The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) recently announced the cancellation of a contract for a surveillance tool known as Webloc, following mounting concerns from lawmakers, prosecutors, and judges over its legality in criminal investigations. This decision marks a significant shift in how federal agencies approach the collection of location data during investigations, raising broader questions about privacy, due process, and the boundaries of law enforcement authority.
The controversy began when Rep. Michael Cloud, a Republican from Texas, and Sen. Ron Wyden, a Democrat from Oregon, raised alarms about the use of Webloc, a tool developed by Penlink. The software collects location data from consumer apps and advertising networks, allowing law enforcement to track the movements of individuals without obtaining a warrant. This method, often referred to as "ad tech" data, has sparked debate among legal experts and civil liberties advocates, who argue that it circumvents constitutional protections against unreasonable search and seizure under the Fourth Amendment.
According to reports, the ATF had been utilizing Webloc as part of a "pilot" program aimed at improving investigative capabilities. However, the agency concluded that the tool did not meet its operational needs and decided to discontinue its use. ATF officials stated that they are not currently employing any other ad-tech-based services, emphasizing their commitment to evaluating tools that align with legal standards and public safety goals. An ATF spokesperson noted that the agency continuously assesses new technologies to combat violent crime while ensuring compliance with legal frameworks.
The decision came after a congressional hearing where ATF Director Robert Cekada admitted that the agency had been purchasing geolocation data on American cellphones. Following this revelation, Wyden and Cloud’s offices were briefed by ATF, leading to the disclosure that over 300 warrantless searches had been conducted using Webloc, including more than 200 related to ongoing ATF cases. One notable case involved a suspected arson incident linked to a U.S. defense contractor, where a prosecutor and a judge voiced concerns about the use of Webloc data. As a result, the agency was compelled to seek traditional court orders for bulk cellphone tower data from telecommunications providers.
Webloc, originally developed by an Israeli company named Cobwebs, was later acquired and integrated into Penlink, a U.S.-based firm. Penlink maintains that its partnership with ATF supports efforts to protect communities from firearm-related violence and arson. Despite the termination of the contract, the company expressed hope for future collaboration with the agency.
This development highlights the increasing reliance of law enforcement agencies on advanced surveillance technologies, even as legal and ethical boundaries remain unclear. While some see these tools as essential for modern policing, others warn of the potential erosion of civil liberties and the need for clearer regulatory oversight. As discussions continue, the implications of this decision extend beyond the ATF, influencing broader conversations about privacy, transparency, and the role of technology in governance.
9 reports
MIT Technology ReviewIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 9020 hr. agoThe article features a selection of technology-related news highlights. One story discusses the UK's generational tobacco ban, which aims to eliminate tobacco sales to those under a certain age, though its effectiveness remains uncertain. Another piece highlights a short story by Elizabeth Bear titled 'You do your own time,' which explores themes of censorship and preserving historical records. Additionally, there is coverage of an EU lawmaker being hacked by the same spyware he was investigating, raising concerns about surveillance practices. Other topics include technological advancements and challenges related to AI and data privacy.
Bias read (Center): The article presents multiple stories with varying degrees of political charge. The tobacco ban and spyware investigation involve governmental policies and oversight, but the framing remains balanced, presenting facts without overt ideological slant. The short story by Elizabeth Bear does not carrya
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 90): The article mentions the EU lawmaker being hacked by spyware accurately, though it's buried in a roundup of other stories. It doesn't add false claims, but lacks depth compared to the primary source.
TechCrunchIndependentCenterFactual 30Objective 853 days agoActi, a Singapore-based startup, has launched an AI-powered keyboard for iOS and Android devices that integrates AI agents directly into the user's typing experience. This keyboard allows users to perform actions such as providing local restaurant recommendations or sharing stock prices within chats, eliminating the need to switch between apps. The technology uses Google's Gemini models and emphasizes privacy by keeping user data on the device unless explicitly shared. Acti's founder, Young Wang, highlights the shift in how AI can be embedded into existing interfaces rather than requiring users to engage with standalone AI chatbots.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses a technological innovation related to AI integration in mobile keyboards. It provides balanced coverage of the product's features, technical underpinnings, and the founder's perspective without showing clear ideological bias or framing that favors one side over another.
Why these scores (Factual 30 · Objective 85): The article discusses AI keyboards but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is low since it's unrelated, but the tone remains neutral.
TechCrunchIndependentCenterFactual 25Objective 853 days ago Lumo, Proton’s privacy-focused AI chatbot, gets an upgradeProton, a privacy-focused productivity app company, has launched an upgraded version of its AI chatbot, Lumo 2.0. The update introduces features such as image recognition, image generation, and enhanced document handling through the Projects widget. Lumo 2.0 also includes a 'thinking mode' for tackling complex tasks and improves response speed by up to 76%. The chatbot emphasizes strong privacy protections, using zero-access encryption and avoiding server-side logging or data sharing. While comparable in functionality to other AI chatbots like Gemini and ChatGPT, Lumo differentiates itself through its commitment to user privacy. The free public version is available now, with premium tiers offering additional features.
Bias read (Center): The article presents information about a technological product update without taking a political stance. It focuses on features, performance improvements, and privacy measures without advocating for any particular ideology or political agenda.
Why these scores (Factual 25 · Objective 85): The article discusses an AI chatbot upgrade but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is low due to irrelevance, but the tone remains neutral.
QuartzIndependentLeftFactual 25Objective 8010 days agoThe article discusses how government agencies at all levels are adopting AI-powered surveillance technologies. These systems are being used to monitor the general population, but concerns have been raised about their accuracy and potential misuse. The piece highlights the growing trend of integrating artificial intelligence into law enforcement and governmental monitoring practices, raising questions about privacy and civil liberties.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the adoption of AI surveillance by government agencies as a concerning development, emphasizing issues like accuracy, privacy, and civil liberties. This suggests a critical perspective towards government actions and technological expansion, aligning with a left-leaning viewpoint.
Why these scores (Factual 25 · Objective 80): The article talks about AI surveillance tools but isn't related to the specific spyware hacking of the EU lawmaker. Factual accuracy is low due to irrelevance, but the tone is neutral.
QuartzIndependentCenterFactual 20Objective 8510 days ago Apple's long gameApple is focusing on long-term strategies involving developers, privacy, and patience as it approaches its 50th anniversary, aiming to reinvent itself in the era of artificial intelligence.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses Apple's strategic focus on technology development and innovation without any political framing or bias. It does not involve political figures, policies, or contentious issues.
Why these scores (Factual 20 · Objective 85): The article discusses Apple's strategy but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is low due to irrelevance, but the tone remains neutral.
TechCrunchIndependentCenterFactual 15Objective 8513 days ago Signal’s Meredith Whittaker wants you to remember that AI chatbots ‘are not your friends’Signal President Meredith Whittaker warned against treating AI chatbots like ChatGPT and Claude as if they were friends or conscious entities during an interview with Bloomberg. She emphasized that these systems are not sentient and cautioned against relying on them for critical tasks such as decision-making or communication. While acknowledging her personal use of AI tools for minor formatting tasks, Whittaker stressed the importance of maintaining independent thought and avoiding reliance on AI-generated responses. She criticized scenarios where AI assistants like Microsoft Copilot might have extensive access to personal data, including financial information, messaging apps, and calendars, calling such access a 'backdoor' in the context of Signal.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses technological concerns related to AI chatbots and their integration into daily life, focusing on privacy and ethical considerations rather than directly addressing political issues, policies, or partisan debates. The content remains neutral in tone, presenting Whittaker's views
Why these scores (Factual 15 · Objective 85): The article discusses AI ethics but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is low due to irrelevance, but the tone remains neutral.
SlateIndependentCenterFactual 15Objective 806 days agoA woman writes to a relationship advice column expressing her distress after discovering her boyfriend had uploaded photos of people close to him—including a family friend he described as a 'sister'—to ChatGPT to generate explicit images. She feels betrayed and questions whether she should end the relationship. The columnist responds by acknowledging her feelings but suggests that generating such images may not constitute a direct violation of privacy unless the photos are shared or misused. The writer cautions against uploading personal photos to AI platforms due to potential risks like data breaches and misuse in deepfakes.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses ethical concerns around AI technology and personal privacy, but does not present a political issue or controversy. The framing remains neutral, focusing on individual behavior and technological risks rather than partisan issues.
Why these scores (Factual 15 · Objective 80): The article discusses a personal relationship issue involving AI and has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is extremely low due to irrelevance, but the tone is neutral.
Los Angeles TimesIndependent🔒CenterFactual 10Objective 8514 days agoThe article discusses the growing role of artificial intelligence in Hollywood and highlights the emerging legal and ethical debates surrounding the use of actors' likenesses and compensation. With AI technology enabling the creation of digital doubles and deepfakes, there is increasing concern about intellectual property rights, consent, and fair payment for performers. The piece emphasizes the tension between technological innovation and traditional labor practices in the entertainment industry, suggesting that unresolved issues could impact both creators and consumers.
Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced overview of the issue without overtly favoring any particular side. It focuses on the technical and legal challenges rather than taking a clear ideological stance. While it acknowledges the potential benefits of AI in filmmaking, it also raises concerns about fairness
Why these scores (Factual 10 · Objective 85): The article discusses Hollywood and AI but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is extremely low due to irrelevance, but the tone remains neutral.
QuartzIndependentCenterFactual 5Objective 8010 days ago The nudifier boomMinnesota is taking legal action against the proliferation of AI-generated sexual deepfakes, which have been spreading widely online. These deepfakes involve the creation of explicit content using artificial intelligence to manipulate images or videos of individuals without their consent. The state aims to address this issue through legislation that could hold creators and distributors accountable. This comes amid growing concerns over the ethical and legal implications of such technology, including issues of privacy, consent, and potential harm to individuals' reputations and mental health.
Bias read (Center): The article presents information about Minnesota's legal response to AI-generated deepfakes without overtly favoring any particular political perspective. It outlines the issue and the legislative efforts being made without using biased language or selectively presenting information to support a pre
Why these scores (Factual 5 · Objective 80): The article discusses AI-generated deepfakes and legal responses but has nothing to do with the spyware incident. Factual accuracy is extremely low due to irrelevance, but the tone is neutral.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
United States
