The Knesset passed the first reading of a controversial Basic Law on Wednesday, July 1, 2026, which seeks to enshrine Torah study as a foundational value of the State of Israel. The bill, sponsored by ultra-Orthodox lawmakers including MK Moshe Gafni of the United Torah Judaism Party, was approved by a narrow margin of 63 votes in favor to 53 against. The legislation, which aims to protect draft evading yeshiva students from legal repercussions, marks a significant shift in Israel’s constitutional landscape. With no formal constitution, Basic Laws hold the highest legal authority, making this new law a pivotal moment in the country’s governance.
The bill was part of a broader effort by the ultra-Orthodox bloc to secure exemptions for yeshiva students from compulsory military service, a demand that has intensified amid the IDF’s severe manpower crisis. The legislation was pushed forward after weeks of threats from haredi party leaders to boycott coalition voting, aiming to pressure Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government to expedite the passage of haredi-backed measures. Netanyahu, who arrived at the Knesset plenum to cast his vote in favor, reportedly engaged in discussions with Shas party leader Arye Deri and other haredi lawmakers prior to the vote, signaling his commitment to advancing the legislation.
The bill’s passage followed three days of marathon meetings in the Knesset’s House Committee, which accelerated the legislative process. Critics argue that the law undermines the state’s obligation to maintain a strong military and risks legitimizing draft evasion. Coalition lawmakers, including two from Netanyahu’s Likud party—MK Dan Illouz and MK Yuli Edelstein—as well as others from the New Hope-United Right and Religious Zionist parties, openly opposed the measure. Their concerns centered around the potential implications of the law, particularly regarding the allocation of state benefits to individuals who avoid military service.
The proposed Basic Law includes provisions that equate Torah study with military service, though this wording was removed in the revised version of the bill. Despite this change, critics contend that the law still enables yeshiva students to retain state benefits, effectively shielding them from penalties for not serving. Legal groups such as the Movement for Quality Government have expressed alarm, warning that the law could be challenged in court and that Netanyahu’s support for the ultra-Orthodox parties appears to come at the expense of broader societal interests.
In response to the passing of the bill, IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir issued a stark warning, emphasizing that soldiers should be the priority of the state. He called for immediate action to address the IDF’s personnel shortages, highlighting the critical role of combatants in maintaining national security. Zamir’s comments reflect a growing concern among military officials that the legislation could exacerbate the manpower crisis, especially as the IDF prepares for increased conflict on multiple fronts.
Meanwhile, the issue of draft evasion remains a flashpoint, with some ultra-Orthodox communities facing scrutiny for their stance on military service. A notable case involves Rabbi Aryeh Yazdi, whose son, Yehuda, defended his father’s actions on a radio show, denying allegations that the rabbi receives substantial state funding. Yehuda claimed that his father, a Torah scholar, receives no financial support from the government, contradicting reports that suggested otherwise. His statements underscore the complex relationship between religious observance and state obligations in Israel.
The controversy surrounding the Basic Law has sparked intense debate, with voices ranging from IDF veterans to legal experts. One such voice is Itzik Saidyan, an IDF veteran who self-immolated in 2021 to draw attention to the plight of soldiers and their families. During a recent appearance before the Knesset House Committee, Saidyan passionately argued that the state must prioritize those who serve on the battlefield, emphasizing the sacrifices made by combatants. His testimony highlights the emotional and moral stakes involved in the legislative debate.
As the bill moves forward, it faces mounting opposition from various quarters, including the Finance Ministry, which has raised concerns about its economic impact. Reports suggest that the law could lead to a potential tax increase of up to 16%, adding to the financial pressures faced by the Israeli economy. Additionally, the IDF has warned that the implementation of the law could further strain the military’s ability to meet its operational demands, particularly as it grapples with the challenges of prolonged conflict and rising casualty rates.
Looking ahead, the fate of the Basic Law will depend on its progression through the Knesset, which requires two additional readings before it becomes law. The upcoming debates will likely involve renewed arguments from both supporters and opponents, with the possibility of legal challenges being filed by advocacy groups. As the political landscape shifts, the tension between religious freedoms and national security continues to shape the discourse around this contentious issue. The outcome of this legislative process will have lasting implications for Israel’s social fabric and its approach to military service.
13 izvještaja
The Times of IsraelNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 95Objektivnost 85prije 15 hThe Times of Israel's Daily Briefing naglašava tekuće izraelske vojne operacije protiv Hezbollaha u južnom Libanonu i ciljanje IDF-a na vođstvo Hamasa povezano s napadom 7. listopada 2023. na vojnu bazu.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Iako članak predstavlja sporno pitanje koje uključuje IDF i vjersku politiku vlade, ne pokazuje jasnu ideološku sklonost.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 95 · Objektivnost 85): Accurately conveys the IDF chief's stance on prioritizing soldiers, including direct quotes and context about the bill's impact. Maintains a neutral tone throughout.
The Jerusalem PostNeovisanDesnoČinjenice 95Objektivnost 85prije 4 danaThe Knesset passed the Basic Law: Torah Study bill in its first reading, backed by ultra-Orthodox (haredi) parties and supported by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The bill seeks to enshrine Torah study as a fundamental value in Israeli society, granting yeshiva students continued state benefits regardless of military service, which critics argue could encourage draft evasion during the IDF's manpower crisis. The measure passed with 63 votes in favor and 53 against, following weeks of haredi-led efforts to pressure Netanyahu's coalition to expedite legislation. The bill will undergo further debates and require additional approvals before becoming law. Coalition members, including Likud and Religious Zionist lawmakers, openly opposed the measure, citing concerns over national security and resource allocation.
Procjena pristranosti (Desno): The article frames the bill as a significant legislative achievement backed by Netanyahu and haredi leaders, emphasizing its alignment with traditional Jewish values and the support from key political figures. While it presents opposition from coalition members, the narrative leans toward validating
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 95 · Objektivnost 85): Accurately reports the Knesset passing the Torah study bill, including key details like the vote count, supporters, and context around the haredi parties' push. Maintains neutrality in presenting facts.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 90Objektivnost 85prije 5 h Veteran IDF-a koji se zapalio moli Knesset: Prioritet borbenim vojnicima, a ne proučavanju ToreVeteran IDF-a Itzik Saidyan, koji je sebe zapalio 2021. godine kako bi privukao pozornost na borbe ranjenih vojnika, obratio se odboru Knesseta koji se zalaže za davanje prioriteta borbenim vojnicima nad proučavanjem Tore kao temeljnom državnom vrijednošću. Njegove primjedbe su se poklopile s raspravom o predloženom Osnovnom zakonu koji bi oslobodio ultraortodoksne muškarce od obvezne vojne službe, potezu kojem se suprotstavljaju pravni stručnjaci i smatra se da pogoršava tekuću krizu radne snage u Izraelu.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak predstavlja obje perspektive: Sajdjanov poziv da se prioritet daju borbenim vojnicima i kontroverze oko predloženog Osnovnog zakona koji štiti ultraortodoksne izbjegavače.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 90 · Objektivnost 85): Reports on the IDF chief's criticism of the Torah study bill, providing context about the manpower crisis and political tensions. Balanced and factual with minimal bias.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 90Objektivnost 80prije 3 dana IDF chief says soldiers must be priority after Basic Law on Torah study advancesIDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir emphasized that soldiers should be prioritized in state policies following the Knesset's approval of a controversial Basic Law designating Torah study as a foundational Israeli value. This law has sparked significant debate, with critics claiming it aims to exempt ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students from military service by legally enshrining Torah study as a national value. The law comes amid ongoing tensions between the government and the Haredi community, which has staged mass protests against the arrest of draft dodgers. Meanwhile, the IDF faces severe personnel shortages due to reduced mandatory service periods and increased combat demands. Senior military officials have called for legislative action to address these challenges, including extending mandatory service and reforming reserve duty laws.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents both perspectives on the controversy surrounding the Basic Law and highlights the concerns raised by the IDF regarding personnel shortages. It does not exhibit overtly biased language or one-sided sourcing, providing a balanced overview of the situation.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 90 · Objektivnost 80): Reports on the Knesset's move to freeze arrests of draft evaders, including key figures and motivations. Provides context but includes some subjective analysis of the political implications.
The Jerusalem PostNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 90Objektivnost 75prije 6 dana Ultra-ortodoksna stranka paralizira glasove u Knessetu kako bi provela iznimke iz vojnog nacrtaUltra-ortodoksna stranka United Torah Judaism (UTJ) najavila je da će bojkotirati glasanje koalicije u Knesetu, ometajući zakonodavni dnevni red. Ovaj potez dolazi nakon što je UTJ optužio vladinu koaliciju da nije dovoljno brzo unaprijedila obećano zakonodavstvo.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): U članku se prikazuju i akcije ultraortodoksne stranke i odgovor vlade, bez da se otvoreno favorizira nijedna strana.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 90 · Objektivnost 75): Includes a direct quote from an IDF veteran expressing strong opinions about prioritizing combat soldiers over Torah study. While factual, the emotional tone affects objectivity.
The Jerusalem PostNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 90Objektivnost 75prije 7 dana Ministarstvo obrane podržava zamrzavanje 90 uhićenja haredija dok se Izrael suočava s krizom koalicijeMinistar obrane Izrael Katz predložio je 90-dnevno zamrzavanje uhićenja haredija (ultra-ortodoksnih) izbjegavača nacrta usred političke krize u kojoj je Knesset unaprijeđivao zakonodavstvo za utvrđivanje proučavanja Tore u Osnovnom zakonu. Ovaj potez slijedi nakon pritiska haredijskih stranaka, uključujući Shas i Ujedinjeni judaizam Tore, koji su prijetili bojkotom koalicijskih glasova ukoliko se ne ispune njihovi zahtjevi. Katz je zatražio hitni sastanak s predsjednikom Odbora za vanjske poslove i obranu Knesseta Boazom Bismuthom kako bi raspravljali o prijedlogu, koji je kasnije opisao Bismuth. Prijedlog bi spriječio uhićenja, istrage ili provedbene radnje povezane s izbjegavanjem nacrta tijekom 90-dnevnog razdoblja. Zakonodavstvo o utvrđivanju proučavanja Tore u Osnovnom zakonu dio je većeg napora haredijskih skupina da osiguraju pravnu zaštitu za svoje vjerske prakse, posebno u vezi s iznimcima za vojnu službu.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak predstavlja prijedlog ministra obrane i zahtjeve haredijskih stranaka bez da otvoreno favorizira jednu stranu. Uključuje citate više zainteresiranih strana i neutralno opisuje pravni i politički kontekst, izbjegavajući opterećeni jezik ili jednostran naglasak.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 90 · Objektivnost 75): Factuality is high as it provides detailed information about the defense ministry's position and related political context. Objectivity is lower due to some emotionally charged language regarding the impact of arrests on enlistment efforts.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanDesnoČinjenice 85Objektivnost 80prije 4 dana Contentious Basic Law on Torah study, aimed at shielding draft evaders, passes 1st readingThe Knesset passed the first reading of a controversial Basic Law that declares Torah study a foundational value of the State of Israel, aiming to protect draft evading ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students from legal repercussions. Sponsored by ultra-Orthodox lawmakers Moshe Gafni and Yaakov Asher, and supported by the Shas party, the bill seeks to exempt religious students from military service obligations. This follows a stalled coalition-backed enlistment bill and reflects ongoing tensions between ultra-Orthodox parties and the governing coalition led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The legislation faces significant criticism, including from within the coalition, for potentially undermining court decisions mandating the conscription of ultra-Orthodox youth. The bill will undergo further review before final approval.
Procjena pristranosti (Desno): The article frames the legislation as a response to perceived threats to religious freedoms and highlights opposition from secular and centrist factions within the coalition. It emphasizes the ultra-Orthodox parties' stance while downplaying concerns about potential legal loopholes and the erosionof
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 85 · Objektivnost 80): Summarizes the political situation and legislative agenda, providing context about the Torah study bill and related bills. Neutral in tone but leans slightly towards highlighting controversy.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 85Objektivnost 80prije 6 dana Daily Briefing 29. lipnja: Može li itko izgraditi koaliciju bez Haredi i arapskih stranaka?The Times of Israel's Daily Briefing raspravlja o predstojećem dnevnom redu izraelskog Knesseta, usredotočenom na kontroverzni predloženi Osnovni zakon koji bi učvrstio proučavanje Tore kao temeljnu vrijednost države, podržanu od strane ultraortodoksnih stranaka s ciljem izuzimanja studenata ješive iz vojne službe.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak pruža uravnotežen pregled višestrukog političkog razvoja u Izraelu, uključujući zakonodavne prijedloge i potencijalne saveze, bez da otvoreno favorizira bilo koju stranu.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 85 · Objektivnost 80): Describes the haredi parties' strategy to delay legislation and pressures on Netanyahu. Presents information objectively but includes some subjective commentary on the impact of the boycott.
The Jerusalem PostNeovisanDesnoČinjenice 85Objektivnost 70prije 4 dana Sin rabina koji je verbalno napao IDF šefa kaže da otac ne prima nikakva državna sredstvaSin rabina Aryeh Yazdija, koji je verbalno napao načelnika stožera IDF-a general-poručnika Eyala Zamira, branio je postupke svog oca tijekom intervjua na 103FM-u. Yehuda Yazdi tvrdio je da njegov otac ne prima državno financiranje, opovrgavajući izvještaje da je godišnje proračuniran na stotine tisuća šekela. Rabin je prokleo Zamira i pozvao na brisanje njegovog imena, opisujući surovo postupanje s vojnicima u vojsci. Yehuda je naglasio posvećenost svog oca proučavanju Tore i kritizirao postupanje s vjerskim ličnostima, pozivajući se na teoriju novinara o različitim izraelskim identitetima. Također je odbacio tvrdnje o financijskoj podršci svog oca, navodeći da više ne prima mjesečnu naknadu jer je registriran kao kol avlelrech.
Procjena pristranosti (Desno): U članku se uvodi verbalni napad rabina na šefa IDF-a kao opravdan odgovor na navodno zlostavljanje vjerskih pojedinaca, naglašavajući vjersku perspektivu i kritizirajući vojno postupanje u vjerskim pitanjima.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 85 · Objektivnost 70): The article provides details about Rabbi Yazdi's verbal attack on IDF chief and his son's claim regarding state funding. While it includes direct quotes and context, it lacks verification of the funding claim and presents the incident with some emotional framing.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanDesnoČinjenice 85Objektivnost 70prije 5 dana Knesset advances Basic Law on Torah study, pushes to freeze arrests of draft dodgersThe Knesset House Committee advanced a proposed Basic Law declaring Torah study a foundational value of Israel, following a contentious debate. This legislation is part of an effort by Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties to secure legal protections for yeshiva students exempt from military service and to shield current draft evaders from prosecution. The bill aims to elevate the status of Torah study within Israeli law, with supporters claiming it preserves Jewish heritage and ensures recognition of religious education. Opponents, including Deputy Attorney General Avital Sompolinsky and opposition lawmakers, argue the law raises unresolved constitutional issues and represents a politically motivated attempt to bypass court decisions on mandatory military service. The legislation is set for its first plenum vote soon.
Procjena pristranosti (Desno): The article frames the legislation as a significant step toward granting special legal status to Torah study and shielding draft evaders, emphasizing support from Haredi parties and their arguments about preserving Jewish heritage. It presents criticism from opponents but does not balance the legal,
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 85 · Objektivnost 70): Factuality is good as it outlines the legislative action and its connection to the Haredi parties' agenda. Objectivity is somewhat lower due to quotes from political figures that contain strong opinions and potentially biased rhetoric.
The Jerusalem PostNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 80Objektivnost 80prije 10 h IDF soldiers to enter reserve duty immediately following mandatory service - reportThe article reports that Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are considering requiring soldiers to enter reserve duty immediately after completing their mandatory service, according to N12 News. This would effectively extend a soldier's total service time by about two months due to the implementation of the reserve draft order (Tzav 8). The move is seen as a temporary solution to address a manpower shortage, especially as Israel's mandatory military service is scheduled to be reduced to 30 months in January 2027. A senior IDF official criticized the policy as 'illogical and unreasonable' in a democratic country, while IDF officials argue that extending service would help build force capacity, address burnout, and improve operational flexibility.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): The article presents both perspectives: criticism from IDF officials who view the policy as unfair and concerns over manpower shortages. While the framing includes some negative commentary about the policy, it also includes official statements supporting the need for extended service. The reporting,
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 80 · Objektivnost 80): Reports on the IDF's plan to extend reserve duty, citing sources and officials. Provides context about the manpower crisis and economic impact, though some details are speculative based on reporting.
The Times of IsraelNeovisanSredinaČinjenice 80Objektivnost 75prije 7 dana Knesset panel za unapređenje mjere zamrzavanja uhićenja Haredi draft evasers za 90 danaOdbor za vanjske poslove i obranu Knesseta, na čelu s Boazom Bismuthom, planira unaprijediti privremeni zakon koji bi zaustavio uhićenja haredijskih (ultra-ortodoksnih) izbjegavača nacrta za 90 dana. Ovaj potez slijedi pritisak ministra obrane Izraela Katza i tajnika kabineta Yossija Fuchsa, koji su oboje pozvali na moratorij na takva uhićenja. Odluka dolazi usred napetosti između vlade i haredijskih stranaka, koje su bojkotirale koalicijsko zakonodavstvo zbog neslaganja oko iznimaka od vojne službe za studente jeshive. Predložena mjera ima za cilj spriječiti daljnje prosvjede i poremećaje uzrokovane demonstracijama haredija protiv provođenja zakona o regrutiranju.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): Članak predstavlja situaciju objektivno, citirajući više dužnosnika i opisujući predloženo zakonodavstvo bez da otvoreno favorizira bilo koju stranu.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 80 · Objektivnost 75): Presents Deputy FM Haskel's criticism of the daycare law with strong emotive language. While factually correct, the tone suggests a partisan viewpoint, affecting objectivity.
HaaretzNeovisan🔒SredinaČinjenice 75Objektivnost 80prije 7 danaČlanak izvještava da je izraelski ministar obrane zatražio od Kneseta da zaustavi uhićenje haredija (ultra-ortodoksnih) muškaraca koji izbjegavaju vojnu službu.
Procjena pristranosti (Sredina): U članku je predstavljen zahtjev ministra obrane bez otvorene podrške ili kritike akcije.
Zašto ove ocjene (Činjenice 75 · Objektivnost 80): Factuality is moderate as it reports a claim from the Israeli Defense Minister without additional context or verification. Objectivity is high as it presents the statement neutrally without evident bias.
★
Neka vijesti ostanu poštene.
ObjectiveNews financiraju čitatelji i bez oglasa je – pristranost vam pokazujemo, ne skrivamo. Podržite neovisno novinarstvo za 5 €/mjesec.
Postani podupiratelj
IL
