ON
← Back to feed
Wallabies should wing it with Lomax and Pietsch ahead of the World Cup
Australia⚽ Sports

Wallabies should wing it with Lomax and Pietsch ahead of the World Cup

Rugby columnist Paul Cully argues that Australian rugby is repeating past mistakes by failing to select former NRL star Zac Lomax and his teammate Dylan Pietsch for the upcoming Rugby World Cup tour. Although Lomax was named in the Australia A squad to face the United States, Cully contends that his primary strength lies on the wing rather than in the midfield where he is currently being assessed. The author highlights Lomax's exceptional skills in the air and athletic ability, suggesting these attributes make him a stronger candidate for the main Wallabies squad than current selections such as Harry Potter and Filipo Daugunu. Additionally, Cully praises Pietsch for his defensive intensity and try-scoring record, describing his exclusion from the touring squad as baffling despite his effective performance in recent matches.

Australian rugby union fans are debating whether the national team is repeating past selection errors regarding Zac Lomax and Dylan Pietsch ahead of the upcoming Rugby World Cup. The Western Force utility back has been selected to play at number 13 for the Australia A side, which faces the United States in New Jersey at 11 am AEST on Saturday. However, analysts argue that Lomax is unlikely to secure the number 13 position for the main Wallabies squad during the tournament. This view draws parallels to previous decisions involving former NRL star Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii. Rugby columnist Paul Cully noted that while initial skepticism existed regarding the impact of National Rugby League converts on the Wallabies, Lomax impressed observers upon entering Super Rugby competition starting from Round 9 this year. His evaluation focused primarily on Lomax’s performance as a winger, highlighting his exceptional skills in catching high balls. Although Lomax demonstrated strong work rates, athletic ability, and a capacity to learn, his aerial prowess was identified as the primary factor marking him as a potential Test player on the wing. The current selection for Australia A appears driven by immediate tactical necessities. David Feliuai received a red card last week, creating a void in the midfield that requires filling. Consequently, Lomax has been placed at number 13 for the match against the United States. Critics suggest that Lomax should not be traveling to the United States at all. Instead, arguments favor including Lomax and his Western Force teammate Dylan Pietsch in the Wallabies touring squad for the Nations Championship northern series. These two players formed the strongest Australian wing partnership in Super Rugby during the previous season. Proponents of this pairing believe they will remain the top Australian combination in Super Rugby next year, provided the Western Force resists the urge to deploy Lomax at number 13. Their exclusion from the current tour is viewed as a missed opportunity, particularly given that Harry Potter and Filipo Daugunu were chosen over them. There is speculation that Lomax’s decision to sign with the PNG Chiefs for contracts beginning in 2028 may have influenced perceptions. However, supporters counter that this move resolves long-term uncertainty early, preventing distracting rumors from consuming media attention. Observers describe Lomax as a task-focused athlete capable of ignoring external noise, suggesting that setting the Rugby World Cup as a clear target allows him to perform effectively. Dylan Pietsch, who scored two tries for Australia A last weekend, offers distinct defensive advantages. Analysts point out that the soft edge defense observed against the All Blacks during the Bledisloe Series would likely not occur under Pietsch’s supervision. He is described as tackling with the intensity of a loose forward, raising questions about why he is absent from coach Les Kiss’s squad. Injuries and a lack of recent competitive rugby appear to have contributed to the omission of both Lomax and Pietsch, yet many consider them obvious selections. The Wallabies touring party currently consists of 35 players. Recent additions include James Ramm and Kalani Thomas, while Kurtley Beale was named to replace Hunter Paisami. This total is one less than the 36 players the All Blacks are bringing. The squad size will decrease to 34 when Tate McDermott returns to Australia for family reasons. Beale’s late inclusion surprised some, though it aligns with recent comments by Kiss praising the veteran. Beale’s form in Super Rugby and Super Rugby AUS has been strong. At 37 years old, his physical endurance for full 80-minute Test matches is questioned. Nevertheless, he could serve as a more logical starter at number 12 than placing Suaalii at number 13. Such a setup would allow Len Ikitau to occupy the number 13 role, leveraging Suaalii’s greater impact as a winger. Additionally, Beale at number 12 could provide mentorship to the developing group of fly-halves without threatening their positions. Despite these considerations, the debate centers on the urgent need to integrate Lomax and Pietsch into the broader picture. Their specific skill sets, particularly Lomax’s aerial ability and Pietsch’s defensive reliability, are seen as assets too valuable to overlook. The window for their inclusion remains open, with the current squad composition allowing for further adjustments before the World Cup commences. The contrast between the current Australia A lineup and the projected Wallabies squad highlights the tension between immediate match requirements and long-term strategic planning for the national team.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentCenter
Wallabies should wing it with Lomax and Pietsch ahead of the World Cup

Rugby columnist Paul Cully argues that the Australian national team management is repeating past mistakes by failing to select former NRL star Zac Lomax and his teammate Dylan Pietsch for upcoming international tours. Although Lomax was selected for the Australia A match against the United States, Cully contends that his primary strength lies on the wing rather than in the midfield, where he is currently being utilized. The author asserts that Lomax and Pietsch form the superior Australian wing combination in Super Rugby and should have been included in the main Wallabies touring squad for the Nations Championship. Cully criticizes the selection of other players over Lomax and Pietsch, describing their exclusion as a wasted opportunity despite potential factors such as injury history or recent playing time.

Bias read (Center): The article is a sports opinion piece focused on player selection and tactical positioning within a specific club and national team context, containing no political arguments or policy implications.

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentCenter
Wallabies should wing it with Lomax and Pietsch ahead of the World Cup

Rugby columnist Paul Cully argues that Australian rugby is repeating past mistakes by failing to select former NRL star Zac Lomax and his teammate Dylan Pietsch for the upcoming Rugby World Cup tour. Although Lomax was named in the Australia A squad to face the United States, Cully contends that his primary strength lies on the wing rather than in the midfield where he is currently being assessed. The author highlights Lomax's exceptional skills in the air and athletic ability, suggesting these attributes make him a stronger candidate for the main Wallabies squad than current selections such as Harry Potter and Filipo Daugunu. Additionally, Cully praises Pietsch for his defensive intensity and try-scoring record, describing his exclusion from the touring squad as baffling despite his effective performance in recent matches.

Bias read (Center): The article is a sports opinion piece focused on player selection and tactical positioning, containing no political content or ideological framing.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories