D'Artagnan, jedan od najpoznatijih likova romana Aleksandre Dumasove "Tri mušketire", bio je stvarna povijesna ličnost koja je poginula 25. lipnja 1673. godine tijekom francusko-nizozemske rata, kada je bila ranjena tijekom opsade Maastrichta. Sada, u srpskoj državi Nizozemsku, u gradu Maastricht, dolazi novi zanimljiv razvoj pronađen je kostur koji se može povezati s ovom ikonikom. Međutim, kao i u mnogim slučajevima povijesnih otkrića, situacija nije jasna. Gradski vijeće objavilo je da je podrijetlina kostura i okolnosti njegove smrti još uvijek nepoznata, a daljnja istraživanja mogu pokazati da je živ ili povijesno otkriven.
Kostur je pronađen pod podom crkve svetih Petra i Pavla, a analiza je pokazala da pripada muškarcu između 44 i 66 godina. Ova doba poklapa s dobom koju je imao d'Artagnan kada je poginuo, ali nije bilo moguće precizno datirati smrt. Istraživači su također primijetili da je prehrana muškarca bila bogata ribom, što je tipično za istočnu ili južnu Europu, a ne za Gaskonju u jugozapadnoj Francuskoj, gdje je d'Artagnan rođen.
Međutim, istraživanje je bilo ozbiljno otežano djelovanjem pokojnog arheologa Wima Dijkmana, koji je počeo kopati grobove ispod crkve bez potrebnih dozvola. Dijkman je priznao da nije obavijestio vlasti o svom radu, jer je želio zasluge za svoje otkriće. Također je priznao da je nekoliko kostiju sačuvao u plastičnoj kutiji u svojoj kući u vrtu, a vratio ih je nadležnim vlastima tek kada je to naložio policiji. Njegov rad je rezultirao izgubljenom vrijednošću jerma, koji je vjerojatno ostao u kostima i nije dokumentirao svoj rad prema standardima, što ga je spriječilo u datiranju grobova.
Kada je crkva saznala da nema odgovarajuće odobrenje, Dijkman je bio prisiljen zaustaviti svoj rad, a 13. ožujka je dobio priliku uzeti profesionalni tim. Istraživači su naglasili da je ovo otkriće možda već uključivalo nekoliko "iznenadnih elemenata" koji upućuju na drugi smjer. Iako je d'Artagnan bio jedan od glavnih likova u Dumasovom romanu, bio je stvarna ličnost, a njegovo posljednje mjesto još uvijek nije poznato.
Uključujući analizu drevne DNK, istraživači su izrazili potrebu za dodatnim istraživanjima kako bi se odgovorilo na pitanje je li otkrivena istinska povijest ili ne.
2 izvještaja
tportalNeovisanSredinajučerThe article discusses the discovery of human remains beneath the Church of Saint Peter and Paul in a town, which has raised questions about whether they belong to the historical figure d'Artagnan, a central character in Alexandre Dumas' novel 'The Three Musketeers'. Local authorities stated that the origin of the skeleton and circumstances of death remain unclear, and further research is needed. The remains were identified as belonging to a man aged between 44 and 66, matching the age at which d'Artagnan died. However, the skeleton could not be dated, and dietary analysis suggested a diet rich in fish typical of Eastern or Southern Europe rather than Gascony in southwestern France, where d'Artagnan was born. This raises doubts about whether such a diet was common among French musketeers in the 17th century. The investigation was complicated by an amateur archaeologist who began excavating without proper permits, damaging the remains and losing valuable data. Professional teams later took over, and further DNA analysis is required to confirm if the remains could be definitively linked to d'Artagnan.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents a balanced account of the archaeological findings and their implications, without overtly favoring any particular political stance. It reports on scientific and historical inquiry without taking a clear ideological position, focusing on the factual aspects of the investigation.
Index.hrNeovisanSredinajučerThe remains discovered this year under a church in Maastricht cannot be definitively identified as those of the famous French musketeer Charles de Batz de Castelmore d'Artagnan, according to local authorities. The investigation of the remains found in the Church of Saints Peter and Paul has not completely ruled out the possibility that they belong to d'Artagnan but has uncovered several surprising elements suggesting otherwise. The remains appear to belong to a man aged between 44 and 66 years old, which matches d'Artagnan's age at death (62). However, the exact time of death could not be determined due to the lack of dating methods. Analysis showed that the individual consumed a diet rich in fish typical of eastern or southern Europe rather than Gascony in southwestern France where d'Artagnan was born. This raises questions about whether such a diet was common among Catholic musketeers in 17th-century France. The research was complicated by the actions of a retired archaeologist who began excavating the grave without proper permits, potentially damaging the bones and losing valuable information. The archaeologist, Wim Dijkman, admitted he did not inform the authorities about his发掘
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents findings from archaeological research and does not show clear bias toward any political side. It reports on scientific analysis and the involvement of local authorities without apparent ideological framing.
★
Neka vijesti ostanu poštene.
ObjectiveNews financiraju čitatelji i bez oglasa je – pristranost vam pokazujemo, ne skrivamo. Podržite neovisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mjesec.
Postani podupiratelj
Croatia
