The harsh messages of Eduardo Feinmann, Jonatan Viale and Luis Majul against Florencia Peña
Florencia Peña, an Argentine actress and television host, faced significant backlash after falsely reporting on the health of Jorge Messi, father of football star Lionel Messi, during her program 'El Show del Verano' on Luzu TV. The false information quickly spread on social media and generated widespread criticism. Eduardo Feinmann, a prominent journalist, strongly criticized Peña, calling her 'an absolute irresponsible' and questioning her accountability for spreading misinformation. He highlighted the gravity of the situation, emphasizing the need for responsibility when discussing matters involving high-profile individuals like the Messi family. Other journalists, including Jonatan Viale, also condemned Peña's actions, stressing that as a show host, she remains ultimately responsible for the content aired, regardless of production involvement.
The actress Florencia Peña was removed from her position on Luzu TV after she broadcasted false information regarding the death of Jorge Messi, father of football star Lionel Messi. The incident occurred during the live airing of her program, El show del verano, where she announced the tragic news without prior verification. This led to immediate backlash from both the public and media figures, prompting the network's founder, Nicolás Occhiato, to issue a formal statement expressing his outrage over the situation.
According to reports, the misinformation spread quickly across social media platforms, causing widespread concern among fans and followers of the Messi family. In response, the Messi family issued their own statement, clarifying that Jorge Messi was indeed recovering from a health issue but was not deceased. They expressed deep disappointment with the irresponsible dissemination of such sensitive information and emphasized that only the closest members of the family could provide accurate updates about his condition.
Following the controversy, Florencia Peña took to her social media accounts to apologize publicly for the distress caused to the Messi family. She admitted that the false news had been relayed to her by the production team under the assumption that it had been verified. Despite this explanation, Peña acknowledged her role in the mistake and decided to step down from her position at Luzu TV. Her decision came amid significant criticism from fellow journalists and commentators who questioned her professionalism in handling such a delicate topic.
Nicolás Occhiato, the founder of Luzu TV, confirmed that all individuals involved in the incident would face disciplinary action, including Peña’s departure from the network. He reiterated the importance of responsible communication and expressed regret over the incident, highlighting the need for rigorous checks before broadcasting any sensitive information. The incident has sparked discussions within the media industry about the responsibilities of content creators when dealing with potentially life-altering news.
The fallout from the incident extended beyond just the removal of Peña from Luzu TV. Various media personalities and journalists criticized the lack of accountability shown by Peña and the production team. Some argued that the incident highlighted the dangers of conflating entertainment with journalism, especially when dealing with high-profile figures like Lionel Messi. Others pointed out that Peña herself had previously spoken out against irresponsible reporting practices, making her actions even more controversial.
In addition to facing professional repercussions, Peña also canceled her planned trip to the World Cup, which had been scheduled shortly after the incident. This move underscored the personal impact of the scandal on her career and public image. As the dust settles around this incident, it remains to be seen how the media landscape will evolve in terms of handling sensitive topics with greater care and responsibility moving forward.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.
Actress Florencia Peña was fired by Luzu TV after broadcasting a false report about the death of Lionel Messi's father, Jorge Messi. The misinformation occurred during a wave of rumors about Jorge Messi's health. Shortly after, the Messi family issued a statement denying the claim and confirming that Jorge Messi is recovering from a serious health issue. Luzu TV expressed regret over the incident and stated that they had decided to terminate the employment of all those involved.
Bias read (Center): The article reports on an event involving a celebrity and a health-related misinformation incident without taking a stance on any political matter. It provides factual information about the situation, including the actions taken by the involved parties and the response from the Messi family. There's
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 85): The article provides detailed information about Florencia Peña being fired from Luzu TV after spreading false news about Jorge Messi’s death, including quotes from Occhiato and the Messi family’s response. It aligns closely with the cross-source consensus, though some details like the exact wording
La NaciónIndependent🔒CenterFactual 95Objective 8020 days ago
Florencia Peña, host of the program 'El show del verano' on Luzu TV, broadcast a false report about the health of Lionel Messi's father, which caused public outrage. After it was revealed to be misinformation, Nicolás Occhiato, founder and producer of the channel, expressed his anger and announced that all responsible parties would be removed from their positions, including Peña stepping down.
Bias read (Center): The article reports on a factual event involving the spread of false information without taking a stance on the matter. It presents statements from both Peña and Occhiato without editorializing or biased language.
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 80): The article provides a thorough account of the event, including direct quotes from Peña and Occhiato. While it presents both sides of the story, it leans slightly toward the narrative of responsibility falling on the production team, affecting its neutrality.
PerfilIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 8020 days ago
The recent spread of a false news report by Florencia Peña during a television program about the health status of Jorge Messi, father of Lionel Messi, sparked widespread criticism from figures in journalism and communication. The incident has led to condemnation of both Peña and the production team of the streaming channel for handling sensitive information unprofessionally.
Bias read (Center): The article reports on a widely criticized instance of misinformation without taking a stance on the issue itself. It presents reactions from various journalists and public figures without favoring any side, maintaining a balanced tone.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 80): The article accurately reports the incident and includes reactions from various media figures. However, it uses emotionally charged language such as 'barbaridad' and 'papelón,' which slightly reduces its objectivity despite presenting multiple perspectives.
PerfilIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 6019 days ago
Florencia Peña, an Argentine actress and television host, faced significant backlash after falsely reporting on the health of Jorge Messi, father of football star Lionel Messi, during her program 'El Show del Verano' on Luzu TV. The false information quickly spread on social media and generated widespread criticism. Eduardo Feinmann, a prominent journalist, strongly criticized Peña, calling her 'an absolute irresponsible' and questioning her accountability for spreading misinformation. He highlighted the gravity of the situation, emphasizing the need for responsibility when discussing matters involving high-profile individuals like the Messi family. Other journalists, including Jonatan Viale, also condemned Peña's actions, stressing that as a show host, she remains ultimately responsible for the content aired, regardless of production involvement.
Bias read (Center): The article presents multiple perspectives from journalists criticizing Florencia Peña for spreading false information about Jorge Messi. While some critics, such as Eduardo Feinmann, use strong language and personal attacks, others like Jonatan Viale focus on professional accountability. The piece,
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 60): The article accurately reports the controversy but includes highly critical and personal remarks from Feinmann, which significantly reduce its objectivity. The tone is biased and includes subjective judgments about Peña’s past work.
ClarínIndependentProgressiveFactual 70Objective 6520 days ago
The article reports that Florencia Peña, who previously spread false information about the death of Jorge Messi, has canceled her trip to the World Cup. The piece highlights the consequences of disseminating misinformation, particularly regarding a public figure. It suggests a direct link between the false news and the decision to withdraw from the event. No specific details about the nature of the false news or further implications are provided beyond this connection.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the dissemination of false information as a significant ethical breach, implying a critical stance toward those who spread misinformation. While not explicitly political, the emphasis on accountability and the potential impact on public perception aligns with a left-leaning focus,
Why these scores (Factual 70 · Objective 65): This article contains minimal factual content beyond the headline, making it less reliable. The claim about Peña canceling her trip to the World Cup lacks supporting evidence from other sources, reducing its factual accuracy and objectivity.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
AR
