The Senate panel led by Senator Erwin Tulfo has announced plans to reassess the age of criminal liability in the Philippines, following a series of tragic incidents involving minors. These cases have sparked intense debate over how best to balance the legal protections afforded to children with the need for societal safety and justice. The review comes amid growing concerns about the effectiveness of current laws in addressing the complex realities of youth involvement in violent acts.
The review process began after three fatal incidents involving minors across the country. The most recent and widely publicized case occurred in Tacloban City, where two students, reportedly aged 14 and 15, allegedly shot and killed three classmates at a high school. Other incidents included a stabbing in Negros Occidental and another in Cavite. These events have prompted urgent calls for legislative action, particularly regarding the age at which children can be held legally responsible for their actions.
Senator Erwin Tulfo, chair of the Senate panel on social justice, welfare, and rural development, emphasized that the review aims to address "glaring gaps" in the implementation of Republic Act No. 9344, the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006. This law currently sets the age of criminal liability at 15, meaning children under 15 are exempt from prosecution and instead receive intervention services. However, the law allows for exceptions if a child between 15 and 18 demonstrates discernment in committing a crime.
Tulfo's call for a comprehensive review reflects broader tensions within the political and legal spheres. While some lawmakers advocate for lowering the age of criminal responsibility, others caution against potential negative impacts on children's rights. For instance, Senator Robin Padilla proposed lowering the age to 10, a suggestion met with criticism from figures like ACT Teachers party-list representative Antonio Tinio, who described the idea as "barbaric." Meanwhile, Senator Risa Hontiveros suggested examining the role of digital media and video games in influencing youth behavior, though this approach has faced skepticism from online communities.
Interior and Local Government Secretary Jonvic Remulla, who supports the push to lower the age of criminal responsibility, acknowledged the challenges posed by the current legal framework. He noted that the Juvenile Justice law fails to adequately address the use of minors as drug couriers, a situation that leaves them vulnerable to exploitation and unable to face charges. Despite his support, Remulla stressed the necessity of consulting with Congress before determining a specific age limit.
The debate surrounding the age of criminal liability extends beyond legal considerations. It touches on ethical, social, and developmental issues. Proponents of stricter liability argue that holding young offenders accountable is essential for maintaining public safety and reinforcing moral boundaries. Conversely, critics warn that lowering the age could lead to the wrongful incarceration of children, undermining efforts to rehabilitate and reintegrate them into society.
The Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006, along with its amendments, represents a significant step toward protecting children's rights. It emphasizes rehabilitation over punitive measures, recognizing that children differ from adults in their emotional, psychological, and social development. Under the law, children aged 15 and below are entirely exempt from criminal liability, while those between 15 and 18 may be considered for prosecution based on their level of discernment.
Section 20-A of the law, introduced through Republic Act 10630, addresses serious crimes committed by children aged 12 to 15. This provision mandates that such children be treated as "neglected children" and placed in specialized intervention centers. The aim is to protect society while ensuring the child receives necessary psychological and educational support. However, this system has drawn criticism for potentially failing to provide adequate accountability for severe offenses.
As the Senate panel moves forward with its review, the focus will likely shift toward finding a balanced approach that respects children's rights while addressing the root causes of violent behavior. This includes improving access to mental health resources, strengthening parental accountability, and enhancing the availability of functional intervention facilities. The outcome of this review could significantly impact future legislation and policy decisions related to juvenile justice in the Philippines.
14 reports
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter5 days agoThe Philippine National Police (PNP) has mandated its units to launch information campaigns aimed at combating bullying and enhancing online safety, following the tragic school shooting in Tacloban City where three students were killed and 20 others injured. PNP Chief General Jose Melencio Nartatez Jr. emphasized collaboration with schools, local authorities, and community leaders to prevent such incidents through education and awareness programs. The PNP's Anti-Cybercrime Group will provide training on identifying cyber threats, while the Department of Education (DepEd) plans to increase the number of school guidance counselors to support mental health and intervene early in cases of potential violence. The shooting was linked to two minors who reportedly faced bullying and were influenced by violent content.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information about the PNP's initiatives and responses to the school shooting without overtly favoring any political side. It includes quotes from PNP leadership and mentions collaboration with educational institutions and local stakeholders, indicating a balanced report.
RapplerIndependentCenter6 days agoA 15-year-old student named Chris Lorenz Fabian was killed during a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22. Known for his kindness and generosity, Chris was described by his mother as caring toward his siblings and often giving away his money to those in need. During the attack, Chris reportedly displayed extraordinary bravery by physically blocking the attackers to protect his teacher and classmates, resulting in his death. The Boy Scouts of the Philippines posthumously honored him with the Gold Gallantry and Heroism Award for his selfless act. Two minors were arrested in connection with the incident, which left two other students dead and 20 others injured.
Bias read (Center): The article focuses on a tragic school shooting and the personal story of a student who died protecting others. While the event has national implications and involves law enforcement (arrests of minors), the framing is primarily human-interest and commemorative, with no clear ideological slant or政治化
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago Pampanga town honors heroism of slain Tacloban shooting victimA 15-year-old student named Chris Lorenz Tanglao Fabian was killed during a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22, 2026. Fabian is being honored as a hero for reportedly shielding his classmates from the attackers. The municipal government of Minalin in Pampanga officially recognized his actions during a council session, acknowledging his bravery in attempting to block the door to protect his peers. The incident resulted in three student deaths and 20 injuries. Minalin Mayor Philip Naguit praised Fabian's courage and expressed condolences to his family and the families of the other victims, calling for justice for his death.
Bias read (Center): The article focuses on a tragic school shooting and the recognition of a student's heroic actions. While it mentions local government response and calls for justice, there is no clear ideological framing or biased language. The content remains focused on factual reporting of the event and community悼
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago DILG chief backs lowering age of criminal responsibilityThe Philippine Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) secretary, Jonvic Remulla, has expressed support for lowering the age of criminal responsibility in response to recent incidents involving minors. Two junior high school students, aged 14 and 15, were arrested for a shooting at a high school in Tacloban City, which resulted in three deaths and multiple injuries. Under current law, children under 15 are not criminally liable, while those between 15 and 18 can only be held responsible if deemed to have 'discernment.' Remulla acknowledged the need to discuss potential changes with Congress but did not specify a proposed age. The suspects are currently in police custody, and authorities are consulting with the Department of Social Welfare and Development to determine whether the 15-year-old can be tried as an adult.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the views of a government official advocating for policy change, alongside legal context and factual details about the incident. It does not exhibit overtly biased language, one-sided sourcing, or omissions that would indicate a clear ideological lean. The framing remains fact-f
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago Tacloban school shooting a case of ‘bullying gone wrong’ – RemullaA school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City resulted in three student deaths and multiple injuries. Two male students, aged 14 and 15, opened fire during class on Monday. According to Interior and Local Government Secretary Jonvic Remulla, the incident was described as 'bullying gone wrong,' with victims claiming they had been bullied by classmates for some time. The students reportedly played a game called 'GoreBox' before the attack. Authorities noted that while police are present at schools, they cannot conduct searches on students, emphasizing that school principals are responsible for internal matters. The incident has prompted calls to review policies on bullying and other underlying issues.
Bias read (Center): The article presents statements from an official (Interior and Local Government Secretary Jonvic Remulla) and includes context about the incident, including the claim of bullying and the involvement of law enforcement. There is no overtly biased language or selective sourcing; the framing remains un
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentRight10 days ago From Duterte’s 1972 shooting story to Tacloban: School violence in PHThe article discusses two separate but related incidents involving school violence in the Philippines. The first recounts former President Rodrigo Duterte's claim that he shot his fraternity brother at San Beda College in 1972 after an altercation involving bullying. Duterte described the event during a 2016 campaign speech, stating he was hit in the nose and fired back, though the victim survived. The second part covers a recent school shooting in Tacloban City, where two students opened fire at San Jose National High School, killing three and injuring at least 20 others. The article notes that while school violence is less common in the Philippines compared to other countries like the U.S., there have been previous incidents, including a 2015 stabbing by a student due to bullying and a 2016 case where a student fatally stabbed a teacher.
Bias read (Right): The article frames Duterte's past actions in a manner that aligns with his political narrative, emphasizing his personal account of the 1972 shooting without critical examination or contextual balance. It highlights his recounting of the incident during a campaign speech, which suggests a pro-Dutert
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago 14-year-old gunman in Tacloban shooting fired at least 33 shots – PNPTwo junior high school students, aged 14 and 15, were arrested for a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22, 2026, which resulted in three fatalities and at least 20 injuries. According to the Philippine National Police (PNP), the older shooter fired once before being restrained, while the younger shooter managed to reload his weapon multiple times, firing at least 33 shots in total. Investigators recovered 34 bullets, including both spent and live cartridges, from the scene. The weapons used were a .38-caliber revolver and a 9-mm Glock 17 pistol, both legally registered to family members. The PNP acknowledged potential gaps in school security protocols that allowed the shooters to bring firearms onto campus.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information about a school shooting, focusing on the number of casualties, the weapons used, and the actions of law enforcement. There is no overtly biased language, and the report includes details from official sources such as the PNP. While the event could be seen as a
RapplerIndependentCenter10 days ago [Pinoy Criminology] The Tacloban school shooting and the challenge of juvenile justiceA school shooting occurred in Tacloban, Philippines, where two teenagers allegedly shot and killed three classmates. The incident has sparked nationwide debate over juvenile justice, particularly regarding the legal age of criminal responsibility. Under the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006, children 15 years old or younger are generally exempt from criminal liability, regardless of their understanding of the crime. Those between 12 and 15 may be held accountable if deemed to have 'discernment'—a legal term indicating sufficient maturity to understand the nature of their actions. The current law emphasizes rehabilitation over punishment, but critics argue it fails to hold juveniles fully accountable for severe offenses. Some advocate lowering the age of criminal responsibility to 12, while others stress the need for reform within the existing framework.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives on the juvenile justice system without overtly favoring one side. It explains the legal framework, highlights public concerns, and includes opposing viewpoints without editorializing or biased language.
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago PNP: Both suspects in Tacloban shooting test positive for gunpowderTwo junior high school students, aged 14 and 15, were arrested for their involvement in a fatal shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22, 2026. The incident resulted in at least three student deaths and multiple injuries. Both suspects tested positive for gunpowder residue via a paraffin test, indicating recent gunfire exposure. The 14-year-old used a 9mm pistol reportedly owned by his aunt, a police officer, while the 15-year-old used a .38 revolver linked to a Cebu-based security agency through his grandfather. Authorities are investigating how the firearms came into the minors' possession, and the aunt has been suspended pending an inquiry. The PNP emphasized the dangers of gun access and suggested potential influences such as violent video games.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information about a criminal incident involving minors, firearms, and law enforcement. While it includes quotes from PNP officials expressing concerns about gun safety and potential influences like violent video games, these comments are presented as part of the official
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago PNP says students may report bullying to police assistance desksThe Philippine National Police (PNP) announced that students can now report bullying incidents to police assistance desks located near schools. This follows a tragic incident at a high school in Tacloban City, where two students shot and killed three classmates, injuring many others. According to authorities, the attackers claimed they had been bullied prior to the incident, though the PNP has not confirmed these claims. The PNP emphasized that no form of bullying justifies such violence and stated that the police are investigating whether the attackers' parents might bear liability. In response, the PNP chief ordered a review of existing school security protocols to address potential vulnerabilities.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information about the PNP's response to a school bullying-related tragedy, including quotes from both the PNP and law enforcement officials. It does not exhibit clear bias toward either side of the issue, providing balanced reporting on the situation without overtly slan
RapplerIndependentCenter10 days ago 2 kids planned Tacloban school shooting, initial police probe showsTwo minors, aged 14 and 15, were involved in a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22, which resulted in three deaths and 15 injuries. According to the Philippine National Police, the suspects had planned the attack in advance, meeting in a restroom for over an hour before opening fire. The police investigation indicated that the attack was premeditated rather than impulsive, and the suspects were reportedly influenced by online content. The victims' claims of being bullied remain unverified. The incident has led to calls for reviewing school safety protocols, and the Senate plans to hold a hearing on the matter.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information based on police reports and investigations without overtly favoring any political side. It focuses on the criminal actions of minors and the subsequent response by authorities, avoiding ideological framing.
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago PNP urges calm amid response measures after Tacloban school shootingFollowing a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City, where two male students aged 14 and 15 killed at least three classmates and injured others, Philippine National Police (PNP) chief Gen. Jose Melencio Nartatez Jr. called for public calm and emphasized the PNP's efforts to enhance school safety measures. The suspects were apprehended under the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act, which mandates handling of minors involved in crimes. The PNP is collaborating with the Department of Education to review safety protocols, implement child protection services, and provide psychosocial support. Nartatez urged the public to avoid speculation and share only verified information while increasing police visibility around schools.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the PNP's response to a school shooting in a balanced manner, focusing on official statements and actions without overtly favoring any political side. It emphasizes collaboration between law enforcement and educational authorities, avoids taking a stance on broader policy issues
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago Tacloban shooting: Slain student who shielded peers hailed a heroA 15-year-old student named Chris Lorenz Fabian was killed during a school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City on June 22, 2026. Fabian is being remembered as a hero after he reportedly shielded his classmates from gunfire by blocking the entrance of one of the shooters. The attack, carried out by two minor students using a .38 revolver and a Glock 17 pistol, resulted in three deaths and 20 injuries. Witnesses stated that Fabian was shot in the back while trying to protect his peers. The suspects, who were enrolled at the school, were handed over to social welfare authorities and claimed the incident was motivated by bullying, though no official motive has been confirmed. Fabian's family described him as a brave and well-behaved individual who had recently transferred to the school and aspired to become a police officer.
Bias read (Center): The article provides a balanced account of the event, focusing on the actions of the student and the details of the shooting without overtly favoring any political perspective. It includes quotes from survivors, family members, and mentions the involvement of local authorities without apparent bias.
Philippine Daily InquirerIndependentCenter10 days ago Tacloban shooting: Western Visayas steps up anti-bullying pushFollowing a deadly school shooting at San Jose National High School in Tacloban City, where three students were killed and 20 others injured, the Department of Education (DepEd) Region 6 (Western Visayas) has issued directives to enhance campus security and enforce anti-bullying initiatives. Two minors, aged 14 and 15, were arrested and found in possession of firearms. Authorities suggest the attack may have been motivated by bullying. DepEd officials have mandated increased security measures, including bag checks, the presence of law enforcement, and the potential acquisition of metal detectors and CCTV cameras. They emphasize the importance of addressing bullying and coordinating with local governments to prevent future incidents.
Bias read (Center): The article presents factual information about a school shooting and subsequent policy responses without overtly favoring any political side. It includes quotes from DepEd officials and mentions actions taken by the department, but does not exhibit clear bias toward one political perspective. The报道
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter![[Pinoy Criminology] The Tacloban school shooting and the challenge of juvenile justice](https://images.weserv.nl/?url=newsinfo.inquirer.net%2Ffiles%2F2024%2F11%2Fbullying-stock-18November2024.png&w=3840&q=75&output=webp&we)
PH
