ON
← Back to feed
One Nation, One Election Bills: Supreme Court gave its nod on Sept 22, but cancelled meet with House panel late, says JPC Chairman
India🏛️ PoliticsCenter

One Nation, One Election Bills: Supreme Court gave its nod on Sept 22, but cancelled meet with House panel late, says JPC Chairman

The chairman of the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) on the 'One Nation, One Election' bills, P P Chaudhary, stated that the Supreme Court initially agreed to hold a meeting with the committee on October 6, 2026, to discuss the proposed legislation. However, the meeting was later canceled after the court received objections from various quarters. The planned meeting was intended as a 'local study visit' involving an 'informal discussion' with the Chief Justice of India and other judges on the issue of simultaneous elections. The controversy arose when Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal criticized the meeting as unconstitutional, arguing that the bills under discussion might eventually be subject to judicial review. The Supreme Court reportedly decided against proceeding with the meeting after internal discussions among senior judges. The JPC had been informed of the initial agreement by the court, and preparations were made, including submitting materials to the court and sharing participant lists. The cancellation came amid concerns that engaging with the judiciary on these bills could lead to legal challenges.

The Supreme Court of India initially approved a meeting with the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) examining the One Nation, One Election (ONOE) bills but later cancelled it, according to P P Chaudhary, the JPC chairman. The meeting was originally scheduled for October 6 at 4:30 pm, but the court informed the committee of the cancellation on October 1, citing concerns that the proposed constitutional amendments might eventually be subject to judicial review. Chaudhary stated that the meeting was arranged following suggestions from DMK MP and senior advocate P Wilson, who argued that consulting the judiciary would provide valuable insights into the legal implications of the bills. The JPC had requested the meeting after obtaining approval from the Lok Sabha Speaker. On September 18, the Lok Sabha Secretariat wrote to the Supreme Court’s secretary general, expressing the committee’s desire to conduct a "local study visit" to the apex court for "informal discussions" with the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and other judges on the topic of simultaneous elections. The Registrar-cum-PPS to the CJI informed the committee on September 22 that the informal discussion was set for October 6. The Lok Sabha secretariat confirmed the visit through an office memorandum, making arrangements for around 35 members and six officers to attend. On September 28, the legislative department forwarded the relevant documents and letters to the Supreme Court’s secretary general. However, on October 1, the Supreme Court’s secretary general informed the committee that the matter had been discussed among senior judges, who concluded that it would not be appropriate to hold the meeting, as the proposed constitutional amendments could potentially fall under judicial review. The Lok Sabha Secretariat subsequently issued an office memorandum to the Supreme Court and a formal letter to the JPC members announcing the cancellation of the scheduled visit. The initial proposal for the meeting was made by P Wilson, who emphasized the importance of broad-based consultation. In a detailed seven-page letter to the committee, Wilson explained that he had suggested the meeting to gather the views of the current CJI and other judges, believing it would contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the legal aspects of the ONOE bills. He noted that similar consultations had taken place in the past, such as during the drafting of the Constitution in 1948 and in relation to the Mediation Bill, virtual courts, and the National Legal Services Authority. Chaudhary acknowledged that while the JPC had considered the suggestion, the Supreme Court ultimately deemed it inappropriate to proceed with the meeting. He stated that if the court felt the meeting was not suitable, there was no need to continue pursuing the matter, as doing so could generate unnecessary public attention. Chaudhary also highlighted that parliamentary committees had previously engaged with the Supreme Court on various issues, underscoring the legitimacy of such interactions. Opposition MPs, including senior advocate Kapil Sibal, criticized the proposed meeting, arguing that it was unconstitutional. Sibal contended that the ONOE bills could eventually be brought before the court for adjudication, making it inappropriate for the committee to seek input from the judiciary. Congress MP Manish Tewari echoed these sentiments, describing the decision to consult the Supreme Court as a grave error. However, Wilson countered these criticisms by pointing to historical precedents where parliamentary committees had sought the views of Supreme Court judges, emphasizing that such meetings did not constitute an attempt to solicit judicial adjudication. In addition to engaging with the Supreme Court, the JPC has also held discussions with several experts and advisors. These include Chief Economic Advisor V Anantha Nageswaran, Chairman of the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister, S Mahendra Dev, and Vivekananda International Foundation chairman S Gurumurthy. All three expressed support for the concept of simultaneous elections, highlighting potential economic benefits and concerns related to frequent electoral cycles. Nageswaran noted that frequent elections tend to shift focus towards revenue expenditure rather than capital expenditure, potentially leading to policy paralysis. Gurumurthy warned that regular elections could foster the growth of paid party workers and the misuse of money power, contrasting this with the development of voluntary political cadres. The JPC is currently examining two key pieces of legislation: the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024, and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2024. Both bills aim to facilitate the implementation of simultaneous elections across the country. As the committee continues its deliberations, the debate over the role of the judiciary in shaping constitutional reforms remains a central issue.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 3 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

3 reports

The Indian Express logoThe Indian ExpressIndependentCenterFactual 98Objective 95
One Nation, One Election Bills: Supreme Court gave its nod on Sept 22, but cancelled meet with House panel late, says JPC Chairman

The chairman of the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) on the 'One Nation, One Election' bills, P P Chaudhary, stated that the Supreme Court initially agreed to hold a meeting with the committee on October 6, 2026, to discuss the proposed legislation. However, the meeting was later canceled after the court received objections from various quarters. The planned meeting was intended as a 'local study visit' involving an 'informal discussion' with the Chief Justice of India and other judges on the issue of simultaneous elections. The controversy arose when Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal criticized the meeting as unconstitutional, arguing that the bills under discussion might eventually be subject to judicial review. The Supreme Court reportedly decided against proceeding with the meeting after internal discussions among senior judges. The JPC had been informed of the initial agreement by the court, and preparations were made, including submitting materials to the court and sharing participant lists. The cancellation came amid concerns that engaging with the judiciary on these bills could lead to legal challenges.

Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives, those advocating for the meeting and those opposing it, as well as the Supreme Court’s reasoning for canceling the meeting. It does not favor one side over the other and provides context from multiple stakeholders, including the JPC chairman, the Supreme Court,

Why factuality (98): The article accurately reports the timeline of events regarding the Supreme Court's initial approval and subsequent cancellation of the meeting with the parliamentary committee. It includes specific details such as dates, names of individuals involved, and the reason given by the Supreme Court for c

Why objectivity (95): The article maintains a largely neutral tone, presenting the statements from both P P Chaudhary and the Supreme Court without overt bias. However, it does include quotes from Chaudhary defending the proposal, which slightly skews the narrative towards his perspective, though it remains mostly balanc

Times of India logoTimes of IndiaIndependentCenterFactual 97Objective 94
Supreme Court agreed to meet, then changed mind: ONOE panel chief

The Supreme Court of India initially agreed to hold an informal meeting with members of a parliamentary committee examining a bill related to simultaneous elections. However, the meeting was later canceled after some opposition Members of Parliament criticized the proposed discussion. The panel's chairperson, P P Chaudhary, stated that the Supreme Court deemed the meeting 'not appropriate' and decided to cancel it. The idea for the meeting was first proposed by DMK MP P Wilson, who argued that such interactions between parliamentary committees and Supreme Court judges were common due to their constitutional expertise. The meeting was scheduled for October 6, but the Supreme Court secretary general informed the committee of its cancellation, citing concerns that the proposed amendment could become a subject of judicial review. Chaudhary noted that the meeting was called off after public criticism arose, and he acknowledged that if the Supreme Court felt it was inappropriate, there was no need to continue pursuing the matter.

Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives, those advocating for the meeting and those opposing it, and explains the reasons behind the Supreme Court’s decision to cancel the meeting. It does not favor one side over the other and provides balanced quotes from multiple sources, including the panel's chair,

Why factuality (97): This article provides a clear account of the sequence of events involving the proposed meeting between the parliamentary committee and the Supreme Court. It correctly identifies P Wilson as the one who first proposed the meeting and accurately conveys the reasons behind the Supreme Court's decision

Why objectivity (94): The article presents the situation in a relatively neutral manner, quoting both sides of the story. However, it leans slightly more toward reporting the official stance of the Supreme Court, which could be seen as a minor bias. Overall, it remains fairly objective.

Deccan Herald logoDeccan HeraldIndependentCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 75
SC initially agreed to a meeting with JPC on ONOE but later cancelled: Panel head Chaudhary

PP Chaudhary, chairman of the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) on simultaneous elections, stated that the Supreme Court initially agreed to an informal meeting with the committee regarding the One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment Bill, 2024, but later canceled it. The cancellation followed concerns that discussing the proposed constitutional amendment could lead to judicial review. Chaudhary, a senior BJP MP, argued that parliamentary committees have precedent for consulting Supreme Court judges due to their constitutional expertise. The meeting was originally set for October 6 but was canceled after public issues arose. Chaudhary noted that the Supreme Court informed them of the cancellation, and they subsequently informed the committee members. The timeline includes several communications between the Lok Sabha Secretariat and the Supreme Court regarding the planned visit and discussions.

Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives: the Supreme Court's concern over judicial review and the JPC's argument based on precedent. It does not overtly favor either side, maintaining a balanced tone by quoting both the committee's position and the court's reasoning. The framing remains neutral, with

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (75): The article presents the information primarily through Chaudhary's perspective, who is a senior BJP MP. This may introduce a potential bias, especially since he defends the panel's actions. The tone remains mostly neutral in reporting the facts, though the inclusion of Chaudhary's defense suggests a

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories