Three men were found not guilty of murdering journalist Lyra McKee in a high-profile trial at Belfast Crown Court on Friday. Jordan Devine, 25, Paul McIntyre, 58, and Peter Cavanagh, 38, were cleared of the murder of McKee, who was shot dead in 2019 while observing riots in the Creggan area of Derry. The verdict came after a lengthy trial that began in May 2024 and concluded nearly two years later. The judge, Mrs Justice Smyth, presided over the non-jury trial, which centered on whether the three men had participated in a joint enterprise with a lone gunman believed to have fired the fatal shot. McKee, 29, was killed on 18 April 2019, when she was struck by a bullet near police vehicles amid violent unrest in Derry. The New IRA, a dissident republican group, claimed responsibility for her death. Prosecutors argued that although none of the three men fired the shot that killed McKee, they had accompanied the gunman and encouraged or assisted him. However, the defense challenged the prosecution’s case, stating it relied heavily on circumstantial evidence and speculation. The judge had previously dismissed a motion to dismiss the case due to insufficient evidence. The trial drew significant attention, particularly given the prominence of McKee as a journalist and activist. Her family expressed deep disappointment with the outcome, calling it a failure of the justice system. Nichola Corner, McKee’s sister, spoke outside the courthouse after the verdict, describing it as a “complete and utter shock.” She criticized the lack of witnesses coming forward despite reports that over 150 people were present at the scene. Corner called for an end to the “culture of silence” in Northern Ireland, emphasizing the need for people to speak out even if it meant facing risks. McKee’s partner, Sara Canning, also voiced her frustration, expressing hope that the killer would be haunted by his actions. She described the gunman as “pathetic,” noting that the violence occurred while an MTV crew was filming in the area. Although the crew had left before the shooting, prosecutors suggested that the disorder had been orchestrated to coincide with their presence. Footage from the MTV team was used in court, though the crew itself was not directly implicated in the crime. The trial involved multiple charges against nine men, with all denying the allegations. One defendant has since passed away. The proceedings were marked by emotional testimony and intense scrutiny of the circumstances surrounding McKee’s death. Judge Smyth acknowledged the pain caused to McKee’s loved ones, stating that the outcome would provide little comfort or relief. She emphasized that the murder was an act of “senseless violence” and that the gunman had not yet faced justice. The case had broader implications, as McKee’s death sparked international outrage and calls for political leaders to address issues related to governance in Northern Ireland. Prominent figures such as the then-Irish president, UK prime minister, and Irish Taoiseach attended her funeral. The incident highlighted tensions within the region and raised questions about security and accountability. As the trial concluded, the focus shifted back to the unresolved issue of identifying and prosecuting the actual shooter. While the three men were cleared, the search for justice continued. McKee’s family vowed to keep pushing for answers, insisting that no effort would be spared in ensuring her legacy is honored. The case remains a poignant reminder of the challenges faced by journalists working in volatile environments and the complexities of seeking justice in regions marked by historical conflict.
6 reports
The Guardian (UK)IndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 7011 days agoThree men from Derry were found not guilty of murdering journalist Lyra McKee in 2019 during riots in Derry. McKee, 29, was killed by a gunshot while observing the unrest. The New IRA claimed responsibility for the attack. During a lengthy trial in Belfast Crown Court, the men were cleared of murder charges, though prosecutors argued they were involved in a joint enterprise to assist the shooter. The defense criticized the prosecution's reliance on speculation, and the judge previously ruled there was enough evidence to proceed. McKee's family expressed deep disappointment, calling the outcome a failure of the justice system and demanding an end to the 'culture of silence' in Northern Ireland. The judge acknowledged the tragedy and regretted the lack of progress in identifying the killer.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the judicial outcome without overt ideological slant, focusing on the legal proceedings and the emotional response from McKee's family. While the family's frustration reflects broader societal tensions in Northern Ireland, the reporting does not favor one political perspective.
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 70): Highly factual, accurately reporting the verdict and details of the case. Objectivity is lower due to the inclusion of emotional quotes from Nichola Corner expressing shock and frustration with the justice system.
Daily MirrorIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 8511 days agoThree men—Paul McIntyre, Peter Cavanagh, and Jordan Gareth Devine—were found not guilty of the murder of journalist Lyra McKee, who was shot during unrest in Londonderry in 2019. McKee, 29, was killed after four shots were fired toward police during chaotic scenes involving petrol bombs and a burning car. The New IRA claimed responsibility for her death. The trio faced charges of aiding a lone gunman, but none were accused of pulling the trigger. The defense criticized the prosecution’s reliance on circumstantial and speculative evidence, and the defendants showed little reaction to the verdict. McKee’s family called the outcome a failure of justice.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the legal outcome of the trial without overtly endorsing any political stance. It reports the verdict, the prosecution’s claims, and the defense’s criticisms neutrally. While the case involves politically sensitive issues related to violence and security in Northern Ireland, the
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 85): Reports the verdict and case details accurately. Includes additional context about the incident and the defense arguments. Objectivity is slightly lower due to emphasis on the family's reaction.
The IndependentIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 7511 days agoThree men were found not guilty of murdering journalist Lyra McKee in Northern Ireland during a non-jury trial at Belfast Crown Court. Lyra McKee, 29, was killed in April 2019 when she was shot near police vehicles during disturbances in Londonderry. Her sister, Nichola Corner, expressed deep disappointment with the legal process and criticized the 'culture of silence' in Northern Ireland, noting that over 150 witnesses did not come forward with evidence. The accused, Paul McIntyre, Peter Cavanagh, and Jordan Gareth Devine, faced a joint enterprise murder charge but were acquitted. The case has been ongoing for several years, and the McKee family remains determined to seek justice.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the facts of the trial and includes direct quotes from both the McKee family and the legal proceedings. It does not exhibit overtly biased language, one-sided sourcing, or editorializing. The framing appears balanced, focusing on the outcome of the trial and the reactions of the
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 75): Accurately reports the case and verdict, including the role of MTV footage. Objectivity is slightly affected by the focus on the emotional impact on the family and the courtroom atmosphere.
Sky News (UK)IndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 7512 days agoThree men were acquitted of the murder of journalist Lyra McKee in Northern Ireland. The verdict was reached by a court, concluding that the prosecution did not meet the required standard of proof. The case has raised questions about the safety of journalists in conflict zones and the legal processes involved in such high-profile cases. The outcome highlights the complexities of prosecuting violent crimes under local laws.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the judicial outcome without overtly favoring any political stance. It focuses on the legal decision rather than taking a position on the broader implications of the case, which involves both legal and political dimensions related to journalism and security in Northern Ireland.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 75): Facts are presented clearly and accurately, including the date, location, and outcome of the case. Objectivity is somewhat reduced by the inclusion of family reactions and the emphasis on the justice system's failure.
BBC News (UK)State / PublicCenterFactual 85Objective 8011 days agoThree men were found not guilty of the murder of journalist Lyra McKee during a non-jury trial in Northern Ireland that lasted over a year. The prosecution relied partly on footage from MTV, which was recorded in Derry on the day of the killing, though the camera crew had already left the scene before the shooting occurred. During the trial, video showed interactions between MTV presenter Reggie Yates and some of the defendants. The prosecution argued that the unrest that erupted was intentionally timed to coincide with MTV's presence, suggesting involvement by dissident republicans. The trial, which began in May 2024 and concluded in April, was noted as one of the longest in recent Northern Irish legal history. The accused did not testify and denied all charges.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the trial outcomes and related facts neutrally, without overtly favoring any side. It includes both the prosecution’s claims and the defense’s stance, providing balanced context without apparent ideological framing.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 80): Factual content is solid, covering the main points of the verdict and case. Objectivity is maintained well with minimal emotional language, though it lacks some contextual details present in other sources.
BBC News (UK)State / PublicCenterFactual 85Objective 759 days ago Partner of journalist Lyra McKee hopes her death haunts her killerThe partner of journalist Lyra McKee expressed her anguish over the acquittal of three men accused of her murder, stating she hopes the killer is haunted by their actions. Lyra McKee was shot and killed on 18 April 2019 during riots in Londonderry, Northern Ireland. Three men—Paul McIntyre, Peter Cavanagh, and Jordan Devine—were found not guilty of her murder in a trial that lasted nearly two years. Sara Canning, Lyra’s former partner, criticized the gunman for 'showing off' for cameras rather than acting for any ideological cause. She stated she knows who the killer is but believes achieving justice requires either a change of heart or new evidence. The incident occurred amid ongoing unrest linked to dissident republican groups, including the New IRA, which claimed responsibility for the killing.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Sara Canning's emotional statements and provides factual details about the trial and circumstances surrounding Lyra McKee's death. It includes direct quotes from Canning and references the legal outcome without overtly favoring one side. The framing remains balanced, focusing on
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 75): Factual accuracy is high, reporting the events and verdict correctly. However, the article includes subjective statements from Sara Canning, such as calling the killer 'pathetic,' which may introduce bias. Objectivity is somewhat compromised by the emotional language used in quoting Sara Canning.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
United Kingdom
