes from Berlin Left Party candidate Elif Eralp regarding an interview about forming a coalition government. The controversy stems from Eralp’s decision to remove a section addressing a pro-Hamas activist who attended a party event, citing personal safety concerns and advice from the state criminal police to avoid naming specific individuals due to organized crime risks. Former SPD Mayor Michael Müller criticized this approach, arguing that if a future mayor cannot clearly identify threats, she becomes susceptible to blackmail. In contrast, the Green Party expressed solidarity with Eralp, stating that politicians should not be intimidated, while CDU Mayor Kai Wegner emphasized the need for a firm stance against extremism despite security fears. Eralp declined to comment on the private nature of the leaked notes but affirmed her commitment to ensuring public safety and fighting violence. Additionally, reports indicate that the Left Party is considering filing a complaint with the German Press Council over the publication of these internal communications.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced overview of the political fallout by quoting representatives from all major parties involved (SPD, Greens, CDU, and the Left). It accurately reports the conflicting viewpoints: the criticism from the former SPD mayor regarding potential vulnerability to blackmail, the

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (85): The tone is largely neutral and journalistic. It presents the situation as a debate ('Debatte') and quotes opposing sides fairly. While the headline uses the word 'Wahlsiegerin' (winner/elected candidate), which is standard but slightly positive phrasing given she was not yet elected at the time of

Falter logoFalterIndependentConservative
The fear reflected in the mirror. The case of Elif Eralp.

The article discusses a controversy involving the German magazine Der Spiegel and Elif Eralp, the top candidate of the Left Party who recently won the Berlin election. The core issue concerns whether a magazine has the right to remove specific questions and answers during the authorization process of an interview. Eralp requested the removal of a question regarding her association with a known clan member named Ibrahim Ibrahim, but her team inadvertently left a note stating she feared for her family’s safety. The author argues that while this incident is being used politically by critics to undermine the new Left-SPD-Green coalition and attack Chancellor Merz’s policies, the fundamental problem lies in journalistic ethics. The piece suggests that Der Spiegel exploited the situation for a sensationalist cover story, while Eralp’s camp claims their privacy was violated and they were exposed to danger.

Bias read (Conservative): The author uses pejorative terms like 'Antichrist' for housing policies, describes the Left as worse than the early NSDAP, and frames the journalist's actions as legitimate duty rather than ethical breach.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories