For Libertarians, Election Day Is the Cruelest Day of the Year
This opinion piece reflects on the author’s longstanding frustration with major-party candidates, using a 2004 magazine cover criticizing John Kerry and George W. Bush as a starting point. The author argues that while they identify as a principled libertarian, they are willing to support major-party candidates if those individuals commit to limiting government size and spending. Focusing on the upcoming New York gubernatorial race, the article criticizes incumbent Democrat Kathy Hochul for receiving the lowest grade in the Cato Institute’s 'Freedom in the 50 States' report. It also dismisses Republican challenger Bruce Blakeman due to his lack of competitive polling numbers and limited political experience. Because legislative changes have restricted third-party ballot access, the author plans to write in 'none of the above' as a protest vote rather than choosing between the two major-party options.
Times Square’s “Naked Cowboy” Robert Burck has formally endorsed Republican Bruce Blakeman for New York governor, declaring it “time for a leader who sticks to the facts.” In a video posted on social media platform X, Burck, who performs regularly in Manhattan’s tourist district, strummed a guitar adorned with stickers reading “Bruce Blakeman for Governor” and “www.FireMamdani.com.” The endorsement comes as Blakeman campaigns against incumbent Democratic Governor Kathy Hochul, with the race characterized by sharp divisions over immigration enforcement, taxation, and foreign policy alliances. Burck sang a self-composed song criticizing Hochul for what he described as a “radical scheme of left-wing delusion.” The lyrics alleged that the governor supports open borders and allows utility bills to rise while working-class residents bear the cost. “New York is tired of the games and the tax,” Burck sang. “While Albany stumbles, and wastes every dime, Bruce Blakeman is ready to crack down on crime.” He added that Blakeman possesses a “practical mind” and intends to lower tax bills and cut waste. The performer urged viewers to “get out the vote” and stated that the choice between the two candidates was clear. Blakeman amplified the endorsement by sharing the video on X, captioning it with the statement that “even the Naked Cowboy wants to Fire Kathy Hochul.” The campaign strategy aligns with Blakeman’s broader messaging, which emphasizes fiscal responsibility and law and order. During a gubernatorial debate in October, Blakeman attacked Hochul for her stance on immigration, specifically rejecting her claim that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations were “out of control” in Nassau County, where Blakeman serves as county executive. Hochul cited an incident involving an 11-year-old boy who cried after his father was detained in an ICE raid. Blakeman countered that ICE had removed more than 2,000 individuals with criminal convictions from his jurisdiction, arguing that cooperation with federal agencies enhances community safety. He noted that no unrest, violence, or incidents occurred at schools, hospitals, or churches during these operations. The political landscape surrounding the race includes diverse endorsements and criticisms from various sectors. Actor and comedian Michael Rapaport recently disclosed that he voted for Blakeman over Hochul. Conversely, libertarian perspectives view the contest negatively. A columnist for Reason magazine, noting that he lives in New York City, expressed frustration with the lack of viable third-party options due to legislative barriers enacted in 2020 that make it difficult for minor parties to access ballots. The columnist, who ranks Hochul among the worst governors based on a Cato Institute report regarding economic and personal liberty, stated he would write in “none of the above” as a protest. Prediction markets reflect high confidence in the incumbent, with one platform assigning Hochul a 96 percent probability of victory. Critics have also focused on Blakeman’s ties to Israeli political figures. Reports indicate that in 2023, Israeli Minister of Heritage Amichai Eliyahu visited Blakeman in Cedarhurst, New York, presenting him with an enlarged replica of an ancient coin. Blakeman accepted the item on behalf of Nassau County residents and Americans who “love Israel.” Blakeman has a history of engaging with officials associated with the Israeli settler movement. Yossi Dagan, an Israeli lobbyist, previously described Blakeman as a “strategic asset” for the State of Israel and the occupied West Bank, referred to locally as Judea and Samaria. Blakeman’s campaign has positioned him as a defender of New York’s Jewish community, claiming he could “stop” New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Blakeman has repeatedly labeled Mamdani an antisemite, a characterization supported by neither Mamdani nor mainstream civil rights organizations. Mamdani has faced scrutiny from right-wing groups for his public statements accusing Israel of committing genocide and for releasing a video calling for the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The International Criminal Court has issued a warrant for Netanyahu’s arrest on war crimes charges, and many international legal experts support the designation of Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocidal. In response to the pro-Palestine protest movement, Blakeman visited Columbia University in 2024 during active student demonstrations. He characterized the demonstrators as “professional protesters” and “anti-American.” Following these visits, Blakeman signed a law banning the use of facial coverings to conceal identity in public within Nassau County. The legislation was introduced by another Republican who argued it was necessary following nationwide pro-Palestine protests, where participants often masked their faces to avoid identification by counter-protestors. Blakeman has stated that if elected governor, he would pursue a similar ban statewide. His campaign did not respond to requests for comment regarding his relationships with Israeli officials or his specific policy proposals beyond general themes of safety and fiscal discipline. The election highlights deep ideological divides in New York politics. While Blakeman leverages endorsements from cultural figures and emphasizes strict enforcement of laws, Hochul defends her record on public safety and criticizes federal immigration tactics. The presence of stickers referencing Mamdani on Burck’s guitar underscores the interconnected nature of the state and city races, linking the gubernatorial contest directly to conflicts between Blakeman and the mayor-elect. As the election approaches, both candidates continue to target voters concerned with rising costs, crime rates, and the direction of state governance, with each side framing the opponent as responsible for New York’s current challenges.
Go to the primary sources (4)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
Times Square performer Robert Burck, known as the Naked Cowboy, publicly endorsed Republican Bruce Blakeman for New York Governor through a musical performance posted on social media. In the video, Burck criticized Democratic incumbent Kathy Hochul, describing her policies as a 'radical scheme of left-wing delusion' and accusing her of supporting open borders and rising costs. The endorsement highlights Blakeman’s campaign focus on lowering taxes, cutting waste, and cracking down on crime. The article contextualizes this by referencing a recent gubernatorial debate where Blakeman defended ICE operations in Nassau County against Hochul’s claims that the agency is 'out of control.' Blakeman argued that ICE actions have improved safety by removing individuals with criminal records, while Hochul cited an incident involving a detained father to illustrate the human cost of enforcement.
Bias read (Conservative): Framing relies heavily on pro-candidate quotes using terms like 'left-wing delusion' and 'criminal illegals,' while presenting the opponent's concerns regarding ICE as mere 'emotional appeals' rather than valid policy critiques.
This opinion piece reflects on the author’s longstanding frustration with major-party candidates, using a 2004 magazine cover criticizing John Kerry and George W. Bush as a starting point. The author argues that while they identify as a principled libertarian, they are willing to support major-party candidates if those individuals commit to limiting government size and spending. Focusing on the upcoming New York gubernatorial race, the article criticizes incumbent Democrat Kathy Hochul for receiving the lowest grade in the Cato Institute’s 'Freedom in the 50 States' report. It also dismisses Republican challenger Bruce Blakeman due to his lack of competitive polling numbers and limited political experience. Because legislative changes have restricted third-party ballot access, the author plans to write in 'none of the above' as a protest vote rather than choosing between the two major-party options.
Bias read (Conservative): The author explicitly identifies as a libertarian, uses pejorative language for both major parties, and cites conservative think tank data to justify rejecting mainstream candidates.
New York gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman maintains close ties with Israeli far-right figures and the settler movement, including receiving a commemorative coin from an Israeli minister in 2023. Despite an International Court of Justice advisory opinion demanding the cessation of settlement activities, Blakeman continues to support policies aligned with these groups. His campaign positions him as a defender of New York’s Jewish community against Mayor Zohran Mamdani, whom Blakeman labels an antisemite due to Mamdani’s criticism of Israel’s actions in Gaza. While Blakeman’s campaign declined to comment, critics note that Mamdani’s stance aligns with expert consensus regarding the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and international legal proceedings against Israeli leadership.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames Blakeman’s pro-Israel stance negatively using terms like 'far-right' and highlights his dismissal of ICJ rulings, while presenting Mamdani’s criticism of Israel as reasonable and supported by experts.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.