A former chief executive of Italy's motorway operator has received the maximum 12-year prison sentence for his role in the 2018 collapse of the Morandi Bridge in Genoa, a disaster that killed 43 people. Giovanni Castellucci, once head of Autostrade per l’Italia, was among 32 individuals convicted in the case, with sentences ranging from one year and 11 months to 12 years. The convictions came after a high-profile trial that lasted several years and drew widespread attention across Italy. The Morandi Bridge collapsed during a summer storm in August 2018, when a 50-meter section gave way, causing vehicles to plunge onto warehouses and a riverbed below. The incident shocked the nation and highlighted long-standing concerns about the safety of aging infrastructure. The trial focused heavily on whether the collapse was due to poor maintenance practices or a fundamental design flaw in the bridge itself. Castellucci's legal team expressed disappointment with the verdict, stating they would appeal. They argued that as CEO, Castellucci relied on Italy’s top engineers and maintained that the disaster stemmed from a critical error in the bridge’s original design, specifically the failure of stay cable No 9. This argument contrasted sharply with prosecutors' claims that years of neglect, ignored warnings, and delayed safety work played a major role in the collapse. The sentencing took place in a quiet courtroom in northwest Italy, attended by around 400 people, including victims' families, lawyers, journalists, and members of the public. Emotional scenes unfolded as some relatives embraced and cried, while others sought time to process the outcome. Egle Possetti, a representative for the victims, stated that the group needed more time to fully comprehend the implications of the ruling, given the complexity of the case involving numerous defendants. Among the 32 convicted individuals, some faced lighter sentences, while others were acquitted or saw charges expire due to the statute of limitations. The trial not only addressed the tragic loss of life but also tested Italy’s judicial system, known for its slowness in handling complex cases. Prosecutors emphasized that the disaster revealed systemic issues in how infrastructure was managed and maintained in the country. The political landscape shifted following the tragedy, with the Benetton family eventually giving up their controlling interest in Autostrade per l’Italia. Meanwhile, the remnants of the Morandi Bridge were dismantled and replaced by the Genoa San Giorgio Bridge, designed by renowned architect Renzo Piano. The new structure, completed in August 2020, incorporates elements inspired by Genoa’s maritime history, featuring sail-like shapes that reflect the city's seafaring past. The trial underscored the ongoing debate over infrastructure safety and corporate responsibility in Italy. While the victims' families seek closure, the broader implications of the case continue to resonate within the country’s legal and political spheres. The new bridge stands as a symbol of renewal, yet questions about the management of aging infrastructure persist.
2 poročil
The Guardian (World)NeodvisenSredinaDejstva 75Objektivnost 70včeraj Nekdanji šef italijanske avtoceste obsojen na 12 let zaradi tragedije na GenoviGiovanni Castellucci, nekdanji izvršni direktor italijanskega avtoceste operaterja Autostrade per l'Italia, je bil obsojen na 12 let zapora zaradi vloge v propadu mostu Morandi v Genovi leta 2018, v katerem je umrlo 43 ljudi.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): Članek predstavlja uravnotežen opis sodnih postopkov, ki podrobno opisujejo argumente tožilstva, ki poudarjajo zanemarjanje in odločitve, usmerjene v dobiček, ter trditve obrambe, ki pripisujejo nesrečo strukturnim pomanjkljivostim.
Zakaj dejstva (75): The article accurately reports the conviction of Giovanni Castellucci and mentions the 43 deaths in the Morandi bridge collapse. However, it omits specific details such as the 200-year total sentence for all defendants and the plea bargain involving ASPI and SPEA. The article also does not mention t
Zakaj objektivnost (70): The article maintains a relatively neutral tone but includes some emotionally charged descriptions like 'hushed courtroom' and 'some relatives embraced and wept.' The quote from Castellucci's lawyer calling the verdict 'a defeat for the truth' introduces a biased perspective, suggesting doubt in the
Daily MirrorNeodvisenSredinapred 8 urami Nekdanji vrhunski britanski policist je po nesreči na volanu ubil očeta dveh otrok.Nekdanji detektiv glavni inšpektor Michael Cooper iz Derbyshire Constabulary je 28. septembra 2021 povzročil smrtno nesrečo, ko je vozil brez oznake policijski avto v Etwallu v Derbyshiru. Cooper, ki ga je predhodno leta 2009 opozoril nevrolog o preteklih blackoutih, ni obvestil DVLA, svojega delodajalca ali zavarovalnice.
Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): Članek predstavlja dejstva o zadevi in sodno odločitev, ne da bi očitno naklonil nobeni politični strani.
★
Ohranimo novice poštene.
ObjectiveNews financirajo bralci in je brez oglasov – pristranskost vam pokažemo, ne skrijemo. Podprite neodvisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mesec.
Postani podpornik