UNESCO has added the ancient West Bank site of Sebastia to its World Heritage List and classified it as "in danger," despite strong objections from Israel. The move follows a vote by UNESCO’s World Heritage Committee in Busan, South Korea, which also included five castles in southern Lebanon on the same list. The decision highlights growing tensions over cultural heritage in regions affected by geopolitical disputes. Sebastia, located approximately 10 kilometers northwest of Nablus in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, is widely regarded as the ancient city of Samaria, the capital of the biblical Kingdom of Israel. The site features extensive archaeological remains spanning the Iron Age, Roman, Byzantine, and Islamic periods. According to UNESCO, it is also associated with the burial of John the Baptist, making it a site of significance to both Christianity and Islam. The site was first nominated for inclusion in the World Heritage List in 2012 by the Palestinian delegation, who argued that its preservation required international recognition due to the challenges posed by Israeli control. Israeli authorities have been increasing their presence in the area, with plans to expropriate roughly 500 acres of land near Sebastia in 2025, claiming the action is necessary for the "preservation and development" of the site. However, Palestinian officials and residents argue that these actions threaten the integrity of the site and undermine local livelihoods, particularly those dependent on tourism. Nizar Kayed, deputy mayor of Sebastia, stated that the UNESCO designation could serve as a critical tool to halt further land seizures and settlement expansions. The inclusion of Sebastia on UNESCO’s World Heritage List and its subsequent placement on the "in danger" list underscores concerns over the site’s vulnerability. The UNESCO committee cited the ongoing conflict in the region and the potential risks to the site’s historical and cultural value as justification for the emergency listing. Palestinian Minister of Tourism and Antiquities Hani al-Hayek emphasized that Sebastia represents a unique convergence of civilizations, with layers of archaeological evidence dating back over 2,000 years. He noted that the site’s designation reflects its "outstanding universal value" and the necessity for its protection under international conventions. Meanwhile, Israel has strongly opposed the decision, criticizing UNESCO for what it describes as politically motivated actions. The Israeli Foreign Ministry accused the Palestinian delegation of conducting a "hostile, one-sided campaign" to misrepresent the historical significance of Sebastia and erase its "profound, well-documented Jewish and Christian history." Israel also rejected the inclusion of the five castles in southern Lebanon, including the Crusader-era Beaufort Castle, which was captured by Israeli forces in May during their military operations against Hezbollah. Israeli officials claimed that the castle had been damaged and that the site should not be considered a cultural landmark due to alleged military activity. Lebanese officials welcomed the UNESCO decision, with Culture Minister Ghassan Salame describing it as a "remarkable achievement" in protecting important historical landmarks. He noted that only two of the five castles fall within the Lebanese government’s jurisdiction, while Israel has allegedly destroyed others and threatens to demolish Beaufort Castle. The inclusion of the castles in the "in danger" list reflects the ongoing conflict and the risks posed to these historic sites. The UNESCO decision has sparked broader debates about the role of cultural heritage in international diplomacy and the challenges of preserving historical sites in regions marked by political instability. While UNESCO maintains that its decisions are based on objective assessments of cultural and historical significance, critics argue that the organization is increasingly influenced by political considerations. The situation in Sebastia and the surrounding areas exemplifies the complex interplay between archaeology, national identity, and territorial disputes. As the UNESCO World Heritage Committee continues its sessions in Busan, the implications of the latest additions to the World Heritage List remain unclear. The designation of Sebastia and the Lebanese castles as sites in danger may prompt renewed discussions about international cooperation in preserving cultural heritage, but it also risks deepening existing divisions between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. The future of these sites will likely depend on how effectively international bodies can mediate between competing claims and ensure their protection from further degradation.
5 poročil
Al Jazeera EnglishDržavni / javniProgresivnopred 5 urami Bo Unescov seznam dediščine ustavil izraelske načrte za Sebastio na Zahodnem bregu?Sebastia, starodavno arheološko najdišče na zasedenih Zahodnem bregu, je bila dodana na Unescov seznam svetovne dediščine in na seznam ogroženih kulturnih najdišč. Palestinski uradniki upajo, da bo to označevanje ustavilo izraelske načrte za zaseg približno 180 hektarjev zemljišč, ki obkrožajo najdišče, za kar trdijo, da ogroža kulturno dediščino in lokalno preživetje.
Ocena pristranskosti (Progresivno): V članku je oznaka Unesca označena kot zaščitni ukrep proti izraelskim zasegom zemljišč in širitvi naselbin, poudarja pa grožnjo palestinskim interesom in kulturni dediščini.
France 24 (English)Državni / javniSredinapredvčerajšnjim UNESCO kljub izraelski nasprotovanju doda mesto na Zahodnem bregu in libanske gradove na seznam svetovne dediščineOdbor Združenih narodov je kljub izraelski opoziciji na seznam svetovne dediščine dodal pomembno arheološko najdišče na Zahodnem bregu, Sebastio, in pet gradov v južnem Libanonu. Izrael je nasprotoval imenovanju in jih označil za "orožje kulturne dediščine". Odločitev je bila sprejeta med srečanjem UNESCO-ja v Južni Koreji, kjer je odbor tudi te kraje uvrstil na seznam svetovne dediščine v nevarnosti zaradi tekočih regionalnih konfliktov. Sebastio, ki se nahaja na Izraelovem zahodnem bregu, velja za starodavno prestolnico biblijskega kraljestva Izrael in ima pomembno versko in zgodovinsko vrednost.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): V članku so predstavljeni dejanski dogodki, pri čemer se upošteva vključitev območij na seznam svetovne dediščine in izraelsko nasprotovanje, ne da bi se postavil na katero koli stran.
Associated PressNeodvisenProgresivnopredvčerajšnjim Unesco kljub izraelskim nasprotovanjem doda mesto na Zahodnem bregu in libanske gradove na seznam svetovne dediščineOrganizacija Združenih narodov za izobraževanje, znanost in kulturo (UNESCO) je na seznam svetovne dediščine dodala dve novi lokaciji: lokacijo na Zahodnem bregu in več gradov v Libanonu.
Ocena pristranskosti (Progresivno): Članek se osredotoča na odločitev Unesca o vključitvi območij na Zahodnem bregu, osrednji regiji izraelsko-palestinskega konflikta, kljub izraelskim ugovorom.
The Times of IsraelNeodvisenKonservativnopred 3 dnevi UNESCO je na seznamu ogroženih kulturnih znamenitosti, ki jih nadzirajo Izraelci v Libanonu in na Zahodnem breguUNESCO je na seznam ogrožene svetovne dediščine dodal več spomenikov v Libanonu in na Zahodnem bregu. Med njimi so grad Beaufort v južnem Libanonu, ki so ga izraelske sile zajele med svojimi vojaškimi operacijami proti Hezbollahu, in Sebastia na Zahodnem bregu, starodavno rimsko in judovsko mesto. Vključitev sledi poročilom o poškodbah in stalnih grožnjah za ta mesta zaradi konflikta. Libanonski uradniki so izrazili zaskrbljenost zaradi domnevnega uničenja drugih gradov v regiji, medtem ko palestinske oblasti želijo, da Unesco prizna Sebastio kot palestinsko dediščino.
Ocena pristranskosti (Konservativno): V članku so navedeni izraelski ukrepi, kot so zajetje gradu Beaufort in ekspropriiranje zemljišč v bližini Sebastie, medtem ko se zmanjšuje,
Die ZeitNeodvisenProgresivnopred 3 dnevi Svetovna dediščina: Unesco razglasi mesta v Libanonu in Zahodnem bregu za svetovno dediščinoPet libanonskih gradov in mesto Sebastia na Zahodnem bregu je bilo dodanih na UNESCO-jevo seznam svetovne dediščine v okviru nujnih postopkov zaradi nevarnosti naravnih nesreč, vojn ali konfliktov. Odločitev je sprejel odbor UNESCO-ja med srečanjem v Busan, Južna Koreja. Izrael je kritiziral ta korak in obtožil palestinsko delegacijo, da je začela "sovražno, enostransko kampanjo", da bi izbrisala dokumentirano judovsko in krščansko zgodovino mesta. Izraelsko zunanje ministrstvo je trdilo, da je Sebastia lažno prikazana kot v krizni situaciji. Medtem je pet gradov v Libanonu opisanih kot del neprekinjenega obrambnega sistema, ki odraža zgodovinski razvoj regije. Nemčija je za vključitev na seznam nominirala gozdno naselje v Zehlendorfu.
Ocena pristranskosti (Progresivno): Članek označuje Unesco kot politično motivirano dejanje palestinske delegacije, kar pomeni pristransko pripovedovanje proti Izraelu.
★
Ohranimo novice poštene.
ObjectiveNews financirajo bralci in je brez oglasov – pristranskost vam pokažemo, ne skrijemo. Podprite neodvisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mesec.
Postani podpornik