ON
← Nazaj na pregled
Pakistanska propaganda? Kopiraj in prilepi objave, ki obtožujejo Indijce, ker je Savdija usmrtila dva Bangladešca
India🏛️ PolitikaBolj konservativnopred 5 urami

Pakistanska propaganda? Kopiraj in prilepi objave, ki obtožujejo Indijce, ker je Savdija usmrtila dva Bangladešca

Saudska Arabija je v Meki usmrtila dva državljana Bangladeša, Nazrul Islam Abdul Bashir in Sweety Akhtar, zaradi domnevnih nemoralnih dejanj, čeprav niti njuni družini niti bangladeška vlada nista bila vnaprej obveščena. Uradni zapisi kažejo, da je par delal kot čistilci za saudsko podjetje in so bili aretirani v začetku leta 2023 na podlagi zakonov o kibernetskih kaznivih dejanjih in prešuštvi, kljub temu, da so družinski člani izpodbijali obtožbe in domnevno zarote, ki vključujejo sodelavce. Zaradi pomanjkanja podrobnih uradnih razkritij v zvezi s specifičnimi prekrški ali dokazi, so se nepotrjene objave na družbenih omrežjih razširile po Pakistanu, Bangladešu in Afriki. V istih objavah napačno obtožujejo neimenovanega Indijca, da je olajšal domnevno razmerje med parom in posnel incident. To trditev zavračajo družine žrtev, ki trdijo, da se posamezniki ne poznajo. Širjenje te dezinformacije poudarja vakuum, ki ga ustvarja omejena preglednost saudskih oblasti v zvezi s pravnimi postopki.

Bangladesh’s government expressed intense frustration on Monday after discovering that two of its citizens, who were executed in Saudi Arabia’s holy city of Mecca on October 14, had been omitted from a critical list of death sentences provided by Riyadh. Dhaka alleges that the omission prevented Bangladeshi diplomats from intervening to potentially save the lives of Nazrul Islam Abdul Basir and Sweety Akhtar. The executions took place without prior notification to the Bangladeshi government or the families of the deceased, leading to accusations of a serious lapse in consular communication between the two nations. Md Sakhawat Hossain, the Bangladesh consul general in Jeddah, raised the issue directly with Farid bin Saad Al Shehri, the director general of Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs. During the meeting, the Saudi official was unable to offer a satisfactory explanation for why the specific death sentences were missing from the documentation sent to Dhaka. Following this discussion, Bangladesh dispatched an additional diplomatic note requesting comprehensive details regarding the judicial proceedings. Officials at the Bangladeshi Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that the initial list, transmitted on September 30, did include the names of Nazrul and Sweety along with descriptions of the offenses they were accused of committing. However, it failed to specify that they had been sentenced to death. The diplomatic crisis unfolded rapidly after the executions. On October 15, the Bangladesh Consulate in Jeddah sent a note to Saudi authorities seeking information. By October 18, Dhaka had escalated the matter by raising it with Saudi Ambassador Abdullah Zafer bin Abiyah. State Minister for Foreign Affairs Humaiun Kobir described the executions as "very disappointing" on Monday. He emphasized that Bangladesh maintains a deep relationship with Saudi Arabia, particularly at the prime ministerial level, and noted that both countries are signatories to the Geneva Conventions. Kobir argued that the gap in information sharing hindered the ability of the diplomatic mission to provide necessary consular assistance. He added that Bangladesh expects reciprocal treatment, promising to notify Saudi Arabia immediately if a Saudi national faces arrest in Bangladesh. Shama Obaed Islam, the State Minister for Foreign Affairs, indicated that the government is currently waiting for copies of the final verdicts to understand the specifics of the cases. She stated that once the documents are reviewed, Dhaka will engage further with Saudi authorities to determine potential next steps. The ministry confirmed that it has not yet received detailed information about the individuals or the formal response from Riyadh regarding the procedural failures. Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Interior announced via the Saudi Press Agency that the two men and women were convicted of committing "immoral acts" inside a mosque in Mecca. The ministry confirmed that the death penalties were imposed under the principle of ta'zir, a category of Islamic law involving discretionary punishments determined by judges for offenses where specific penalties are not prescribed in religious texts. The sentences were reportedly upheld by judicial authorities and authorized by a royal order. Despite these confirmations, Riyadh has not publicly detailed the specific acts committed, the timing of arrests, or the conduct of the trials. A confidential memo from the Bangladesh Consulate General in Jeddah, obtained by local media, revealed that both victims were employed as cleaners by the Saudi company Al Majal. The prisoner list received on September 30 indicated that Nazrul had been detained on August 1, 2023, under Saudi cybercrime laws, while Sweety was detained the following day on allegations of adultery. Both families have firmly disputed these charges. Nazrul’s relatives claimed he was the victim of a conspiracy orchestrated by a Pakistani co-worker with whom he had previously had a dispute. Sweety’s family asserted that she was arrested after some of her female colleagues allegedly purchased a vehicle illegally. Neither account has been independently verified. Social media platforms have become a battleground for conflicting narratives. Unverified posts, originating from Pakistan-based accounts and replicated by users in Bangladesh, Africa, and elsewhere, allege that Nazrul and Sweety were in a romantic relationship and engaged in adultery in a secluded area between gates 85 and 87 of the Grand Mosque. These viral claims assert that an Indian man stood guard during the encounter and later circulated a recording of the event after failing to pursue a relationship with Sweety. The posts claim the Indian man was sentenced to 20 years in prison. However, no official records substantiate these allegations, and both families have rejected the notion that the two knew each other romantically, stating they were strangers. Other online rumors suggested the offense involved nothing more than a kiss on the forehead, a claim also denied by the families. Nazrul, the eldest son of Abdul Bashir and Rahima Begum, hailed from Brahmanbaria Sadar upazila in Chattogram Division. He moved to Saudi Arabia in November 2022 to work as a cleaner at Masjid al-Haram. His family reported that police arrested him approximately eight months after his arrival. Relatives said they last spoke to him on October 11, receiving news of his execution three days later. His 65-year-old aunt, Abeda Begum, fainted upon hearing the news and subsequently died. Nazrul’s father, Abdul Basir, who had worked in Saudi Arabia for 24 years, demanded justice, stating that his son was not afforded a fair trial. The case highlights broader concerns regarding transparency in Saudi judicial processes. Human rights organizations have documented high rates of capital punishment in the kingdom, with many sentences handed down for non-violent offenses. In a similar recent instance, a Sri Lankan Hindu immigrant named Anojan Sivarasa was sentenced to death for blasphemy, though his conviction was later overturned following intervention by the Sri Lankan government. More than three million Bangladeshi citizens live and work in Saudi Arabia, predominantly in low-wage sectors. The current diplomatic standoff leaves the bodies of the two executed citizens in Saudi custody, with Dhaka pressing for their repatriation alongside the requested legal clarifications.

Kako je nastalo to poročilo. Objektivne novice je to poročilo napisal iz 2 izvornih člankov s pomočjo umetne inteligence po naši metodologiji. Gre za naše lastno besedilo, ne za kopijo posameznega medija. Preberite našo metodologijo.

Odgovorni urednik: Matej BašaSte opazili napako? Sporočite jo

3 poročil

Times of India logoTimes of IndiaNeodvisenSredinaDejstva 85Objektivnost 90včeraj
Bangladeš je besen, ker na saudski seznam zaporov ni bilo smrtnih kazni za dva državljana

Bangladeš je izrazil močno nezadovoljstvo s Savdsko Arabijo, potem ko sta bila dva njena državljana, Nazrul Islam in Sweety Akhter, usmrčena v Meki 14. oktobra brez predhodnega obvestila Daki. Bangladeška vlada je kritizirala saudske oblasti, ker so opustile smrtne kazni s seznama obsojenih državljanov, ki so jih dobili 30. septembra, kar je Bangladešu preprečilo potencialno posredovanje. Generalni konzul Bangladeša v Džedi je to vprašanje neposredno dvignil s saudsko predstavništvom in poslali so dodatne diplomatske note, v katerih so zahtevali podrobne informacije o primeru, vključno s sodnim postopkom in ali so imeli posamezniki priložnost, da se branijo. Bangladeš je poudaril pomen konzularne komunikacije in poudaril obstoječe diplomatske vezi med obema narodoma.

Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): V članku so predstavljeni dejanski primeri, osredotočeni na diplomatske ukrepe Bangladeša in njegove pomisleke glede konzularne komunikacije s Savdsko Arabijo. V njem ni očitno pristranskega jezika, enostranskega iskanja virov ali uredništva. Oblike obeh držav so omenjene brez jasnih ciljev.

Zakaj dejstva (85): The article provides specific details such as the names of the individuals involved (Nazrul Islam and Sweety Akhter), dates (October 14 execution, September 30 list submission), and the roles of the Bangladeshi consul general and Saudi official. These align with the cross-source consensus. The menti

Zakaj objektivnost (90): The article presents the situation in a neutral manner, reporting facts without apparent bias. It uses formal language and avoids emotionally charged terms. The focus is on the diplomatic response and procedural issues rather than taking sides.

India Today logoIndia TodayNeodvisenSredinaDejstva 85Objektivnost 75včeraj
Ubil zaradi poljuba v mošeji? Tajna saudska usmrtitev Bangladešcev je povzročila ogorčenje

Saudijska Arabija je usmrtila dva državljana Bangladeša, Nazrul Islam Abdul Basir in Siti Akhtar, zaradi "nemoralnih dejanj", storjenih v mošeji v Meki. Narava domnevnih dejanj ostaja neopažena s strani saudskih oblasti, kar vodi do domneve, da se je par morda poljubil. Izvršitev je sprožila mednarodno kritiko, zlasti glede pomanjkanja preglednosti v procesu sojenja in pravičnosti kazni. To je posledica prejšnjih sporov, ki so vključevali tuje državljane v Savdski Arabiji, kot je primer moškega iz Šrilanke, katerega smrtna obsodba je bila kasneje razveljavljena. Vprašanja ostajajo glede tega, ali je bila Bangladeš obveščen pred usmrtitvami in ali so lahko diplomatska prizadevanja vplivala na izid.

Ocena pristranskosti (Sredina): V članku je dogodek predstavljen nevtralno, s poudarkom na dejanjih Savdske Arabije ter reakcijah Bangladeša in mednarodnih opazovalcev. Ne prikazuje očitno pristranskega jezika in zagotavlja več pogledov, ne da bi favoriziral eno stran. Oblikovanje je objektivno, poudarja lakov

Zakaj dejstva (85): The article provides general information about the executions of two Bangladeshi nationals in Saudi Arabia for 'immoral acts' in a mosque, citing Saudi media and referencing broader context about Saudi Arabia's use of the death penalty. It mentions the legal framework (ta'zir) and references another

Zakaj objektivnost (75): The article uses emotionally charged terms like 'outrage' and 'secret execution,' which may imply bias or sensationalism. It raises questions about the fairness of the trial and the lack of transparency, but does so in a way that suggests criticism of the Saudi system without overtly taking sides. T

India Today logoIndia TodayNeodvisenKonservativnoDejstva: uradni vir/dokument ni zaznanObjektivnost 70pred 5 urami
Pakistanska propaganda? Kopiraj in prilepi objave, ki obtožujejo Indijce, ker je Savdija usmrtila dva Bangladešca

Saudska Arabija je v Meki usmrtila dva državljana Bangladeša, Nazrul Islam Abdul Bashir in Sweety Akhtar, zaradi domnevnih nemoralnih dejanj, čeprav niti njuni družini niti bangladeška vlada nista bila vnaprej obveščena. Uradni zapisi kažejo, da je par delal kot čistilci za saudsko podjetje in so bili aretirani v začetku leta 2023 na podlagi zakonov o kibernetskih kaznivih dejanjih in prešuštvi, kljub temu, da so družinski člani izpodbijali obtožbe in domnevno zarote, ki vključujejo sodelavce. Zaradi pomanjkanja podrobnih uradnih razkritij v zvezi s specifičnimi prekrški ali dokazi, so se nepotrjene objave na družbenih omrežjih razširile po Pakistanu, Bangladešu in Afriki. V istih objavah napačno obtožujejo neimenovanega Indijca, da je olajšal domnevno razmerje med parom in posnel incident. To trditev zavračajo družine žrtev, ki trdijo, da se posamezniki ne poznajo. Širjenje te dezinformacije poudarja vakuum, ki ga ustvarja omejena preglednost saudskih oblasti v zvezi s pravnimi postopki.

Ocena pristranskosti (Konservativno): V članku se širjenje dezinformacij označuje kot "pakistanska propaganda", pri čemer se izvor lažnih trditev pripisuje računu s sedežem v Pakistanu in poudarja geopolitično napetost med Indijo in Pakistanom. S poudarkom obtožbe proti indijski državljan in označevanje dism

Zakaj dejstva: uradni vir/dokument ni zaznan

Zakaj objektivnost (70): The headline uses the charged phrase 'Pak propaganda?' which introduces a speculative and potentially inflammatory frame before the body text begins. While the body itself attempts neutrality by noting that family accounts are 'unverified' and citing official memos, the initial framing leans toward

Kako je poročala vsaka stran

Isti dogodek, razvrščen po političnem nagibu medijev, ki so o njem poročali.

Kako je poročala vsaka stran

Podprite neodvisne novice z zavedanjem pristranskosti in odklenite družbeni utrip, glasovanje skupnosti in vse druge funkcije za podpornike.

Postani podpornik

Poročanje po svetu

Isti dogodek, kot so ga poročali v drugih državah.

Poročanje po svetu

Podprite neodvisne novice z zavedanjem pristranskosti in odklenite družbeni utrip, glasovanje skupnosti in vse druge funkcije za podpornike.

Postani podpornik

Preverjanje trditev

Ključne dejanske trditve in koliko virov jih potrjuje oz. zavrača.

Preverjanje trditev

Podprite neodvisne novice z zavedanjem pristranskosti in odklenite družbeni utrip, glasovanje skupnosti in vse druge funkcije za podpornike.

Postani podpornik

Ohranimo novice poštene.

ObjectiveNews financirajo bralci in je brez oglasov – pristranskost vam pokažemo, ne skrijemo. Podprite neodvisno novinarstvo za 4 €/mesec.

Postani podpornik

Povezane zgodbe