Michel Barnier, the former chief Brexit negotiator for the European Union, has suggested that the United Kingdom could potentially rejoin the EU on "special" terms—similar to those it enjoyed prior to Brexit—if it chose to do so. Speaking ahead of the 10th anniversary of the Brexit referendum on June 23, Barnier emphasized that the UK could retain the pound and remain outside the Schengen passport-free travel zone, challenging previous claims that such conditions might be impossible under EU rules. His remarks, delivered during an interview with The Guardian before a conference commemorating the Brexit vote, have sparked renewed interest among pro-reintegration advocates and raised questions about the future trajectory of UK-EU relations.
Barnier outlined that while all EU member states are generally expected to adopt the euro, exceptions exist, notably Denmark’s permanent opt-out. Furthermore, although new members are typically required to join the Schengen Area upon accession, Ireland holds the sole official opt-out. Barnier pointed out that five of the 13 countries that joined the EU since 2004 have not adopted the euro, indicating that opting out of both the single currency and Schengen is legally feasible. This stance directly contradicts recent warnings from Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski, who cautioned against expecting the UK to receive similar "à la carte" membership privileges as before.
The former French prime minister, who served as the EU’s lead Brexit negotiator from 2017 to 2020, reiterated his belief that the UK made a significant error in leaving the EU. He cited ongoing economic stagnation and the persistent challenges surrounding immigration as evidence of the negative consequences of Brexit. While he acknowledged that the UK’s current difficulties could not be solely attributed to Brexit, he stressed that the process had exacerbated existing issues. Barnier also expressed skepticism regarding the feasibility of closer economic ties without the free movement of people, dismissing Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s ambitions in this regard.
Barnier’s comments come at a pivotal moment for UK-EU relations, as the two sides prepare for a new round of "reset" talks scheduled for July 22. These discussions aim to improve trade, security, and economic cooperation, though progress has been slow due to mutual distrust and differing priorities. Meanwhile, internal British politics remains volatile, with the upcoming by-election in Makerfield potentially reshaping the leadership race within the Labour Party. Andy Burnham, a rival to Starmer, has shown mixed signals on rejoining the EU, suggesting that the UK could be trapped in a "permanent rut" if it continues to focus on divisive debates rather than constructive engagement.
In addition to reiterating the possibility of a swift reentry, Barnier proposed the creation of a European Council for Security and Defence, which would include non-EU countries like the UK and Norway. This idea reflects a broader vision of enhanced collaboration on security matters, particularly in light of growing geopolitical tensions and the need for collective resilience against external pressures. Such a structure would allow the UK to participate in strategic initiatives without full membership, aligning with its historical role as a close ally of the EU.
Despite these optimistic projections, Barnier admitted that the UK government would likely require considerable time to consider rejoining. He emphasized that while the institutional framework exists to facilitate a rapid reentry, the political will to pursue such a course remains uncertain. Nevertheless, his remarks have bolstered the case for reintegration, especially among those who argue that the UK’s isolationist approach has weakened its global standing and economic prospects.
As the UK grapples with the long-term implications of Brexit, Barnier’s insights offer both hope and caution. They underscore the complexity of EU membership and the potential for negotiated arrangements, but also highlight the enduring challenges of rebuilding trust and fostering unity. Whether the UK will ultimately choose to rejoin remains unclear, but the conversation is now more open than ever.
5 reports
The Guardian (World)IndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 7018 days agoMichel Barnier reflects on his personal interactions with Boris Johnson's father, Stanley Johnson, during a weekend spent at a French castle. He discusses Johnson's early views on Brexit, noting that while Johnson was initially more European in outlook, his approach was seen as pragmatic and even cynical in pursuit of power. Barnier also comments on the ongoing negotiations related to Brexit and the future of the EU.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Michel Barnier's reflections on Boris Johnson and Brexit without overtly favoring any particular political stance. It includes direct quotes from Barnier and provides context about their relationship and discussions regarding Brexit. There is no evident bias toward either the UK
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 70): Highly factual with detailed background on Barnier and Brexit negotiations. The tone includes subjective commentary like 'cynical to get power,' which affects objectivity.
The Guardian (World)IndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 7018 days ago UK could keep special pre-Brexit terms if it rejoined EU, Michel Barnier saysMichel Barnier, the EU's former chief Brexit negotiator, stated that the UK could potentially retain certain pre-Brexit arrangements, such as keeping the pound and avoiding the Schengen passport-free zone, if it were to rejoin the EU. He suggested that the UK might be able to maintain these exemptions based on existing precedents. His remarks challenge claims by some officials, like Poland's foreign minister, that the UK would face stricter conditions upon re-entry. Barnier emphasized that the UK's return to the EU would depend on meeting specific criteria outlined in EU treaties.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Michel Barnier's statements without overtly favoring either pro-EU or anti-EU perspectives. It reports his views objectively, noting both his position and counterarguments from other officials, while providing context on EU treaty obligations. There is no clear editorializing or
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 70): Accurate in reporting Barnier's statements on special terms and opt-outs. However, the tone leans slightly toward supporting pro-reentry views with phrases like 'boost to those who are campaigning.'
The IndependentIndependentCenterFactual 88Objective 6817 days agoMichel Barnier, the former chief Brexit negotiator, suggested that the UK could potentially rejoin the EU under similar special terms it had prior to Brexit. He noted that the UK would not need to adopt the euro or join the Schengen travel area. Barnier emphasized that while Brexit was not solely responsible for current challenges facing the UK, it has exacerbated them. He also dismissed the possibility of closer EU economic ties without accepting freedom of movement, citing concerns about political backlash in Europe. This comes amid discussions around the 10th anniversary of the Brexit vote.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Michel Barnier's statements suggesting that Brexit has worsened the UK's situation and that rejoining the EU might be feasible under special conditions. The framing emphasizes the negative consequences of Brexit and supports the idea of returning to the EU, which aligns with a '
Why these scores (Factual 88 · Objective 68): Consistent with other sources on special terms and opt-outs. Language like 'wrong choice' and 'problems more difficult because of Brexit' shows a clear pro-EU stance affecting neutrality.
The Guardian (World)IndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 7513 days ago UK could rejoin EU on ‘short’ timeline if it wanted, former Brexit negotiator says – as it happenedFormer EU Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier stated that the UK could potentially rejoin the EU on a 'short' timeline if it wished, citing existing regulatory alignment between the UK and the EU. He emphasized that while rejoining could happen quickly, the UK would not be allowed to selectively adopt aspects of the EU's single market, known as the 'four freedoms,' including free movement of labor, capital, services, and goods. Barnier also suggested the creation of a European Security and Defence Council to include non-EU countries like the UK and Norway, aiming to enhance European cooperation on security matters.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Michel Barnier's statements objectively, quoting him directly without overtly favoring any political perspective. It outlines both the potential for the UK to rejoin the EU and the conditions under which this might occur, providing balanced information without apparent bias.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 75): Factual claims align with other sources, though some details like the 'European Council for Security and Defence' are speculative. Objectivity is somewhat compromised by phrases like 'it is so important to be together' suggesting advocacy.
Daily MailIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 6517 days agoMichel Barnier, the EU's former chief Brexit negotiator, suggests the UK could rejoin the EU on 'special' terms a decade after the Brexit referendum. He mentions the possibility of the UK keeping the pound and remaining outside the Schengen Zone. Barnier notes that some EU countries have opt-outs from using the euro and being part of the Schengen Zone, though new members are generally required to join Schengen.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Michel Barnier's comments objectively without overtly favoring either the UK or the EU. It includes details about existing EU rules regarding the euro and Schengen Zone, providing context rather than taking a stance. There is no evident loaded language or one-sided sourcing.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 65): Facts match other reports but includes biased language like 'made the wrong choice' and 'cold water on Sir Keir Starmer’s hopes,' indicating a pro-EU bias.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
United Kingdom
