Rosie O’Donnell described being gay as a “doomed” existence during a recent interview with Amy Poehler on the Good Hang podcast, drawing a parallel between sexual orientation and physical traits such as being left-handed or having blue eyes. The comments were part of a broader discussion about O’Donnell’s personal experiences and career, including her reflections on past relationships and her current life in Ireland. The conversation took place on a recent episode of the Ringer/Spotify podcast, hosted by Poehler, who is known for her work on Saturday Night Live. During the interview, O’Donnell recounted the emotional impact of losing her first lover, Corby, and expressed frustration over the lack of support from her family during that difficult period. O’Donnell detailed how her family did not acknowledge her grief after Corby’s passing, despite knowing she had been in a long-term relationship with her. She emphasized the isolation and loneliness she felt, describing it as a sense of being “doomed” by her identity. “It makes you feel that you’re sort of doomed by being gay, which is no different than being left-handed or having blue eyes,” she said. O’Donnell added that while being gay is not a choice, it is a true expression of self, and that it is not an easy path. She noted that many people might not choose to live as themselves, but once they do, it becomes their reality. Poehler responded positively to O’Donnell’s approach to raising her 13-year-old nonbinary child, Clay, using “they/them” pronouns consistently. She praised O’Donnell for making a conscious effort to correct others in real time, calling it “really beautiful.” This moment highlighted the evolving conversations around gender identity and the importance of language in fostering inclusivity. O’Donnell’s remarks came amid her ongoing presence in the United States, despite her relocation to Ireland in January 2025 following the re-election of President Donald Trump. She has returned to the U.S. at least twice since then, including a notable appearance at the Tony Awards in June. However, her return has been accompanied by controversy, as Trump has previously threatened, without legal justification, to revoke her U.S. citizenship. These threats have contributed to the public scrutiny surrounding O’Donnell’s decision to leave the country. Her move to Ireland was framed as a response to the political climate in the U.S., particularly the policies and rhetoric associated with Trump’s administration. While O’Donnell has maintained a presence in American media, her absence from the country has raised questions about the intersection of politics and personal safety for LGBTQ+ individuals. Despite these challenges, she continues to engage publicly on issues related to identity, acceptance, and the rights of marginalized communities. The discussion on the podcast underscored both the personal and political dimensions of O’Donnell’s life. By addressing her past struggles and current circumstances, she offered insight into the complexities of navigating identity in a society that often fails to provide adequate support. Her comparison of being gay to innate characteristics like eye color aimed to challenge perceptions of choice and destiny, emphasizing instead the authenticity of lived experience. As she continues to navigate her public life, O’Donnell’s words remain a reflection of the ongoing dialogue about identity, belonging, and resilience.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
United States
