Raman, L.A. leaders join in condemnation after ICE officers reportedly detain two near Boyle Heights hospital
Federal immigration enforcement officers reportedly detained two individuals late Friday evening during an anti-ICE protest near Adventist White Memorial Hospital in Boyle Heights, Los Angeles. The incident prompted immediate condemnation from local political figures, including Mayor-Elect Nithya Raman, Mayor Karen Bass, and other state and city officials, who described the federal presence as frightening and inappropriate for a healthcare setting. While neither the Department of Homeland Security nor the Los Angeles Police Department officially confirmed the detentions, LAPD acknowledged that federal agents were present at the hospital. Social media videos captured by observers show officers using physical force to detain individuals, with one officer citing criminal arrest authority and alleging that a detainee had assaulted a federal agent. Community advocates and protesters expressed anger over the actions, claiming the detainees were U.S. citizens, while the article notes that numerous protesters were pushed and pepper-sprayed according to media reports.
A 21-year-old Wisconsin state trooper was released from federal custody on Friday following a detention by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents the previous day. Carel Aaron Van Der Merwe, a native of South Africa, was traveling to visit family when he was taken into custody. His attorney, Marc Christopher, described the incident as a dramatic experience for the young man. Van Der Merwe was released under an order of supervision, which requires him to check in with ICE periodically. Christopher stated that Van Der Merwe arrived in the United States with his family on a visa when he was 14 years old. The family has waited seven years for their asylum case to be heard. The trooper previously resided in New Mexico with his relatives and expressed a desire to serve in the U.S. military. However, he was unable to enlist because he lacked permanent residency. He subsequently earned a degree in criminal justice and moved to Wisconsin for employment. For the past year, he has served with the Wisconsin State Patrol. His work authorization remains valid until 2030. A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson issued a statement asserting that Van Der Merwe entered the country in March 2019 with legal permission to stay until September 2019. The spokesperson claimed that the individual overstayed his admission in defiance of national laws. The agency maintained that work authorization or a pending application does not confer legal status in the United States. Attorney Christopher rejected the government's characterization of the situation. He labeled the incident absurd and ridiculous, arguing that the trooper and his family have remained in the country lawfully. According to Christopher, the family has been waiting for their application to be adjudicated by immigration courts. Christopher said he planned to speak with Van Der Merwe to discuss future steps in his case. He advised his client to return home, settle back into routine, and recover from the traumatic event. Meanwhile, separate incidents involving federal immigration agents occurred in Los Angeles. Federal officers reportedly detained two people late Friday evening during an anti-ICE protest near Adventist White Memorial Hospital in Boyle Heights. The detentions sparked condemnation from local leaders, including Mayor-Elect Nithya Raman. Raman stated that the Trump administration is unwelcome in Los Angeles and across the country. She described the events at the hospital as an affront to the wishes of the American people. City Councilmember Ysabel Jurado and California State Senator Maria Elena Durazo also joined in condemning the actions of federal agents. Neither the Department of Homeland Security nor the Los Angeles Police Department officially confirmed the detentions to reporters. However, an LAPD spokesperson confirmed that federal agents were present at the hospital while a person in their custody received medical treatment. The police department reported that large groups had assembled at the hospital and caused a disturbance. Video footage captured by observers showed protesters confronting a line of masked immigration officers who appeared to block an ambulance entrance. In one clip, officers pinned a person to the sidewalk at the intersection of Boyle Avenue and Pennsylvania Avenue. Bystanders urged the agents to release the detainee. An officer identified by a vest reading POLICE ICE ordered onlookers to back away, stating they were impeding an arrest. Another officer told a person off-camera that their brother had assaulted a federal agent. The officer declared that the individual was being arrested for assault and would accompany the agents. Witnesses reported that numerous protesters were pushed and pepper-sprayed. Footage showed a young woman kneeling on the ground, crying, as others poured water on her face. Federal agents left the scene shortly after a priest appeared. LAPD indicated it received a second call from hospital security at approximately 2:24 a.m., alleging that about 30 protesters had breached the ambulance access area. Police responded to maintain public safety and preserve access to emergency medical services. The department stated that its officers did not participate in federal immigration enforcement or detain anyone on behalf of federal authorities. Officers made contact with the group, who cooperated and dispersed without further incident.
A 21-year-old Wisconsin state trooper, Carel Aaron Van Der Merwe, was released from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody after being detained while traveling to visit family. Van Der Merwe, who arrived from South Africa on a visa at age 14 and holds work authorization valid until 2030, was placed under an order of supervision requiring periodic check-ins. His attorney described the detention as absurd and noted that the family has been waiting seven years for their asylum case to be heard, stating they have been present lawfully while awaiting adjudication. Conversely, a Department of Homeland Security spokesperson stated that Van Der Merwe overstayed his initial admission period in violation of federal laws, emphasizing that work authorization does not confer legal status. The incident occurs amidst broader Trump administration initiatives to increase immigration enforcement, including expanded ICE operations and visa revocations.
Bias read (Center): The article presents conflicting quotes from the attorney and DHS, balancing the narrative of lawful residency with the assertion of illegal overstay without adopting either side's rhetoric.
Why factuality (85): The article accurately reflects the details provided by the attorney and includes the DHS counter-statement regarding the visa overstay. It relies on secondary reporting (NewsNation, USA Today) since no primary source was available, but the facts align with the likely consensus of such events.
Why objectivity (70): The tone is largely neutral, presenting both the attorney's perspective ('dramatic experience') and the government's stance ('defiance of laws'). However, the headline uses the word 'dramatic' in quotes, which slightly leans toward the attorney's narrative rather than maintaining strict neutrality.
Federal immigration enforcement officers reportedly detained two individuals late Friday evening during an anti-ICE protest near Adventist White Memorial Hospital in Boyle Heights, Los Angeles. The incident prompted immediate condemnation from local political figures, including Mayor-Elect Nithya Raman, Mayor Karen Bass, and other state and city officials, who described the federal presence as frightening and inappropriate for a healthcare setting. While neither the Department of Homeland Security nor the Los Angeles Police Department officially confirmed the detentions, LAPD acknowledged that federal agents were present at the hospital. Social media videos captured by observers show officers using physical force to detain individuals, with one officer citing criminal arrest authority and alleging that a detainee had assaulted a federal agent. Community advocates and protesters expressed anger over the actions, claiming the detainees were U.S. citizens, while the article notes that numerous protesters were pushed and pepper-sprayed according to media reports.
Bias read (Progressive): The article relies heavily on quotes from Democratic officials condemning the federal action and includes unverified claims from protesters regarding citizenship, omitting any counter-narrative or defense from federal authorities.
Why factuality (60): The article explicitly states that neither DHS nor LAPD confirmed the detentions, yet proceeds to describe them as having occurred based on video and local reports. This creates a gap between verified facts and the narrative presented. The reliance on unconfirmed reports lowers the factual certainty
Why objectivity (40): The piece is heavily slanted toward condemning the federal agents. Quotes from Mayor-Elect Raman and Mayor Bass use strong emotional language ('affront', 'frightening', 'unwelcome'), and the framing focuses entirely on the negative impact on the community without balancing it with any official justi
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.