Stephen A Smith Doesn't Hold Back on Alabama's Kalen DeBoer

Stephen A. Smith openly criticized Alabama head coach Kalen DeBoer during Tuesday’s episode of First Take on ESPN, calling for his immediate dismissal if the team fails to show improvement in the upcoming 2026 season. Smith highlighted DeBoer’s struggles, noting that the Crimson Tide have recorded four losses in each of his first two seasons leading the program. The team missed the College Football Playoff in DeBoer’s inaugural campaign and suffered a shocking 38-3 defeat to the eventual champion Indiana Hoosiers in the CFP quarterfinals last year. DeBoer, who signed a seven-year contract with Alabama in April, is set to earn $12.5 million annually under the agreement. In a statement at the time, DeBoer expressed enthusiasm about continuing his tenure in Tuscaloosa, emphasizing the program’s rich tradition and his commitment to bringing more championships to Alabama. However, Smith dismissed these assurances, arguing that DeBoer’s performance has fallen short of expectations. During the segment, Smith compared DeBoer unfavorably to other successful coaches such as Jimbo Fisher and Brian Kelly, suggesting that Alabama should consider replacing him rather than investing further in his current approach. Smith pointed to specific examples of DeBoer’s shortcomings, including the low-scoring output against Indiana. He argued that the offensive philosophy under DeBoer has failed to produce results, with the team scoring just three points in that game despite being heavily favored. “They were lucky to get to the postseason,” Smith said. “This man's supposed to be about offense, they scored three points. Give him the money to just go away.” The criticism comes amid growing pressure on DeBoer following a disappointing 2025 season. While Alabama managed to secure a spot in the College Football Playoff, the team struggled throughout the year, failing to live up to its historic standards. Fans and analysts alike have questioned whether DeBoer can consistently deliver the high-level performances associated with Alabama’s storied program. The 2026 season will mark DeBoer’s third year as head coach, with the team set to open its schedule against the East Carolina Pirates on September 5. The outcome of this season could determine whether DeBoer remains in his position or faces a potential change in leadership. With a substantial financial investment already made, Alabama will likely evaluate DeBoer’s performance closely over the next few months before making any final decisions. As the coaching staff prepares for the new season, the focus will shift toward addressing the issues that have plagued the team under DeBoer. Whether through adjustments in strategy, personnel changes, or a complete overhaul of the coaching structure, the pressure is mounting for results. For now, the spotlight remains on DeBoer and the challenges ahead.