ON
← Back to feed
VIDEO / They bought a 120-year-old house and smelled a strange smell: When they lifted the carpet, there was a shock
Croatia🩺 HealthCenter8/31/2026

VIDEO / They bought a 120-year-old house and smelled a strange smell: When they lifted the carpet, there was a shock

Aidan and Catherine McGowan purchased a 120-year-old farmhouse in South Dakota and encountered an unexpected discovery during renovations. While removing an old carpet in the living room, they uncovered large brown and yellow stains beneath it and under the floorboards. The stains were so severe that they joked the previous owners might have had a dog. Further investigation revealed similar marks under other carpets in the house, though the living room was the worst affected. The couple now faces extensive repairs, including removing existing flooring, replacing lower wall sections with drywall, and installing new wooden floors. Their experience went viral online, with many commenting on the unpleasantness of old carpets hiding dirt and advising protective measures during renovations.

Aidan and Catherine McGowan, a 30-year-old couple from South Dakota, purchased a 120-year-old farmhouse on a ten-hectare property and quickly discovered they had bought more than just a home, they had acquired a mystery. The couple, who had anticipated the challenges of restoring an old house, were unprepared for the unsettling discovery that awaited them during their renovation efforts. What began as a simple task, removing an old carpet, soon turned into a shocking revelation that would alter their entire renovation plan. The McGowans bought the historic home in 2023, knowing it had been vacant for nearly a year before their purchase. They were aware that renovations would require considerable work, but nothing could have prepared them for the bizarre smell emanating from the living room. As they set out to remove the worn-out carpet, they recorded the process on video, which would later go viral. Their initial question, "Why does this place smell so weird?", was soon answered in a way neither of them could have imagined. As Aidan began lifting the carpet, dark brown and yellow stains appeared on both the underside of the rug and the floor beneath it. With each layer removed, it became clear that the entire floor was covered in traces of something far worse than dirt. “We started thinking maybe they had a dog,” they joked in the video description. But the reality was far more alarming. The stains suggested long-term contamination, possibly related to biological waste or even something more sinister. Catherine later told Newsweek that similar stains were found under other carpets throughout the house, though the condition in the living room was far worse. “When we lifted the carpet, we were completely horrified. And while there were traces in other rooms, the living room was truly catastrophic,” she said. The discovery forced the couple to rethink their approach entirely. What had initially seemed like a straightforward project now required extensive demolition and reconstruction. The McGowans now face a daunting task ahead. They must remove the existing flooring, replace sections of the walls with gypsum board up to approximately 90 centimeters high, and finally install new wooden floors. This level of intervention has significantly increased the scope of their renovation, turning what was once a manageable project into a major undertaking. Despite the setbacks, the couple remains committed to completing the restoration. Their video, shared on social media, sparked widespread reaction. Many users expressed disgust over the state of the home, with one commenting, “I hate carpets. They can hide incredible amounts of filth.” Others warned the couple to wear protective gear during the cleanup, while many shared their own experiences of discovering hidden messes during home renovations. One user recounted how he had sensed a foul odor in his basement for years until removing the carpet revealed identical stains. After thorough cleaning and installing new flooring, the issue disappeared entirely. Despite the challenges, the McGowans show no signs of giving up on their dream of living in a 120-year-old farmhouse. In fact, they’ve decided to take on much of the work themselves, despite lacking prior experience in home restoration. “We don’t have any experience with home renovation, so we’re learning everything along the way,” Catherine admitted. They regularly share updates on their progress, revealing how many layers of wall coverings they’ve had to strip back and what further surprises might still lie hidden beneath the floors and walls. Beyond the farmhouse, the couple also plans to restore an old barn on the property, transforming it into a space for raising livestock. They hope to eventually keep chickens, pigs, and perhaps even their own cow, bringing their rural dream closer to reality. While the journey has been anything but easy, the McGowans remain determined to see their vision through.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

Go to the primary sources (1)

The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.

2 reports

Večernji list logoVečernji listIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 978/31/2026
They bought a 120-year-old house, and then they smelled a strange smell: When they lifted the carpet, there was a shock

Aidan i Catherine McGowan, tridesetogodišnjaka, kupili su seosku kuću izgrađenu 1906. godine u Južnoj Dakoti. Tijekom renovacije, prilikom uklanjanja starih tepiha, otkrili su ogroman broj mrlja i tragova na podu, što ih je zgrožilo i promijenilo planove za obnovu. Mrlje pronašli su i ispod drugih tepiha, a stanje u dnevnom boravku bilo je najgori. Otkrića su izazvala šok i zabrinutost, ali par nije planira odustati od projekta. Njihov video postao je viralan, uz pozive korisnika društvenih mreža da nosi zaštitne maske i rukavice, kao i djelovanje kao izvor inspiracije za druge koji renoviraju stare kuće.

Bias read (Center): The article focuses on a personal renovation experience and does not engage with political discourse, ideological positions, or governmental policies. While the situation involves significant health and safety concerns, the narrative remains centered on individual experiences rather than partisan or

Why factuality (95): The article closely follows the primary source document from Večernji list, accurately reporting the events, quotes, and details about Aidan and Catherine's discovery of stains under the carpet. It includes specific information such as the year the house was built (1906), the location (South Dakota)

Why objectivity (97): The article maintains a neutral and objective tone throughout, presenting the story without bias or emotional language. It reports the couple’s experience, reactions, and plans objectively, using direct quotes from Catherine and describing the situation in a matter-of-fact manner. There is no indica

N1 Hrvatska logoN1 HrvatskaIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 958/31/2026
VIDEO / They bought a 120-year-old house and smelled a strange smell: When they lifted the carpet, there was a shock

Aidan and Catherine McGowan purchased a 120-year-old farmhouse in South Dakota and encountered an unexpected discovery during renovations. While removing an old carpet in the living room, they uncovered large brown and yellow stains beneath it and under the floorboards. The stains were so severe that they joked the previous owners might have had a dog. Further investigation revealed similar marks under other carpets in the house, though the living room was the worst affected. The couple now faces extensive repairs, including removing existing flooring, replacing lower wall sections with drywall, and installing new wooden floors. Their experience went viral online, with many commenting on the unpleasantness of old carpets hiding dirt and advising protective measures during renovations.

Bias read (Center): The article discusses a renovation project involving health concerns related to mold or filth under carpets but does not involve political figures, policies, or contentious issues. It focuses on personal experience and general advice, making it apolitical.

Why factuality (90): This article accurately summarizes the main points from the original Večernji list piece, including the couple's discovery of the stained carpet, the impact on their renovation plans, and Catherine's quote from Newsweek. However, it omits some contextual details like the couple's decision to renovat

Why objectivity (95): The article remains largely objective, presenting the facts without overt bias. It uses neutral language and avoids taking sides or expressing personal opinions. However, the inclusion of an advertisement could be seen as a slight disruption to the neutrality of the piece, though it doesn't directly

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories