Two forwards, two mindsets: The contrasting philosophies driving the Hawks and Magpies

Two forwards, two mindsets: The contrasting philosophies driving the Hawks and Magpies On August 14, 2026, the Australian Football League (AFL) witnessed a pivotal moment in the careers of two standout forwards, Jack Ginnivan of Hawthorn and Lachie Schultz of Collingwood, as their contrasting styles and the philosophies of their respective clubs became increasingly apparent. The narrative surrounding these two players highlights how individual choices and team strategies can shape the trajectory of careers in professional sports. In 2023, Hawthorn expressed interest in Lachie Schultz, who was then playing for Fremantle and considering a return to Victoria. However, Schultz ultimately signed with Collingwood, driven by the club's status as premiers and its aggressive pursuit of talent. Had he joined Hawthorn instead, the course of both players' careers could have taken dramatically different paths. For instance, Jack Ginnivan, who later became a prominent figure for Hawthorn, might not have gained the attention he did on social media, nor would he have been traded from Collingwood. The decision to pursue Schultz over Ginnivan underscored the divergent priorities of the two clubs. Schultz was set to become an unrestricted free agent in 2024, prompting Collingwood to act swiftly. They met with Schultz shortly after their historic premiership, during which Ginnivan played a limited role, recording just seven touches in three quarters. This meeting marked the beginning of a new chapter for Schultz, who eventually found his place within the Collingwood structure. In contrast, Ginnivan's relationship with Collingwood came to an end due to a series of personal missteps, including his attendance at the races the night before the 2023 grand final. These actions led to his eventual departure from the club. Following the 2023 grand final, Ginnivan met with Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell and his assistant Rob McCartney at Mitchell’s residence, a rare occurrence that signaled a potential shift in his career direction. It was clear that this move would align better with Ginnivan’s public persona, which included a strong presence on social media. His time at Collingwood had seen him become a headline act, particularly after a two-match suspension related to an incident involving an illicit substance. This controversy further distanced him from the club, paving the way for his transfer to Hawthorn. Schultz, on the other hand, proved to be a perfect fit for Collingwood’s structured approach. Known for his efficiency and reliability, he adjusted well to the team’s demands. By 2026, he had established himself as the AFL’s top performer in tackles inside the forward 50-metre arc, averaging 39 tackles in 19 games. His playing style, close to goal, disciplined, and unflappable, contrasted sharply with Ginnivan’s more flamboyant and controversial approach. While Ginnivan often engaged in provocative interactions with opposing fans, Schultz remained composed, focusing on his role within the team’s broader strategy. Collingwood’s coaching staff, including long-time recruiter Derek Hine, had recognized Ginnivan’s potential to contribute upfield, beyond his role as a deep forward. Despite this, Ginnivan’s behavior in 2023, particularly his decision to attend the races, created a rift with the club. This, combined with his disciplinary issues, made it easier for Collingwood to part ways with him. Meanwhile, Hawthorn embraced Ginnivan’s flair and social media presence, integrating him into their evolving identity under coach Sam Mitchell. The contrasting philosophies of Collingwood and Hawthorn are reflected in their approaches to player development and team culture. Collingwood prioritizes adherence to a structured system, exemplified by the McRae coaching philosophy, which emphasizes discipline and consistency. In contrast, Hawthorn allows for more flexibility, creating an environment where players like Ginnivan can thrive through their individuality. This divergence has shaped the careers of Schultz and Ginnivan, each finding success in environments that align with their strengths and personalities.