Rosario Central issued a firm statement on Monday in response to the negative backlash over its choice of image to congratulate the Argentine national football team after their World Cup defeat to Spain. The club clarified that the photo used in its social media post did not include Lionel Messi, sparking online criticism. Users linked this decision to a desire to avoid showcasing Messi due to his past association with Newell's, a rival club. The image selected by Rosario Central for its message of congratulations featured Giovani Lo Celso, a player who emerged from the club's youth system. The club emphasized that the photograph was part of the starting lineup during the match against Jordan in the group stage, which marked Lo Celso's sole appearance as a starter in the tournament. In its communication, Rosario Central stated that the image was published without any edits, asserting its right to free expression under Article 14 of the Argentine Constitution. The club also included a photo of Messi alongside Lo Celso from the celebration following the 2022 Finalissima. Rosario Central warned that it would take legal action against individuals who have insulted the institution, describing the attacks as indiscriminate. The club expressed concern over government officials' responses to the initial tweet, including Foreign Minister Pablo Qerino, who criticized the omission of Messi and Scaloni from the photo, calling it another institutional misfortune. The club reiterated its admiration for all members of the Argentine team, particularly Messi, whom they regard as both a professional and a person, and noted their long-standing positive relationship with his family. The controversy surrounding the photo has intensified online discussions, with fans pointing out the absence of Messi in the image. Many users speculated that the omission was intentional, given the historical rivalry between Rosario Central and Newell's, where Messi began his career. This situation has reignited anger among football supporters towards Rosario Central, especially since the club became a focal point of controversy in 2025 when the Professional League awarded it a title for accumulating the most points throughout the season, despite the rulebook not stipulating such a reward. There were also suspicions that the club's president, Gonzalo Belloso, had close ties with Claudio Chiqui Tapia, the head of the Argentine Football Association. These connections were highlighted in posts showing Belloso and Cristinziano accompanying Tapia during a visit to Rosario Central's stadium. Such associations have fueled further debate about the motivations behind the club's actions and its relationships within football administration. As the situation continues to unfold, Rosario Central remains focused on defending its decisions and maintaining its stance on free expression. The club's position underscores the complex dynamics within Argentine football, where personal and institutional histories often influence public perception and reactions. The ongoing discourse reflects broader tensions between clubs, players, and governing bodies, highlighting how even seemingly minor gestures can spark significant debate.
3 reports
La NaciónIndependent🔒CenterFactual 90Objective 8013 hr. agoRosario Central, un club de fútbol argentino, emitió un comunicado oficial el lunes para defenderse de las críticas generadas por una imagen publicada en sus redes sociales. La fotografía mostraba a la selección argentina después de perder la final contra España en la Copa del Mundo, pero excluía a Lionel Messi. Los usuarios de redes sociales sugirieron que la decisión era para evitar mostrar a Messi debido a su historial como jugador del rival Newell’s. El club aclaró que la imagen fue seleccionada intencionalmente para destacar a Giovani Lo Celso, jugador nacido en las categorías inferiores del club, y que no hubo edición de la imagen. Además, Rosario Central advirtió que tomará medidas contra quienes criticaron la publicación, señalando que autoridades nacionales deben enfocarse en temas más relevantes. El comunicado también expresa respeto y admiración hacia los jugadores y técnicos de la selección, incluido Messi.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses a sports-related issue involving a football club's decision regarding image selection for a social media post. It does not involve political figures, policies, or contentious societal issues. The framing remains neutral, focusing on the club's defense against criticism and clar
Why factuality (90): This article provides a detailed account of Rosario Central's response to the criticism, including a formal statement from the club defending their choice of image. It cites specific legal provisions (Article 14 of the Argentine Constitution) and includes a quote from the club's message. The informa
Why objectivity (80): The article maintains a more neutral tone compared to the first, presenting the club's defense without overtly taking sides. While it acknowledges the public backlash, it focuses on the club's explanation and legal justification, avoiding emotionally charged language. There is a slight leaning towar
La NaciónIndependent🔒CenterFactual 85Objective 7018 hr. ago Rosario Central greeted the national team with a suggestive photo in which there is no MessiRosario Central, un club de fútbol argentino, expresó su apoyo a la selección nacional durante la Copa del Mundo mediante una fotografía en sus redes sociales. Sin embargo, la imagen mostraba a la plantilla que jugó contra Jordania, sin incluir a Lionel Messi, quien es el ícono del equipo. Esta omisión generó críticas entre los seguidores del fútbol argentino, quienes cuestionaron la decisión del club liderado por Gonzalo Belloso. Los hinchas acusaron al club de favorecer a otros jugadores como Giovani Lo Celso, mientras que algunos vincularon la acción con la relación cercana entre Belloso y el titular de la Asociación del Fútbol Argentino, Claudio Chiqui Tapia. Este incidente resalta tensiones dentro del fútbol argentino, especialmente entre clubs rivales.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses a sports-related event involving football clubs and players, which does not involve political issues or contentious policies. The framing remains neutral, focusing on the actions and reactions within the sports community without taking a clear ideological stance.
Why factuality (85): The article accurately reports the incident where Rosario Central posted a photo without Messi, leading to public backlash. It references the historical rivalry between Rosario Central and Newell’s, as well as the controversy over the team's decision to highlight Giovani Lo Celso. The article aligns
Why objectivity (70): The tone leans slightly towards criticizing Rosario Central and highlighting the public outrage, which may reflect a bias toward the fans' perspective. While the reporting is generally factual, there is some editorializing in the phrasing such as 'la situación renovó la furia de los hinchas', which
ClarínIndependentCenterFactual 60Objective 552 days agoLionel Messi shared an emotional post on social media shortly before the final match, which generated significant attention and reactions online. The post resonated strongly with fans and sparked widespread discussion across various platforms. Fans and followers responded with messages of support, admiration, and encouragement for Messi ahead of the important game. The emotional nature of the post highlighted the anticipation and significance of the upcoming match for both Messi and his supporters.
Bias read (Center): The article focuses solely on a sports-related event involving a prominent athlete, with no mention of political figures, policies, or contentious issues. The content is centered around the emotional impact of a social media post related to a football match, making it apolitical in nature.
Why factuality (60): This article appears to be incomplete or improperly formatted, as it only mentions the title and begins with 'Clarín.com'. There is no substantive content provided to assess the factual claims or verify the details of the event. As a result, it cannot be evaluated for accuracy or alignment with othe
Why objectivity (55): Due to the lack of content, it is impossible to determine the objectivity of this article. The brief mention of 'el emotivo posteo de Lionel Messi' suggests a potential focus on Messi's personal involvement, but without further information, any assessment of tone or balance is speculative.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
AR
