ON
← Back to feed
This is how a team of researchers works to turn the shadow into a right
Spain🏛️ PoliticsLean Progressive

This is how a team of researchers works to turn the shadow into a right

The article discusses the work of the Department of Umbrology, an interdisciplinary research team based in Barcelona, which explores the concept of shade as a fundamental right in urban planning. The team argues that current city designs, influenced by 19th-century sun-focused urbanism, fail to account for the need for shade during extreme heat, making public spaces uncomfortable and inaccessible. They propose interventions and policies that prioritize shade as a collective resource, emphasizing its simplicity and climate action potential. The department has developed a fictional ordinance advocating for the right to shade, aiming to push municipalities to implement similar measures. Their initiatives began with a project in 2024, transforming a concrete space into a community gathering area, leading to further exploration of shade’s social and cultural significance.

A team of researchers in Barcelona has launched an initiative aimed at transforming shade into a fundamental right, challenging the traditional design of cities that prioritize sunlight over comfort. The Department of Umbrology, based in the city, operates as an interdisciplinary group of scholars and artists who study shade through the lenses of anthropology, architecture, environmental science, and the arts. Their goal is to develop interventions and policies that make shaded public spaces more accessible and integral to urban life. The project emerged from a series of experiments conducted by the architectural collective Arquitectura de Contacte, which installed a temporary shaded space called A l'ombra del Trencadís near a school on the Rambla del Badal in 2024. Initially conceived as a climate refuge over a concrete area, this structure evolved into a community hub where people of all ages gathered, played, and rested. The success of this experiment led to further exploration, including a citizen-led investigation into how shade is used and shared within urban environments. This effort culminated in the creation of the Department of Umbrology, which was formalized through a workshop titled La ciudad de las sombras. The Department’s approach is rooted in the belief that modern cities have inherited the sun-centric planning of the 19th century, which minimized shade and exposed residents, particularly during summer, to harsh conditions. In the context of climate change, such designs are increasingly problematic, making public spaces uncomfortable and inaccessible during heatwaves. By contrast, shade is presented not merely as a comfort but as a necessity, one that fosters collective action and resilience against rising temperatures. The Department has developed a fictional ordinance titled Right to Shade, which outlines proposals intended to guide municipalities toward implementing policies that ensure equitable access to shaded areas. These include measures such as guaranteeing workers’ rights to rest in the shade, limiting private occupation of public space during extreme heat, and integrating shading solutions into urban infrastructure. While not a real legal document, the ordinance serves as a tool to pressure local governments to take action based on evidence and public demand. One of the Department’s projects focuses on agricultural communities in Lleida, where many migrant farmworkers face dangerous working conditions with little protection from the sun. In collaboration with the Institute of Global Health, they have designed portable climate shelters tailored to these workers. One prototype provides cooling, ventilation, and medical supplies for those operating heavy machinery, while another offers foldable shade integrated into staircases used by footworkers. These innovations aim to improve safety and dignity in high-risk jobs. The Department also relies on academic research, urban regulations, and participatory mapping of existing shaded areas to create a catalog that identifies and reimagines these spaces. This work seeks to shift perceptions of shade from a passive feature of the environment to an active element of urban policy and social equity. Through workshops, installations, and advocacy, the team hopes to inspire broader recognition of shade as a human right, one that can shape more livable, inclusive, and resilient cities.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

3 reports

La Vanguardia logoLa VanguardiaIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 90
Philippe Rahm, architect: The air conditioning has made passive heat solutions disappear which we now need to recover

The article features architect Philippe Rahm discussing the impact of air conditioning on urban heat management strategies. He argues that widespread reliance on air conditioning has led to the erosion of passive cooling solutions that were previously used to combat heat. Rahm emphasizes the need to revive these sustainable methods to address current and future climate challenges. The piece highlights concerns about energy consumption and environmental sustainability in architectural design. It does not present specific data or policies but focuses on expert opinion regarding urban planning and climate adaptation.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the issue through the lens of environmental sustainability and critiques the overuse of air conditioning, which aligns with progressive environmental concerns. While it does not directly reference political parties or policies, the emphasis on recovering 'passive' solutions resonb

Why factuality (85): The article reports a direct quote from architect Philippe Rahm, discussing the impact of air conditioning on passive cooling solutions. Since no primary source is available, factuality is judged based on consistency with the cross-source consensus. Both articles repeat the same quote, suggesting re

Why objectivity (90): The article presents the statement neutrally, quoting Philippe Rahm directly without adding subjective commentary or emotional language. It maintains a balanced tone by focusing solely on the architect’s perspective without editorializing.

La Vanguardia logoLa VanguardiaIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 90
Philippe Rahm, architect: The air conditioning has made passive heat solutions disappear which we now need to recover

Philippe Rahm, an architect, discusses how air conditioning has led to the disappearance of passive solutions for dealing with heat, which are now needed to be rediscovered. He highlights the importance of returning to traditional methods of cooling buildings naturally, rather than relying solely on mechanical systems. This perspective comes amid growing concerns about energy consumption and environmental impact associated with modern climate control technologies. Rahm suggests that rethinking architectural design to incorporate natural ventilation, shading, and thermal mass could offer sustainable alternatives to conventional air conditioning. His comments reflect a broader conversation about adapting urban environments to rising temperatures while reducing reliance on energy-intensive systems.

Bias read (Center): The article presents an architectural expert's opinion on environmental sustainability and building design, focusing on technical and ecological considerations rather than political positions. The framing remains neutral, emphasizing practical solutions and does not take a stance on contentious soci

Why factuality (85): This article is identical in content to the first, repeating the same quote from Philippe Rahm. As there is no primary source, factuality relies on cross-source agreement. The repetition supports the reliability of the information, though it does not add new evidence or context.

Why objectivity (90): The article remains objective by presenting only the quoted statement without introducing bias or additional interpretation. It avoids emotional language and sticks to reporting the architect’s words as given.

elDiario.es logoelDiario.esIndependentProgressiveFactual 85Objective 78
This is how a team of researchers works to turn the shadow into a right

The article discusses the work of the Department of Umbrology, an interdisciplinary research team based in Barcelona, which explores the concept of shade as a fundamental right in urban planning. The team argues that current city designs, influenced by 19th-century sun-focused urbanism, fail to account for the need for shade during extreme heat, making public spaces uncomfortable and inaccessible. They propose interventions and policies that prioritize shade as a collective resource, emphasizing its simplicity and climate action potential. The department has developed a fictional ordinance advocating for the right to shade, aiming to push municipalities to implement similar measures. Their initiatives began with a project in 2024, transforming a concrete space into a community gathering area, leading to further exploration of shade’s social and cultural significance.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the issue of urban shade access as a matter of justice and equity rather than mere comfort, aligning with progressive values. It emphasizes collective ownership and municipal responsibility, suggesting a left-leaning perspective on urban governance and climate action. The focus on

Why factuality (85): The article presents information about the Department of Umbrology based on its description as an interdisciplinary team researching shade from anthropological, architectural, environmental science, and arts perspectives. It references the project’s funding and collaborators, aligning with cross-sou

Why objectivity (78): The tone is informative and descriptive, focusing on explaining the concept and goals of the Department of Umbrology. While there is some enthusiasm for the potential impact of shade as a right, the language remains professional and avoids overt emotional appeal. However, the article frames the issu

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories