A Swiss mountain guide has been convicted of multiple negligent homicide after a deadly avalanche during a ski tour in March 2023. The verdict was delivered on Friday in Thun, with the regional court imposing a conditional fine of 150 daily rates of 90 Swiss francs, totaling 13,500 francs, against the main responsible guide. A co-leader of the tour was acquitted. The incident occurred in Meiringen, in the Bernese Oberland region, involving a group of students from the Ecole d’Humanité internat school in Hasliberg. On the afternoon of March 21, 2023, the student group, accompanied by a tour guide and a mountain guide, was traveling along the Gstelliwang area. That day, the snow warning level was set at 2, indicating moderate avalanche danger. However, the bulletin warned specifically above 2,200 meters, especially on north-facing slopes, about an old snow problem. After a safe descent on the eastern side of the Gstelliwang, the group made a second run on a steeper section of the slope. There, an avalanche broke loose and carried an 18-year-old American woman and an 18-year-old British man over a several hundred-meter-high rock wall. The prosecution viewed the second descent through steep terrain as a dangerous misjudgment, leading to charges of negligent homicide and conditional fines. According to the expert report from the Snow and Avalanche Research Institute, the first route was exemplary and significantly different from the second descent, which led to the accident. The defense argued that the main guide did not notice any major difference from the first, safer route and had not observed any danger signs on-site. Therefore, they requested acquittals for both the guide and the co-leader, noting that zero risk does not exist in such activities. The legal proceedings followed a tragic event that left two young lives lost. The court’s decision reflects the gravity of the situation, acknowledging the responsibility of the guide in assessing risks during guided tours. The case highlights the complexities of managing safety in alpine environments, where even well-prepared expeditions can face unforeseen dangers. The conviction underscores the legal consequences of failing to adequately assess and mitigate risks, particularly in areas known for potential hazards. The trial brought together various stakeholders, including local authorities, environmental experts, and the families of the victims. While the exact circumstances of the avalanche and the decisions made by the guides were scrutinized, the court's ruling emphasized the need for heightened caution and professional judgment in guiding groups through potentially hazardous terrain. The outcome serves as a precedent for similar cases, reinforcing the importance of rigorous risk assessment and adherence to safety protocols in mountaineering and winter tourism. Looking ahead, the families of the deceased have expressed their hope that the case will lead to improved safety measures and better training for professionals working in high-risk environments. Meanwhile, the broader community continues to reflect on the balance between adventure and safety, urging greater awareness and preparedness in the face of natural challenges. As the legal process concludes, the focus remains on ensuring that lessons learned contribute to preventing future tragedies in the mountains.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
CH
