ON
← Natrag na feed
Noah Donohoe inquest adjourned until later this year, as jury unable to reach unanimous verdict
Ireland🏛️ Politikajučer

Noah Donohoe inquest adjourned until later this year, as jury unable to reach unanimous verdict

The inquest into the death of 14-year-old Noah Donohoe, who was found drowned in an underground water tunnel in Belfast in June 2020, has been adjourned until later this year. The jury, consisting of eight men and two women, was tasked with reaching unanimous answers to 10 questions, including the exact date of his death and whether police actions contributed to his demise. After deliberating for nearly 24 hours over three days, the jury was unable to reach a consensus, prompting Judge Mr Justice Rooney to adjourn the proceedings. Several jurors became unavailable, leading to the unprecedented decision to delay the inquest until August or September. The inquest, which began in January, heard testimony from 76 witnesses, along with additional statements, visual evidence, and expert reports. Noah's mother attended every session, and the coroner emphasized that jurors must base their findings solely on the evidence presented.

Robson Nkosana Prince Nkomo, 33-godišnji građevinski radnik koji je živio u hotelu Ripley Court u Dublinu 1, tragično je izgubio život nakon što je pao u unutarnji dok u Harbourmaster Placeu.

Njegova smrt označila je mračan trenutak za njegovu obitelj i izazvala zabrinutost zbog sigurnosnih mjera oko dokova u dublinskom sjevernom gradu.

Nkomo, kojeg je njegova majka, Euredis Chippendo, opisala kao vještog plivača koji ju je naučio plivati, pio je s prijateljem u unutarnjem doku oko 20:30 sati.

Fernandez je odmah počeo pokušavati pomoći svom prijatelju, vičući mu da skine cipele i ruksak. Nakon otprilike tri minute, shvatio je da se Nkomo bori da ostane na površini i sam je skočio u vodu.

Garda Ava Daimon svjedočila je da je Nkomo bio u kritičnom stanju kada su ga vatrogasci iz Dublina izvukli iz vode.

Nakon što je stigao u Mater Misericordiae Univerzitetsku bolnicu u 10:31, Nkomo je procijenjen zbog posljedica dugotrajnog uranja u hladnu vodu. Unatoč medicinskim intervencijama, uključujući ventilaciju i zagrijavanje, ostao je bez svijesti tijekom cijele noći. Sljedećeg jutra u 2:56 ujutro službeno je proglašen mrtvim.

Mrtvozornik Clare Keane istaknuo je nekoliko čimbenika koji su doprinijeli tragediji.

Njena majka, Euredis Chippendo, naglasila je da je njezin sin od djetinjstva bio posvećeni plivač. Ona je također spomenula da je nedavno pretrpio ozljedu ruke koja je zahtijevala gips, što je moglo utjecati na njegovu sposobnost da učinkovito pliva u hladnoj vodi.

Kako se zajednica bori s gubitkom, vjerojatno će se nastaviti rasprave o poboljšanju sigurnosnih mjera na javnim dokovima i rješavanju potencijalnih ranjivosti u postojećim sigurnosnim protokolima.

7 izvještaja

RTÉ News logoRTÉ NewsDržavni / javniSredinaČinjenice 85Objektivnost 95prije 4 dana
Porota na Bouchakarovom suđenju nastavit će raspravu sutra.

Porota u suđenju Riadu Bouchakeru, koji je optužen za pokušaj ubojstva i napada na više osoba u Dublinu u studenom 2023. godine, nastavit će razmatranje nakon što zatraži dodatne informacije o pravnim definicijama, svjedočenjima svjedoka i zaključnim argumentima. Bouchaker, koji se izjasnio da nije kriv za sve optužbe, suočava se s optužbama, uključujući pokušaj ubojstva troje djece i napad na nekoliko drugih, uključujući radnika vrtića. Sud je naglasio da porota mora temeljiti svoju odluku isključivo na predstavljenim dokazima, izbjegavajući vanjske utjecaje kao što su javno mišljenje ili nepovezani incidenti. Sudac Tony Hunt naložio je poroti da ostane objektivna, usredotočujući se na pravne kriterije za pokušaj ubojstva, posebno naglašavajući potrebu da se dokaže blizina činu ubojstva, a ne samo namjera ili priprema.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak pruža uravnotežen izvještaj o sudskom postupku, citirajući upute sudaca poroti i detaljno opisuje optužbe protiv optuženog bez očiglednog ideološkog okvira.

Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 85 · Objektivnost 95): Factual but incomplete, focusing on the ongoing deliberation rather than the final verdict. Highly objective with clear emphasis on judicial instructions to the jury and neutrality in reporting.

TheJournal.ie logoTheJournal.ieNeovisanSredinajučer
Noah Donohoe inquest adjourned until later this year, as jury unable to reach unanimous verdict

The inquest into the death of 14-year-old Noah Donohoe, who was found drowned in an underground water tunnel in Belfast in June 2020, has been adjourned until later this year. The jury, consisting of eight men and two women, was tasked with reaching unanimous answers to 10 questions, including the exact date of his death and whether police actions contributed to his demise. After deliberating for nearly 24 hours over three days, the jury was unable to reach a consensus, prompting Judge Mr Justice Rooney to adjourn the proceedings. Several jurors became unavailable, leading to the unprecedented decision to delay the inquest until August or September. The inquest, which began in January, heard testimony from 76 witnesses, along with additional statements, visual evidence, and expert reports. Noah's mother attended every session, and the coroner emphasized that jurors must base their findings solely on the evidence presented.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents a factual account of the inquest process without overtly favoring any political stance. It focuses on the procedural aspects of the legal inquiry rather than taking a position on the broader implications of the case, which involves potential systemic issues in policing or public

The Irish Times logoThe Irish TimesNeovisan🔒Sredinajučer
Inquest into death of Noah Donohoe adjourned until later this year

An inquest into the death of 14-year-old Belfast boy Noah Donohoe has been postponed until later this year due to extended jury deliberations lasting over 24 hours. The coroner, Kevin Rooney, described the situation as 'unprecedented,' noting that the court session ran until 12:50 am on Friday. The inquest, which began in late January and was expected to conclude by Easter, has heard testimony from 76 witnesses and statements from 42 others. The case centers on determining the exact date of Noah's death and whether any police errors contributed to his demise. His body was discovered in an underground water tunnel in north Belfast in June 2020, following a reported incident involving him falling off his bicycle and discarding his clothing. Noah's mother, Fiona Donohoe, has attended every session of the inquest and has advocated publicly for clarity regarding her son's death.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents factual developments surrounding the inquest without overtly favoring any political stance. While the subject involves a public inquiry into a youth's death, the tone remains neutral, focusing on procedural updates rather than taking sides or promoting ideological positions. The

RTÉ News logoRTÉ NewsDržavni / javniSredinajučer
Donohoe inquest adjourned after 25 hours of deliberations

The inquest into the death of 14-year-old Noah Donohoe in Belfast in 2020 has been adjourned after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict despite 25 hours of deliberation over three days. The coroner, Mr Justice Kevin Rooney, decided to postpone the proceedings until all 10 jurors are available, as some could not attend the next session. The jury is tasked with answering 10 questions related to Noah's death, including whether police errors contributed to his death. His body was discovered in an underground water tunnel six days after he went missing in June 2020. The inquest, which began in January, has included testimony from 76 witnesses and reviewed various evidence such as maps, videos, photographs, police logs, and expert reports. A post-mortem determined that Noah died from drowning. His mother, Fiona, has attended every day of the inquest.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article provides a balanced account of the inquest proceedings without apparent bias toward any side. It focuses on procedural aspects of the legal process and does not take a stance on the issues being investigated, such as potential police errors. The language remains neutral, and there is no

RTÉ News logoRTÉ NewsDržavni / javniSredinaprekjučer
Jury in Noah Donohoe inquest continues deliberations

The inquest into the death of 14-year-old Noah Donohoe, who was found drowned in a Belfast underground water tunnel in 2020 after going missing for six days, has entered its third day of jury deliberations. The coroner, Mr Justice Kevin Rooney, addressed the jury of eight men and two women, emphasizing that their findings must be based solely on the evidence presented during the inquest, which included testimony from 76 witnesses, statements from 42 others, and various documents such as maps, videos, photos, and police records. Noah’s mother, Fiona, has attended all sessions. The coroner stressed that the jury must reach a unanimous decision without time constraints, ensuring that all parties involved remain available until a conclusion is reached.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents a factual account of the inquest proceedings without overtly favoring any political stance. It focuses on the legal process and does not frame the case through a specific ideological lens. While the subject involves a tragic incident and potential systemic issues, the reporting,

RTÉ News logoRTÉ NewsDržavni / javniSredinaprije 4 dana
Čovjek se utopio nakon što je pao u dublinski gradski dok - istraga

Čovjek po imenu Robson Nkosana Prince Nkomo, 33, umro je nakon što je pao u Inner Dock u sjevernom gradu Dublina. On i njegov prijatelj pili su na doku kada je Nkomo izgubio ravnotežu i pao u vodu. Njegov prijatelj pokušao ga je spasiti tako što je držao glavu iznad vode otprilike 40 minuta prije nego što su spašeni. Unatoč naporima da ga ožive više od četiri sata, Nkomo je proglašen mrtvim u bolnici Mater Misericordiae.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak sadrži činjenični izvještaj o istrazi u slučaju davljenja. Ne predstavlja nikakvu otvoreno pristrasnu riječ, niti favorizira jednu stranu nad drugom. Sadržaj se fokusira na slijed događaja i svjedočenja predstavljenih tijekom istrage bez očiglednog ideološkog okvira.

TheJournal.ie logoTheJournal.ieNeovisanSredinaprije 4 dana
Čovjek se utopio nakon pada u doku unatoč prijatelju koji je držao glavu iznad vode 40 minuta

Robson Nkosana Prince Nkomo (33), građevinski radnik koji je živio u Dublinu, utopio se nakon što je pao u Inner Dock u sjevernom gradu. Bio je sa svojim prijateljem Emeraldo Fernandezom, koji je pokušao držati Nkomoovu glavu iznad vode otprilike 40 minuta prije nego što su spašeni. Unatoč opsežnim naporima oživljavanja koji su trajali više od četiri sata, Nkomo je proglašen mrtvim 11. studenoga 2024.

Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak izvještava o tragičnom incidentu davljenja u kojem je sudjelovao lokalni stanovnik i ne predstavlja nikakva politička mišljenja, argumente ili okvire koji bi ukazivali na određenu ideološku sklonost.

Neka vijesti ostanu poštene.

ObjectiveNews financiraju čitatelji i bez oglasa je – pristranost vam pokazujemo, ne skrivamo. Podržite neovisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mjesec.

Postani podupiratelj

Povezane priče