"Psihični" IT delavec je bil odpuščen, ker je kolegici povedal, da jo je že videl v sanjah, izgubil je boj za odškodnino
Elrich Daudet, IT delavec, ki trdi, da ima preroške sanje, je bil odpuščen s svojega položaja v podjetju Computacenter (UK) Ltd, potem ko je sodelavki poslal ljubezenske pesmi, v katerih je njen vonj omenil kot "cvetje v rajskem vrtu". Ženska, identificirana kot Vanessa De Souza, je poročala, da se zaradi njegovih napredkov počuti nelagodno in panično. Daudet je trdil, da je njegovo prepričanje v preroške sanje zaščiteno prepričanje po zakonih o enakosti in zahteval odškodnino za nepošteno odpuščanje. Vendar pa je vrhovni sodnik za zaposlovanje v Združenem kraljestvu, lord Fairley, zavrnil njegovo trditev in navedel, da njegova dejanja pomenijo nadlegovanje in da njegovo prepričanje v preroške sanje ne spada med zaščitena prepričanja.
Elrich Daudet, a former IT worker at Computacenter (UK) Ltd, has lost his legal battle for compensation after being dismissed for sending love poems to a female colleague, whom he claimed he had already encountered in his dreams. The case, which reached the Employment Appeal Tribunal, concluded that Mr Daudet’s belief in the prophetic nature of his dreams did not qualify as a protected belief under UK equality laws, and that his actions constituted harassment. Daudet, a senior computer analyst at the company, was employed from 2008 until his dismissal in December 2022. He described himself as possessing the "gift" of prophetic dreams, which he believed could foretell the future. According to the tribunal records, he had such visions since childhood, some of which he felt compelled to share with others, particularly when they contained warnings. Other dreams, he said, were more personal and social in nature, which he chose not to disclose. In August 2022, Daudet was introduced by his supervisor to a new colleague, Vanessa De Souza, a relatively recent starter at the company. After a brief face-to-face meeting, he reportedly realized that she was the same woman who had appeared in his dreams months prior. He then sent her a message stating that he had known for a year they would meet and that she was "haunting" his dreams. In subsequent communications, he included love poems, describing her scent as reminiscent of "flowers in the Garden of Eden." These messages led to an internal disciplinary inquiry, during which Daudet was accused of harassment. As a result, he was dismissed for "gross misconduct." Following this, he filed a lawsuit seeking compensation for unfair dismissal, harassment, and discrimination based on his race and his belief in the prophetic power of dreams. During a five-day hearing in 2024, an employment tribunal ruled that there was nothing unfair about his dismissal. The tribunal determined that Daudet’s belief in his ability to foresee the future was not a "protected belief" under equality legislation, as it was too specific to his personal experiences rather than a broader philosophical stance. Additionally, the tribunal found that his messages could reasonably be interpreted as harassment, given the context in which they were received. Daudet appealed the decision, arguing that the lower tribunal had misinterpreted his belief and failed to recognize its significance. His lawyer, Chinonso Ijezie, contended that the belief was not merely about his own abilities but represented a broader conviction regarding the divine nature of dreams. However, the Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected the appeal, affirming that the initial ruling was legally sound. The case highlights the complexities surrounding workplace conduct and the interpretation of personal beliefs in professional settings. While Daudet maintained that his actions were rooted in a deeply held conviction, the tribunal found that the manner in which he expressed these convictions crossed into inappropriate behavior. The outcome underscores the legal boundaries between personal expression and professional conduct, especially in environments where such expressions can lead to discomfort or distress among colleagues. Vanessa De Souza, the female colleague at the center of the dispute, testified that Daudet’s statements made her feel "uncomfortable" and "panicky." She had previously informed another colleague that his proclamations were causing her stress, indicating that his behavior had already begun to affect her work environment. These accounts were central to the tribunal’s determination that his actions constituted harassment. Computacenter (UK) Ltd, a major IT services provider listed on the FTSE100, defended its decision to terminate Daudet’s employment, emphasizing that the company takes all allegations of misconduct seriously. The firm stated that the disciplinary process was conducted in accordance with its policies and that the termination was justified under the circumstances. As the case concludes, Daudet faces the reality that his claims for compensation have been denied. The ruling serves as a precedent for similar cases, reinforcing the importance of maintaining professional boundaries and respecting the comfort of coworkers in the workplace.
Kako je poročala vsaka stran
Isti dogodek, razvrščen po političnem nagibu medijev, ki so o njem poročali.
progresivno
sredina
konservativno
★
Kako je poročala vsaka stran
Podprite neodvisne novice z zavedanjem pristranskosti in odklenite družbeni utrip, glasovanje skupnosti in svoj prilagojen pregled Zame.
Elrich Daudet, IT delavec, ki trdi, da ima preroške sanje, je bil odpuščen s svojega položaja v podjetju Computacenter (UK) Ltd, potem ko je sodelavki poslal ljubezenske pesmi, v katerih je njen vonj omenil kot "cvetje v rajskem vrtu". Ženska, identificirana kot Vanessa De Souza, je poročala, da se zaradi njegovih napredkov počuti nelagodno in panično. Daudet je trdil, da je njegovo prepričanje v preroške sanje zaščiteno prepričanje po zakonih o enakosti in zahteval odškodnino za nepošteno odpuščanje. Vendar pa je vrhovni sodnik za zaposlovanje v Združenem kraljestvu, lord Fairley, zavrnil njegovo trditev in navedel, da njegova dejanja pomenijo nadlegovanje in da njegovo prepričanje v preroške sanje ne spada med zaščitena prepričanja.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): Medtem ko se incident nanaša na ravnanje na delovnem mestu in morebitne trditve glede diskriminacije, članek predstavlja obe strani argumenta, ne da bi odkrito zagovarjal eno perspektivo.
Elrich Daudet, IT delavec, ki se identificira kot 'psihični' z sposobnostmi prerokovalnih sanj, je bil odpuščen s službe v podjetju Computacenter (UK) Ltd leta 2022 po tem, ko je sodelavcu poslal ljubezenske pesmi in trdil, da so se prej srečali v svojih sanjah. Trdil je, da je njegovo prepričanje v prerokovalno naravo sanj predstavljalo zaščiteno prepričanje po zakonih o enakosti in zahteval odškodnino za nepošteno odpuščanje. Vendar pa je vrhovni sodnik za zaposlitev v Združenem kraljestvu, Lord Fairley, odločil proti njemu in navedel, da njegova dejanja - pošiljanje romantičnih sporočil in pesmi - predstavljajo nadlegovanje in niso nujno manifestacija njegovih prepričanj.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): Medtem ko zadeva vključuje osebni sistem prepričanj in ravnanje na delovnem mestu, članek predstavlja obe strani argumenta, ne da bi odkrito zagovarjal eno perspektivo.
★
Ohranimo novice poštene.
ObjectiveNews financirajo bralci in je brez oglasov – pristranskost vam pokažemo, ne skrijemo. Podprite neodvisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mesec.