West Bengal's legislative assembly recently passed two significant amendment bills aimed at revising the state's policies regarding Other Backward Classes (OBC) reservations. These changes align with directives issued by the Calcutta High Court in May 2024, which mandated the removal of certain Muslim communities from the OBC list and a reduction in the overall reservation percentage for OBCs. The amendments mark a pivotal shift in how OBC status is determined and allocated within the state.
The newly enacted legislation reduces the OBC reservation quota from 17% to 7%, effectively altering the landscape of affirmative action in West Bengal. This decision follows a judicial review initiated by the Calcutta High Court, which found that some communities had been incorrectly listed as OBCs without proper evaluation. As part of this process, 77 Muslim communities previously included in the OBC list have been excluded. The remaining OBC communities, totaling 66, have been identified through comprehensive surveys conducted by the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes.
The passage of these bills was supported by a majority of legislators, with 186 members voting in favor and 17 opposing the measure. Six members chose to abstain from voting. Notably, a faction of the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC), led by Ritabrata Banerjee, staged a walkout during the proceedings, indicating internal dissent within the party regarding the amendments.
Backward Classes Development Minister Gourishankar Ghosh emphasized that the changes were necessary to rectify past practices where communities were added to the OBC list without adequate assessment. He highlighted that the new framework ensures that only those communities verified through thorough surveys retain their OBC status. Additionally, the minister pointed out that the previous administration had bypassed the commission responsible for evaluating OBC eligibility, leading to potential misuse of the system. Under the new laws, efforts will be made to prevent the issuance of fraudulent OBC certificates, a practice reportedly prevalent during the prior regime.
The revised OBC list includes specific Muslim communities such as Jolah, Fakir, Pahadia Muslim, Hajjam, and Chowduli. These communities have been retained following evaluations that confirmed their socio-economic conditions warrant inclusion in the OBC category. In contrast, numerous other Muslim communities, including Muslim Nehariya, Muslim Haldar, Muslim Sanpui, Muslim Mali, Ghosi (Muslim), Muslim Darji/Ostagar/Idrisi, Muslim Rajmistri, Muslim Batiyara, Muslim Molla, and Dhali (Muslim), among others, have been excluded from the list.
The background of these changes traces back to a series of petitions filed between 2010 and 2020 by individuals and organizations, including Atmadeep, a human rights group. These petitions challenged the arbitrary allocation of OBC status to various communities without assessing their actual socio-economic standing. The Calcutta High Court's May 2024 order addressed these concerns, prompting the current government to implement the necessary amendments. Prior to this, the Left Front government, led by Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, had established a 10% reservation for "economically, socially and educationally backward" or "most backward" Muslims under the OBC-A category, while "backward" Muslims received a 7% reservation under the OBC-B category.
The implementation of these amendments reflects a broader effort to ensure equitable representation and access to opportunities for all sections of society, particularly focusing on verifying the authenticity of claims to OBC status. By adhering to the judicial guidelines and conducting rigorous assessments, the West Bengal government aims to create a fairer system that benefits genuinely disadvantaged communities without compromising the integrity of the reservation policy.
3 reports
Hindustan TimesIndependentRightFactual 95Objective 904 days agoThe West Bengal legislative assembly passed two amendment bills to revise the Other Backward Classes (OBC) reservation laws, removing 77 Muslim communities from the OBC list as directed by the Calcutta High Court in May 2024. The changes, implemented by the BJP-led government under Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari, reduce the OBC reservation quota from 10% to 7%, reorganize OBC categories, and mandate new surveys to determine eligibility. The move follows a directive from the high court two years prior, which had ordered the removal of Muslim communities added without proper verification. The legislation also aims to prevent the issuance of 'fake OBC certificates,' a practice criticized during the previous Trinamool Congress government. Specific Muslim communities like the Jolah and Fakir were retained in the updated list, while others such as the Muslim Nehariya and Muslim Haldar were removed.
Bias read (Right): The article frames the removal of Muslim communities from the OBC list as a corrective measure against past mismanagement by the previous ruling party, implying systemic bias. It emphasizes the BJP government’s adherence to judicial orders and highlights the alleged misuse of OBC status by the Trinā
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 90): Accurate summary of the event with correct details about the removal of 77 Muslim communities and reduction of OBC quota. Minor omissions like specific dates and some contextual details but overall faithful to primary source.
Scroll.inIndependentRightFactual 90Objective 853 days agoThe West Bengal Assembly has passed two bills amending the Other Backward Classes (OBC) reservation laws, removing 77 Muslim communities from the OBC list as ordered by the Calcutta High Court in May 2024. The previous government's OBC list included 113 sub-groups, 77 of which were Muslim, but the High Court deemed this list invalid due to lack of proper surveys. The new legislation reduces OBC reservations to 7% from 17%, revises the classification of backward classes, and mandates future surveys conducted by the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes. The bills were supported by 186 MLAs and opposed by 17, with six members abstaining. Opposition leaders, including TMC rebels, walked out during the session. The minister argued that the previous government had bypassed the commission and allowed fraudulent OBC certificate issuance.
Bias read (Right): The article frames the removal of Muslim communities from the OBC list as a corrective measure based on judicial orders, emphasizing the previous government's failure to follow proper procedures. It highlights the reduction of OBC quotas and criticizes the prior administration for bypassing the West
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 85): Accurately summarizes the event including the number of communities removed and changes to OBC quotas. Provides additional context about the previous government's challenge to the High Court ruling.
NDTVParty-alignedRightFactual 85Objective 803 days agoThe BJP government in West Bengal has removed 77 Muslim communities from the Other Backward Classes (OBC) list, which was granted during the previous Trinamool Congress administration. This move comes alongside a reduction in the OBC reservation quota from 10% to 7%. The decision is part of the BJP's broader policy changes after taking office in May. These actions aim to reshape affirmative action policies in the state, potentially affecting educational and employment opportunities for these communities. The change reflects a shift in governance priorities under the new administration.
Bias read (Right): The article frames the removal of OBC status for specific Muslim communities and the reduction of reservations as policy decisions made by the BJP government, implying approval of these changes without presenting counterarguments or alternative perspectives. The focus on reducing quotas and altering
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 80): Correctly reports the main facts about the removal of 77 Muslim communities and reduction of OBC quota. Some minor inaccuracies in percentages and lacks specific details present in the primary source.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
India
